Richard Dawkins offers half apology over those Down syndrome comments: 'Half the problem lies in a wanton eagerness to misunderstand'

The scientist attempts to clarify his “contentious” views in a statement

Richard Dawkins has addressed the “feeding frenzy” that arose after he said that it was “immoral” to give birth to a baby with Down syndrome if the mother was aware of the child’s condition.

Responding to a “real ethical dilemma” of one his Twitter users, who said she wouldn’t know what to do if she “were pregnant with a kid with Down syndrome”, Dawkins offered his controversial view.

“Abort it and try again,” he tweeted. “It would be immoral to bring it into the world if you have the choice.”

Unsurprisingly, his comments provoked “hate tweets” and the scientist has since published an apology of sorts, in which he is very sorry if he offended anyone with his “logical” opinion.

It wasn’t his view that was wrong, he says, more the public’s “wanton eagerness to misunderstand”.

"What I was saying simply follows logically from the ordinary pro-choice stance that most us, I presume, espouse,” he wrote. “My phraseology may have been tactlessly vulnerable to misunderstanding, but I can’t help feeling that at least half the problem lies in a wanton eagerness to misunderstand.”

The lengthy tome begins with a definition of Down syndrome, helpfully pointing out that parents who have a child with the genetic condition “usually” grow to form attachments to their son or daughter.

“Parents who care for their children with Down Syndrome usually form strong bonds of affection with them, as they would with any child,” he said. “These feelings are sincere and mutual, and probably account for some of the hate tweets I have been experiencing.”

He goes onto say that “most doctors recommend” abortion when Down Syndrome is detected – although offers no statistics to support the statement – before clarifying that his tweets were meant as private messages, rather than public.

The limited 140 characters meant he was unable to offer his full take on the issue, which he rectifies in a lengthier format. While he wouldn’t “dream of imposing my views on you”, he reiterates the same sentiment – that the “moral and sensible” choice is to abort a child with the condition.

“For what it’s worth, my own choice would be to abort the Down fetus and, assuming you want a baby at all, try again,” he wrote. “Given a free choice of having an early abortion or deliberately bringing a Down child into the world, I think the moral and sensible choice would be to abort. And, indeed, that is what the great majority of women, in America and especially in Europe, actually do. 

“I personally would go further and say that, if your morality is based, as mine is, on a desire to increase the sum of happiness and reduce suffering, the decision to deliberately give birth to a Down baby, when you have the choice to abort it early in the pregnancy, might actually be immoral from the point of view of the child’s own welfare.”

He then attempts to break down the reasons as to why anyone could have possibly been offended by his views.

The “haters”, as he describes, comprise: those whom are categorically against abortion; those who thought he was dictating to women how to act; those who thought he was “advocating a mob rule”; those who believe he was supporting a “eugenic policy” and, finally, those who raised an “emotional point” because they know and love a person with Down syndrome.

“I have sympathy for this emotional point, but it is an emotional one not a logical one,” he wrote in defence. “It is one of a common family of errors, one that frequently arises in the abortion debate.”

He also name checks two of his works.

The long and short of it is, those who disagree or have been offended have simply been confused by his “tactlessly vulnerable to misunderstanding” comments.

READ MORE:RICHARD DAWKINS ON DATE RAPE V STRANGER RAPE
WOMEN AT CENTRE OF ABORTION CASE FORCED TO GIVE BIRTH
DAWKINS' BIN LADEN COMMENT SPARKS TWITTER HASHTAG
PROMOTED VIDEO
News
ebooksNow available in paperback
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs People

h2 Recruit Ltd: Business Development Manager - HR Consultancy - £65,000 OTE

£35000 - £40000 per annum + £65,000 OTE: h2 Recruit Ltd: London, Birmingham, M...

Day In a Page

Homeless Veterans appeal: 'It took a lot of help for me to find my voice'

Homeless Veterans appeal

Ex-soldier Michael Crossan was able to get off the streets and develop his skills as an artist thanks to Veterans Aid
Building a British naval base in Bahrain is a 'symbolic choice' – for no clear reason

Building a British naval base in Bahrain is a 'symbolic choice' – for no clear reason

The authoritarian kingdom where doctors are tortured is a strange place for this £15m investment, says Patrick Cockburn
Smart farmers call in the gleaners: Volunteers are salvaging crops that supermarkets refuse to take – and giving them to food charities

Smart farmers call in the gleaners

Volunteers are salvaging crops that supermarkets refuse to take – and giving them to food charities
Shmuley Boteach: Sex, Sainsbury's, celebrity... and anti-Semitism

Shmuley Boteach: Sex, Sainsbury's, celebrity... and anti-Semitism

The self-proclaimed 'Rabbi of America', says Britain has grown worryingly anti-Israel – and he wants us to listen to him
The best and worst restaurants of 2014: From delicious dishes and sensational service to eating in the dark and bullies in the kitchen

The best and worst restaurants of 2014

From delicious dishes and sensational service to eating in the dark and bullies in the kitchen
Britain branches out: Shoppers reject imported Christmas trees in favour of home-grown ones

Britain branches out

Shoppers reject imported Christmas trees in favour of home-grown ones
Stephen Hawking right about dangers of AI... but for the wrong reasons, says eminent computer expert

Stephen Hawking right about dangers of AI...

... but for the wrong reasons, says eminent computer expert
Ed Harris: The actor on painting houses, smashing chairs and learning not to be so terse

Ed Harris opens up

The actor on painting houses, smashing chairs and learning not to be so terse
Eric Garner 'chokehold' death: A grand jury blind to the evidence before it

A grand jury blind to the evidence before it

The decision not to bring charges after the death of a black man in police custody suggests a fatal flaw in the system, says Rupert Cornwell
Oh, what a circus Jeremy Thorpe's Liberals were...

Oh, what a circus Jeremy Thorpe's Liberals were...

The Seventies' party was quite unlike its modern successor. It really believed in pluralism and tolerance, says DJ Taylor
The 12 food trends of Christmas: From mince-pie cocktails to deep-fried crackling

The 12 food trends of Christmas

Flavourless white turkey and mushy sprouts with a cava chaser? No more! Make this year’s celebrations the foodiest ever...
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef banishes the grey-sky blues with his soul-warming Asian feast

Bill Granger's Asian feast

From sticky ribs to earthy shiitake, our chef likes to see off the cold weather with steaming bowls of Asian comfort food
Southampton vs Manchester United: Why Ronald Koeman and Louis van Gaal will never be friends

Why Koeman and Van Gaal will never be friends

As the Dutch managers prepare to go head to head in the Premier League, Miguel Delaney explores their relationship
The Last Word: Candidate Sebastian Coe must demand that doping is a criminal offence

Michael Calvin's Last Word

Candidate Coe must demand that doping is a criminal offence
Al-Jazeera journalists imprisoned by Egypt to ‘teach Qatar a lesson’ for supporting the Muslim Brotherhood

Al-Jazeera journalists imprisoned by Egypt to ‘teach Qatar a lesson’

Mohamed Fahmy, one of three reporters held in a Cairo prison, has written to Robert Fisk to outline his grievances against his employers