Cyberclinic: My Wikipedia entry keeps being changed – what can I do about it?
Wednesday 05 September 2007
Latest in Science
Related articles
On Facebook
From the blogs
Why David Cameron owes unemployed single mothers an apology
How would you describe an unemployed single mother, with moderate depression, who can't afford new s...
Can we shop our way out of a recession?
The idea that a lot of shopping translates into a healthy economy is dubious. On the three prior oc...
How social networking made public vanity acceptable
When did it become acceptable to brag about oneself publicly?
‘French beer is unknown. We must change that’
Stereotypes die hard. ‘The Very Hungry Frenchman’, the BBC’s current television series following che...
Before we get to Wikipedia, those who read last Thursday's account of my attempt at internet pop stardom will be thrilled to hear that the video for my single "Those Rules" has now been watched by more than a quarter of a million people on YouTube.
I'm still waiting to see if the miserable sales figure of 58 has been boosted by generous readers of this newspaper but, in the meantime, an ex-pat radio station in Spain has been playing it, and apparently it's a hit with drinkers at The Stagecoach Inn in Newport, Gloucestershire. Every little helps.
Now, on to Wikipedia. The online encyclopedia, which anyone can add to and edit, persistently appears at the top of Google's search results when we're looking for information. Despite this, we're also told – particularly by the traditional media – to take its contents with a pinch of salt. Independent studies have shown that it stands up pretty well against traditional encyclopedias, but it's difficult to take it seriously when I could go there right now and claim that Marvin Gaye is alive and well and living in Sutton Coldfield.
While vandalism on Wikipedia is common, it doesn't tend to stay online for very long – thanks to a core of devoted, eagle-eyed editors. But genuine disputes over facts and editorial style can become extremely protracted. "For a good example of furious squabbling," writes Martin Connolly, " check out the 'discussion' tab on the entry about Gdansk, with Germans and Poles at each other's throats."
Wikipedia encourages vigorous debate, in the hope that better articles will emerge from the process. "But if your opinions don't reflect a broad consensus," writes Richard Miller, "your edits may be removed quite legitimately. If this is the case, you should try to reach a compromise."
In the cases where arguments continue to rage, Wikipedia provides mediation, followed by full-scale arbitration. In these situations you'll frequently see "protected" pages which have been closed for editing while a resolution is worked out. You might find the list of most pointless Wikipedia clashes (at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WP:LEW) something of an eye-opener. If you can resolve these disputes it is your duty, as a Wikipedian, to weigh in.
Diagnosis required
Next week's question comes from Dan Stojanovic:
"People keep telling me about all the stuff they've found on the internet using BitTorrent. It's still a mystery to me – how does it work?"
Any comments, and new questions for the Cyberclinic, should be emailed to cyberclinic@independent.co.uk
- 1 Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged
- 2 The Sun on Sunday to launch soon, says Rupert Murdoch
- 3 Vatican told to pay taxes as Italy tackles budget crisis
- 4 Greeks rage at erosion of sovereignty while leaders haggle over deal
- 5 Prehistoric cybermen? Sardinia's lost warriors rise from the dust
- 6 Facebook hacker is jailed for eight months
- 7 Blizzards to batter UK again
- 1 WikiLeaks takes aim at an unlikely new victim: Unesco
- 2 Prehistoric cybermen? Sardinia's lost warriors rise from the dust
- 3 Employers reject jobs scheme that's all work and no pay
- 4 Robert Fisk: I've lost a good, brave, honourable friend
- 5 Vatican told to pay taxes as Italy tackles budget crisis
- 6 Administrators set to meet with Rangers squad
- 7 Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged
- 8 'My 10 days at an Eton summer school was a real shock to the system'
- 9 Spotify: 1 million plays, £108 return
- 10 The artist vandalising advertising with poetry
Free trial of new Independent iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Win a family adventure for four in the new Subaru XV
Enjoy a three-nights family adventure at Slaley Hall Resort, Northumberland courtesy to Subaru XV
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
Inside the tiny town that will topple Sarkozy
Claire Foy: Criticism, tumours and embarrassing sex scenes
Wilderness and wildlife in Australia’s Top End
48 Hours: Marrakech




Comments