Law Report: Legal expenses insurer need not pay costs

Law Report: 6 December 1996

Murphy and another v Young & Co's Brewery plc and another; Court of Appeal (Lady Justice Butler-Sloss, Lord Justice Phillips, Sir John Balcombe) 20 November 1996

An order for costs against a non-party, such as the legal expenses insurers of an unsuccessful plaintiff, should only be ordered where exceptional circumstances made it reasonable and just to do so. The mere fact that the insurers had funded the litigation under a commercial agreement was not enough to justify such an order.

The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the first defendant, Young & Co's Brewery plc, against the refusal of Mr Griffiths- Williams QC, sitting as a deputy High Court judge on 9 May 1995, to order the second defendant, Sun Alliance & London Insurance plc, to pay the first defendant's costs of an action brought against it by the plaintiffs, Daniel Joseph Murphy and Christine Anne Murphy.

The Murphys were employed by Youngs to manage a public house. Youngs dismissed them for breach of duty. The Murphys brought an action for wrongful dismissal. Their claim was dismissed and Youngs were awarded pounds 16,000 on their counterclaim together with almost all the costs, taxed at pounds 42,806.

The Murphys were insured by Sun Alliance under the American Express Legal Expenses plan. Their limit of cover in respect of any one claim was pounds 25,000. They exhausted their right to indemnity in respect of this action, their own expenses having exceeded that limit. In these circumstances Sun Alliance denied any liability to meet Young's costs in the event of the Murphys being unable to do so.

Andrew Hillier (Druces & Attlee) for Youngs; Stuart Isaacs QC and Neil Calver (Osborne Clarke) for Sun Alliance.

Lord Justice Phillips said that the jurisdiction provided by section 51(1) of the Supreme Court Act 1981, under which costs "shall be in the discretion of the court, and the court shall have full power to determine by whom and to what extent the costs are to be paid", was not subject (as had been believed) to an implied limitation that costs could only be awarded against those who were parties to the litigation: see Aiden Shipping Co Ltd v Interbulk Ltd [1986] AC 965.

However, an order for the payment of costs by a non-party would always be exceptional. The ultimate question was what was reasonable and just on the facts of the individual case.

In Chapman Ltd v Christopher (unreported; 23 May 1996) the plaintiffs recovered damages in excess of pounds 1m from an impecunious defendant who was covered against liability for damages and costs up to pounds 1m under his mother's household policy with Sun Alliance. Judge Zucker QC ordered Sun Alliance to pay the plaintiffs' costs.

But it would not always be appropriate to order liability insurers to pay the plaintiff's costs where they had unsuccessfully defended a claim against their insured if the result would be to render them liable beyond their contractual limit of cover.

In this case, Sun Alliance had funded the Murphys' litigation under a commercial agreement, but that seemed the only ground that could validly be advanced for ordering Sun Alliance to pay Youngs' costs. In particular:

1) Sun Alliance had no interest in the result, save insofar as this affected their liability to pay costs.

2) Sun Alliance did not initiate the litigation. They were contractually bound to fund it up to the limit of pounds 25,000 and would have been better off if the litigation had never commenced.

3) Sun Alliance exercised no control over the conduct of the litigation.

4) Sun Alliance could not be accused of "wanton and officious intermeddling" in the dispute.

Legal expenses insurance was in the public interest, particularly if it was on the terms of the cover in this case.

An order under section 51 that a non-party pay costs would only be justified when exceptional circumstances made such an order reasonable and just. This case did not fall within any of the categories of exceptional circumstances that might justify such an order.

The existence of legal expense insurance with a limit of cover that had been exhausted did not make it reasonable or just to order the insurer to pay the costs of the adverse successful party.

Paul Magrath, Barrister

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs People

Ashdown Group: Human Resources Manager

£28000 - £35000 per annum + Benefits: Ashdown Group: A successful organisation...

Recruitment Genius: Internal Recruiter - Manufacturing

£20000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An Internal Recruiter (manufact...

Ashdown Group: HR Manager (CIPD) - Barking / East Ham - £50-55K

£50000 - £55000 per annum + 25 days holidays & benefits: Ashdown Group: HR Man...

Recruitment Genius: Operations / Project Manager

£40000 - £48000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This software company specialis...

Day In a Page

Isis profits from destruction of antiquities by selling relics to dealers - and then blowing up the buildings they come from to conceal the evidence of looting

How Isis profits from destruction of antiquities

Robert Fisk on the terrorist group's manipulation of the market to increase the price of artefacts
Labour leadership: Andy Burnham urges Jeremy Corbyn voters to think again in last-minute plea

'If we lose touch we’ll end up with two decades of the Tories'

In an exclusive interview, Andy Burnham urges Jeremy Corbyn voters to think again in last-minute plea
Tunisia fears its Arab Spring could be reversed as the new regime becomes as intolerant of dissent as its predecessor

The Arab Spring reversed

Tunisian protesters fear that a new law will whitewash corrupt businessmen and officials, but they are finding that the new regime is becoming as intolerant of dissent as its predecessor
King Arthur: Legendary figure was real and lived most of his life in Strathclyde, academic claims

Academic claims King Arthur was real - and reveals where he lived

Dr Andrew Breeze says the legendary figure did exist – but was a general, not a king
Who is Oliver Bonas and how has he captured middle-class hearts?

Who is Oliver Bonas?

It's the first high-street store to pay its staff the living wage, and it saw out the recession in style
Earth has 'lost more than half its trees' since humans first started cutting them down

Axe-wielding Man fells half the world’s trees – leaving us just 422 each

However, the number of trees may be eight times higher than previously thought
60 years of Scalextric: Model cars are now stuffed with as much tech as real ones

60 years of Scalextric

Model cars are now stuffed with as much tech as real ones
Theme parks continue to draw in thrill-seekers despite the risks - so why are we so addicted?

Why are we addicted to theme parks?

Now that Banksy has unveiled his own dystopian version, Christopher Beanland considers the ups and downs of our endless quest for amusement
Tourism in Iran: The country will soon be opening up again after years of isolation

Iran is opening up again to tourists

After years of isolation, Iran is reopening its embassies abroad. Soon, there'll be the chance for the adventurous to holiday there
10 best PS4 games

10 best PS4 games

Can’t wait for the new round of blockbusters due out this autumn? We played through last year’s offering
Transfer window: Ten things we learnt

Ten things we learnt from the transfer window

Record-breaking spending shows FFP restraint no longer applies
Migrant crisis: UN official Philippe Douste-Blazy reveals the harrowing sights he encountered among refugees arriving on Lampedusa

‘Can we really just turn away?’

Dead bodies, men drowning, women miscarrying – a senior UN figure on the horrors he has witnessed among migrants arriving on Lampedusa, and urges politicians not to underestimate our caring nature
Nine of Syria and Iraq's 10 world heritage sites are in danger as Isis ravages centuries of history

Nine of Syria and Iraq's 10 world heritage sites are in danger...

... and not just because of Isis vandalism
Girl on a Plane: An exclusive extract of the novelisation inspired by the 1970 Palestinian fighters hijack

Girl on a Plane

An exclusive extract of the novelisation inspired by the 1970 Palestinian fighters hijack
Why Frederick Forsyth's spying days could spell disaster for today's journalists

Why Frederick Forsyth's spying days could spell disaster for today's journalists

The author of 'The Day of the Jackal' has revealed he spied for MI6 while a foreign correspondent