The hobbit: was it a work of fiction?

The three-foot tall creature was hailed as a new species of human. Now research casts doubt on the claim. By Steve Connor

It is either the most important discovery in human evolution for decades, or one of the biggest blunders of modern science - and there's not much room for anything in between.

She was either a new species of miniature "Hobbit-like" human, just three feet tall, who lived 18,000 years ago on a remote Indonesian island among giant rats, pygmy elephants and massive, dragon-like reptiles. Or she was just another member of our own species - Homo sapiens - who was unfortunate enough to suffer from a severe congenital disorder that meant she developed an unusually small braincase, stunted body and shortened limbs.

If the latter is ever proved to be the case, it will come as a huge embarrassment to the scientists behind a study published in the journal Nature in 2004, claiming that Homo floresiensis truly represents a new species of miniature human being.

The latest salvo in the dispute over the bones has come in a study published in the current issue of the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, which backs up claims that the "hobbit" is nothing more than a small-brained member of our own species.

The authors of the study claim that the original assessment of the remains was wrong, and that there is no evidence for the existence of a miniature species of human who hunted pygmy rats and who was in turn hunted by giant Komodo dragons.

The dispute over the bones of the "hobbit" broke out almost as soon as the details of its existence emerged in a groundbreaking piece of research that, it is fair to say, set the world of palaeo-anthropology alight.

A team of Indonesian and Australian scientists had found a partial skeleton of a creature they labelled LB1, the first human from Liang Bua cave on the island of Flores.

What was unique and utterly amazing about the individual - apparently an adult female, although the original artist's impression that accompanied the research, right, was drawn depicting a male - was that she must have lived with a skull containing a braincase no bigger than a grapefruit - about a third of the size of that of modern-day humans. She would have also stood barely three feet high.

Being this height is not in itself unusual. Some modern-day pygmies are this height, a dwarfism that results from lacking the typical adolescent growth spurt of non-pygmy humans. But the head size - and braincases - of modern pygmies still fall within the normal range of the other members of Homo sapiens.

But the "hobbit", as the female at Liang Bua cave was nicknamed, had a far smaller head that was more in proportion with her body.

Professor Mike Morwood of the University of New South Wales in Armidale, a leading member of the team, said at the time that he could not believe what he and his colleagues had found - especially given that the carbon dating pointed to the creatures still living on Flores as recently as 13,000 years ago.

"It is a new species of human who actually lived alongside us, yet were half our size. They were the height of a three-year-old child, weighed around 25 kilos [4 stones] and had a brain smaller than most chimpanzees," Professor Morwood said in 2004.

"Even so, they used fire, made sophisticated stone tools and hunted stegadon - a primitive type of elephant - and giant rats. We believe that their ancestors may have reached the island using bamboo rafts. The clear implication is that, despite tiny brains, these little humans were intelligent and almost certainly had language," Professor Morwood said.

For evolutionary biologists, the discovery pointed to the first case of endemic island dwarfism in humans. Animals isolated on a remote island can evolve into giants - like the Flores rat - or pygmies, such as the stegadon.

"Although a common feature of large mammals in insular environments, this has never been recorded for a human relative before," said Peter Brown of the University of New England, another leading member of the team.

Archaeological evidence suggests that the Liang Bua cave was inhabited by early humans of some description for about 800,000 years.

Archaeologists have also found relatively sophisticated stone tools in the cave that appear similar to those made at other sites in the world by an earlier species of human called Homo erectus. However, the crucial difference between Homo erectus tools and those at Liang Bua is that the Flores cave artifacts are far smaller - suggesting that they were honed by the tiny hands of the miniature humans.

"Finding these hominins on an isolated island in Asia, and with elements of modern human behaviour in tool-making and hunting, is truly remarkable and could not have been predicted by previous discoveries," Professor Brown said.

Within weeks of the discovery, however, doubts began to arise. The leading critic of the "hobbit theory" emerged in the form of Professor Teuku Jacob of Gadjah Mada University in Yogyakarta. A veteran Indonesian palaeo-anthropologist, Professor Jacob suggested that Homo floresiensis was not a new species at all, but merely an unfortunate, anatomically modern human with microcephaly - a disease that causes stunted growth and a small braincase. "Everything points to the direction of Homo sapiens," he said.

Professor Jacob, an influential figure in Indonesian science, infuriated the original discoverers of the hobbit by getting access to the bones through his friend and long-time colleague, Professor Radien Soejono of Indonesia's Centre for Archaeology in Jakarta, who was a co-author on the original Nature study.

There have since been claims that the bones have been damaged during the time they were in Professor Jacob's care, claims he denies.

Professor Jacob leads the list of authors in the latest paper in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Science, which also includes Professor Soejono, who now appears to have changed his mind as well as his allegiances.

The study also includes Robert Eckhardt, professor of developmental genetics and evolutionary morphology at Penn State University. "LB1 is not a normal member of a new species, but an abnormal member of our own," Professor Eckhardt said.

The thrust of the criticism is that the original researchers used a Eurocentric approach in determining whether the features of the LB1 skeleton were indeed unusual enough to warrant classification as a separate species.

"LB1 looks differently if researchers think in terms of European characteristics because it samples a population that is not European, but Australomelanesian, and further because it is a developmentally abnormal individual, being microcephalic," Professor Eckhardt said.

"To establish a new species, palaeo-anthropologists are required to document a unique complex of normal traits not found in any other species," he said. "But this was not done. The normal traits of LB1 were not unique and its unusually small braincase was not normal."

To date, scientists have amassed skeletal remains from nine individuals from the Liang Bua cave but most of these are body fragments - such as an odd tooth - rather than the partial skeleton and skull of LB1.

"What would clinch it is if we could find another skull," said Professor Richard Roberts of the University of Wollongong in Australia, one of the original discoverers.

The latest onslaught from the non-hobbit camp does not impress the team who made the find and wrote the seminal 2004 scientific paper in Nature. "There's nothing in it that's revelatory. I'm not changing my mind on the basis of what they have published," Professor Roberts said yesterday."Complete rubbish. None of their arguments stand up at all," said Professor Brown, who questioned whether the study had been properly peer-reviewed by the journal.

"There's absolutely nothing to it. We've been asking them to supply any modern skeleton that has the same features as the hobbit, and they haven't done it," he said.

Such disagreements are unlikely to be resolved for some time. Yet another study is shortly to be published in the Journal of Human Evolution which supports the idea that the LB1 skeleton of the "hobbit" does indeed belong to a new human species.

Debbie Argue and Colin Groves of the Australian National University in Canberra dismiss the idea that the individual is microcephalic and their assessment supports the contention that the "hobbit" belongs to a new species called Homo floresiensis.

"This is a completely independent study and it validates our claim that the skeleton belongs to a new human species," said Professor Brown. "It completely supports our original study and it's by a group who don't have a political axe to grind," said Professor Brown.

But even this is unlikely to be the final word on the LB1 skeleton. Another group of scientists at Stony Brook University in New York have studied it in detail and concluded that "she" may not have been female after all.

Few bones of contention are destined to be chewed over for so long as those of the hobbit.

News
peoplePaper attempts to defend itself
Voices
voicesWe desperately need men to be feminists too
Life and Style
food + drink
Arts and Entertainment
British actor Idris Elba is also a DJ and rapper who played Ibiza last summer
film
PROMOTED VIDEO
News
ebooksAn unforgettable anthology of contemporary reportage
Arts and Entertainment
The Tiger Who Came To Tea
booksJudith Kerr on what inspired her latest animal intruder - 'The Crocodile Under the Bed'
News
Alan Bennett criticised the lack of fairness in British society encapsulated by the private school system
peopleBut he does like Stewart Lee
Sport
John Terry, Frank Lampard
footballChelsea captain sends signed shirt to fan whose mum had died
News
people
News
i100
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Account Executive/Sales Consultant – Permanent – Hertfordshire - £16-£20k

£16500 - £20000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: We are currently r...

KS2 PPA Teacher needed (Mat Cover)- Worthing!

£100 - £125 per day: Randstad Education Crawley: KS2 PPA Teacher currently nee...

IT Systems Manager

£40000 - £45000 per annum + pension, healthcare,25 days: Ashdown Group: An est...

IT Application Support Engineer - Immediate Start

£28000 per annum: Ashdown Group: IT Software Application Support Analyst - Imm...

Day In a Page

Syria air strikes: ‘Peace President’ Obama had to take stronger action against Isis after beheadings

Robert Fisk on Syria air strikes

‘Peace President’ Obama had to take stronger action against Isis after beheadings
Will Lindsay Lohan's West End debut be a turnaround moment for her career?

Lindsay Lohan's West End debut

Will this be a turnaround moment for her career?
'The Crocodile Under the Bed': Judith Kerr's follow-up to 'The Tiger Who Came to Tea'

The follow-up to 'The Tiger Who Came to Tea'

Judith Kerr on what inspired her latest animal intruder - 'The Crocodile Under the Bed' - which has taken 46 years to get into print
BBC Television Centre: A nostalgic wander through the sets, studios and ghosts of programmes past

BBC Television Centre

A nostalgic wander through the sets, studios and ghosts of programmes past
10 best rucksacks for backpackers

Pack up your troubles: 10 best rucksacks for backpackers

Off on an intrepid trip? Experts from student trip specialists Real Gap and Quest Overseas recommend luggage for travellers on the move
Secret politics of the weekly shop

The politics of the weekly shop

New app reveals political leanings of food companies
Beam me up, Scottie!

Beam me up, Scottie!

Celebrity Trekkies from Alex Salmond to Barack Obama
Beware Wet Paint: The ICA's latest ambitious exhibition

Beware Wet Paint

The ICA's latest ambitious exhibition
Pink Floyd have produced some of rock's greatest ever album covers

Pink Floyd have produced some of rock's greatest ever album covers

Can 'The Endless River' carry on the tradition?
Sanctuary for the suicidal

Sanctuary for the suicidal

One mother's story of how London charity Maytree helped her son with his depression
A roller-coaster tale from the 'voice of a generation'

Not That Kind of Girl:

A roller-coaster tale from 'voice of a generation' Lena Dunham
London is not bedlam or a cradle of vice. In fact it, as much as anywhere, deserves independence

London is not bedlam or a cradle of vice

In fact it, as much as anywhere, deserves independence
Vivienne Westwood 'didn’t want' relationship with Malcolm McLaren

Vivienne Westwood 'didn’t want' relationship with McLaren

Designer 'felt pressured' into going out with Sex Pistols manager
Jourdan Dunn: Model mother

Model mother

Jordan Dunn became one of the best-paid models in the world
Apple still coolest brand – despite U2 PR disaster

Apple still the coolest brand

Despite PR disaster of free U2 album