Wednesday Law Report: Inconsistency alone is not abuse of process

17 March 1999 Bradford & Bingley Building Society v Seddon (Hancock and others as third parties) Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Nourse, Lord Justice Auld and Lord Justice Ward) 11 March 1999

INCONSISTENCY BETWEEN third party proceedings and an earlier claim made by the defendant against one of the third parties was not, without more, sufficient to justify the striking out of the third party proceedings as an abuse of process.

The Court of Appeal allowed the defendant's appeal against an order striking out as an abuse of process his third party proceedings against the three third parties on the ground that they were inconsistent with a claim made by the defendant against the first third party in an earlier action.

The defendant had claimed damages for negligence and/or an indemnity against Mr Hancock, an accountant, in respect of a failed investment which Mr Hancock had advised him to fund by taking a mortgage loan from the plaintiff building society. Mr Hancock had admitted liability under the indemnity.

The defendant had entered judgment for the admitted sum, but had been unable to enforce the judgment against Mr Hancock as the latter had no money. As a result, the defendant owed the building society over pounds 180,000. When the building society instituted proceedings against him for possession of his mortgaged home, he sought by third party proceedings to revive the unsatisfied claim against Mr Hancock and to include in it two of his partners, Mr Walsh and Mr Rhodes.

The defendant expressed the third party claim in broader terms than the earlier action, seeking against all three third parties an indemnity against or contribution towards his liability to the building society and damages in respect of their failure to indemnify him and/or in negligence and/or for misrepresentation.

The third parties successfully applied to strike out the third party claim as an abuse of process. It was the judge's view that the third party proceedings were inconsistent with the earlier claim made by the defendant against Mr Hancock. The defendant appealed.

Michael Black QC (Putsmans, Birmingham) for the defendant; Mark Halliwell (Oldham Rust Jobson, Stafford) for Walsh; Philip Raynor QC (Lyons Wilson, Manchester) for Rhodes.

Lord Justice Auld said that it was important to distinguish clearly between res judicata and abuse of process not qualifying as res judicata. Abuse of process might arise where there had been no earlier decision capable of amounting to res judicata.

Mere re-litigation, in circumstances which did not give rise to cause of action or issue estoppel, did not necessarily amount to abuse of process. Equally, the maintenance of a second claim which could have been part of an earlier one, or which conflicted with an earlier one, should not per se be regarded as an abuse of process.

Some additional element was required, such as a collateral attack on a previous decision; some dishonesty; or successive actions amounting to unjust harassment. It followed that, in a case of re- litigation falling short of res judicata, the onus should be on the person alleging abuse of process to establish what made the further litigation an abuse.

The question in the present case was whether the obtaining of the earlier judgment against Mr Hancock, which was arguably inconsistent with some but not all of the allegations made in the third party proceedings, was an abuse of process in the circumstances. The judge appeared to have considered that inconsistency alone was enough to justify a finding of abuse.

He should, however, have been more hesitant before striking out the third party claim on a conclusion of inconsistency based on his construction of what were arguably equivocal pleadings and disposal by the court in the earlier action. More importantly, he should have looked beyond the inconsistency which he had found, and should have considered whether Mr Walsh and Mr Rhodes had shown that it and the other differences between the two claims made the third party claim in all the circumstances an abuse of the process.

Suggested Topics
Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
SPONSORED FEATURES
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs People

Recruitment Genius: Internal Recruiter - Manufacturing

£20000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An Internal Recruiter (manufact...

Ashdown Group: HR Manager (CIPD) - Barking / East Ham - £50-55K

£50000 - £55000 per annum + 25 days holidays & benefits: Ashdown Group: HR Man...

Recruitment Genius: Operations / Project Manager

£40000 - £48000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This software company specialis...

Ashdown Group: Human Resources Manager

£28000 - £35000 per annum + Benefits: Ashdown Group: A successful organisation...

Day In a Page

The Silk Roads that trace civilisation: Long before the West rose to power, Asian pathways were connecting peoples and places

The Silk Roads that trace civilisation

Long before the West rose to power, Asian pathways were connecting peoples and places
House of Lords: Outcry as donors, fixers and MPs caught up in expenses scandal are ennobled

The honours that shame Britain

Outcry as donors, fixers and MPs caught up in expenses scandal are ennobled
When it comes to street harassment, we need to talk about race

'When it comes to street harassment, we need to talk about race'

Why are black men living the stereotypes and why are we letting them get away with it?
International Tap Festival: Forget Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers - this dancing is improvised, spontaneous and rhythmic

International Tap Festival comes to the UK

Forget Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers - this dancing is improvised, spontaneous and rhythmic
War with Isis: Is Turkey's buffer zone in Syria a matter of self-defence – or just anti-Kurd?

Turkey's buffer zone in Syria: self-defence – or just anti-Kurd?

Ankara accused of exacerbating racial division by allowing Turkmen minority to cross the border
Doris Lessing: Acclaimed novelist was kept under MI5 observation for 18 years, newly released papers show

'A subversive brothel keeper and Communist'

Acclaimed novelist Doris Lessing was kept under MI5 observation for 18 years, newly released papers show
Big Blue Live: BBC's Springwatch offshoot swaps back gardens for California's Monterey Bay

BBC heads to the Californian coast

The Big Blue Live crew is preparing for the first of three episodes on Sunday night, filming from boats, planes and an aquarium studio
Austin Bidwell: The Victorian fraudster who shook the Bank of England with the most daring forgery the world had known

Victorian fraudster who shook the Bank of England

Conman Austin Bidwell. was a heartless cad who carried out the most daring forgery the world had known
Car hacking scandal: Security designed to stop thieves hot-wiring almost every modern motor has been cracked

Car hacking scandal

Security designed to stop thieves hot-wiring almost every modern motor has been cracked
10 best placemats

Take your seat: 10 best placemats

Protect your table and dine in style with a bold new accessory
Ashes 2015: Alastair Cook not the only one to be caught in The Oval mindwarp

Cook not the only one to be caught in The Oval mindwarp

Aussie skipper Michael Clarke was lured into believing that what we witnessed at Edgbaston and Trent Bridge would continue in London, says Kevin Garside
Can Rafael Benitez get the best out of Gareth Bale at Real Madrid?

Can Benitez get the best out of Bale?

Back at the club he watched as a boy, the pressure is on Benitez to find a winning blend from Real's multiple talents. As La Liga begins, Pete Jenson asks if it will be enough to stop Barcelona
Athletics World Championships 2015: Beijing witnesses new stage in the Jessica Ennis-Hill and Katarina Johnson-Thompson heptathlon rivalry

Beijing witnesses new stage in the Jess and Kat rivalry

The last time the two British heptathletes competed, Ennis-Hill was on the way to Olympic gold and Johnson-Thompson was just a promising teenager. But a lot has happened in the following three years
Jeremy Corbyn: Joining a shrewd operator desperate for power as he visits the North East

Jeremy Corbyn interview: A shrewd operator desperate for power

His radical anti-austerity agenda has caught the imagination of the left and politically disaffected and set a staid Labour leadership election alight
Isis executes Palmyra antiquities chief: Defender of ancient city's past was killed for protecting its future

Isis executes Palmyra antiquities chief

Robert Fisk on the defender of the ancient city's past who was killed for protecting its future