The Titanic's flamboyant owner, the celebrity chef Marco Pierre White, is accused by Oliver Peyton, who runs the Atlantic, of trying to entice the same wealthy clientele with a similarly imposing art-deco style in the same building, the Regent Palace Hotel near Piccadilly Circus, central London.
Mr Peyton is suing his landlord, Posthouse Hotels and Forte, and Mr Pierre White's company, MPW Criterion, fordamages and seeking an injunction. He claims that such competition should not be allowed under the terms of his lease.
The legal action is the culmination of a friction that began with the glittering opening of the Titanic last December.
At the High Court in London yesterday, Nicholas Dowding, QC, acting for Mr Peyton, told Mr Justice Rattee that a covenant in Mr Peyton's underlease barred his landlords from allowing a competing business on the premises, with the proviso that nothing should prevent the landlords from carrying on their trade as hoteliers, restaurateurs and caterers.
The judge said he was "extremely puzzled" because the covenant and the proviso appeared to be contradictory. The hearing continues.