# Fermat's theorem is proved at last . . . but what does it matter?

PURE mathematicians are an undemonstrative breed. Last Wednesday, at the Isaac Newton Institute in Cambridge, they finally solved the most celebrated problem of the century, a puzzle that had perplexed the world's greatest mathematicians for more than 300 years; then they went off to the upstairs common room and had coffee. But when it had all sunk in, Andrew Wiles, the man who proved Fermat's Last Theorem, did join his colleagues in a glass of champagne at lunch.

It had all started with Pierre de Fermat (1601-65) and a 3rd-century Greek mathematician, Diophantus of Alexandria. Besides being one of the greatest French mathematicians, Fermat was one of the great non-publishers of all time, being content to summarise his findings in scribbled comments in the margin of his copy of Arithmetics by Diophantus.

Thus, where Diophantus showed how to find triples of numbers (e g, 3, 4, 5 or 5, 12, 13) such that the squares of the first two add up to the square of the third, Fermat wrote: 'It is impossible for a cube to be written as the sum of two cubes, or a fourth power to be written as the sum of two fourth powers, or generally for any number which is a power greater than the second, to be written as a sum of two like powers.'

In symbols, he was claiming that there were no whole numbers x, y, z, and n such that x to the power n + yx to the power n = zx to the power n , for any n greater than 2. And, to his statement of the theorem, he added: 'I have a truly wonderful demonstration of this proposition which this margin is too narrow to contain.'

When Fermat made such a statement, he was eventually almost invariably proved right. The competitive style of mathematics of his time was very much to state results and challenge others to prove them, rather than spreading wisdom. By the 19th century, however, it was generally agreed that this time Fermat had got it wrong. The truth or falsity of his theorem (or conjecture, as it should properly have been called until last Wednesday) lay far deeper in the mathematical field of rational numbers than was dreamt of in the 17th century.

Fermat's 'proof', like many more recent attempts, had probably involved making a plausible, but unjustified, assumption about the structure of numbers. But for 300 years, plausible assumptions were the best anyone had to offer.

When Professor Andrew Wiles of Cambridge University and Princeton began his series of three lectures at the Newton Institute last Monday, there was a feeling that he might reveal something special. By the end of Tuesday's lecture, it was felt he was building up to something big.

'I'd heard more and more rumours,' said Professor Kenneth Ribet of Berkeley, California, 'so I brought my camera.' Had it been a video camera, it would have recorded the 40-year-old Briton ending Wednesday's lecture, having proved a major theorem in the theory of elliptic curves, then writing 'Corollary' on the blackboard, followed by Fermat's Last Theorem, and saying: 'I think I'll stop there.'

The audience, comprising many of the best mathematicians from around the world, greeted this with open-mouthed silence for about 10 seconds, followed by a burst of applause. Then, after some technical questions, there was more applause before they went for coffee.

The principal result that Professor Wiles proved was something known as Taniyama's conjecture, which for the past 10 years has been known to be inextricably linked to Fermat's Theorem. Some of the bonds between the two were discovered by Professor Ribet, whose work helped to establish that the theorem was unlikely to be an isolated quirk of numbers but, if true, fitted in with other aspects of mathematics.

'We knew that Taniyama's conjecture had to be true,' he said. 'It fitted into a whole string of interlocking conjectures. But we knew that we were unable to prove it.' Professor Wiles's proof is in fact of such complexity that it takes up 200 pages of still unpublished manuscript.

Professor John Coates of the Isaac Newton Institute described the result as the mathematical equivalent of splitting the atom, but Professor Wiles shyly said: 'Its significance is primarily symbolic'. So where does mathematics go from here, now that the Everest of Fermat has been scaled? Millions of amateur number- theorists must now find another problem. We can recommend any of the following, all still unproved:

The Goldbach Conjecture, that every even number is the sum of two prime numbers

The Prime Pairs Problem: to prove that there are infinitely many pairs of prime numbers, such as 5, 7, or 29, 31, or 101, 103 where the higher is two more than the lower

The 3N+1 problem: Start with any number; if it is even, halve it, if it is odd, multiply by three and add one; keep repeating this procedure. Prove that whatever number you started with, you will always reach the number 1

Like much of pure mathematics, neither these problems nor Fermat's Theorem has any conceivable application; but, as Professor Ribet points out, much of modern cryptography and theoretical physics uses mathematics that once had no conceivable application. 'When I went into this, I was quite proud of choosing an area that would never be applied,' he said. 'I have more perspective now . . .'

(Photographs omitted)

Suggested Topics
News

### Katie Hopkins causes outrage with Twitter 'tribute' to Bob Crow

peopleCampaign to become Britain's most-hated continues apace
Arts & Entertainment

### Going nowhere: Jon Snow stuck in a lift in rush to cover Bob Crow report

tv
Arts & Entertainment

### What are the best first lines in fiction?

books
Arts & Entertainment

### 'We're far-right, but not that kind of far-right': EDL Angel gets into a muddle

tvReview: EDL Girls - Don't Call Me Racist, BBC3
VIDEO
Sport

sport
News

### 'I was detrimental to my own career' (We think he means 'instrumental')

peopleWatch troubled child star Bieber display shocking new levels of arrogance in taped oral testimony
News

### From awkward to touching to perhaps a little overenthusiastic...

videoWatch what happens when a filmmaker asks ten pairs of strangers to kiss for the first time
Voices

### Who cares if she spells it Barraco Barner?

voicesGrace Dent: Gemma Worrall is more employable than some bookish arts graduate
Sport

### 10 reasons for Arsenal to be optimistic against Bayern Munich tonight

sportGunners need to overturn a 2-0 deficit against European champions
Arts & Entertainment

### Noah banned

filmRussell Crowe film forbidden in three Arab countries
Arts & Entertainment

### It's a man's world

filmWomen still 'vastly underrepresented in top films'
News

### Whatever you do, don't call Beyoncé 'bossy'

peopleSinger joins host of women celebrities for female empowerment campaign
News

news
News

science
Sport

### 'I wouldn't sit on a car bonnet going that fast'

sportInterview with Kelly Gallagher, Britain's first Winter Paralympics gold medallist
Arts & Entertainment

tv
News

### Space junk to be zapped by giant lasers in big Nasa clean-up

science

Threat of 'catastrophic cascade of collisions' must be averted, warn scientists

Independent
Travel Shop
The Pheasant at Gestingthorpe, Essex
From £129prpn Find out more
5* Thailand twin-centre holiday
from £1,599pp for 10 nights Find out more
All-inclusive Kos holiday
from £499pp for 7 nights Find out more
##### Independent Dating
and

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our

### Private Client

£30000 - £50000 per annum + Very Competitive Salary: Austen Lloyd: Private Cli...

### Residential Conveyancer - Dorset

£30000 - £35000 per annum + Very Competitive Salary: Austen Lloyd: Residential...

### Banking Analysis Internship - PAID

£1000 per month: Inspiring Interns: The company works with Tier 1 FTSE 100 Ban...

### Treasurer (trustee) with Crossroads Care Havering

VOLUNTARY ONLY - EXPENSES REIMBURSED : Reach Volunteering: Fantastic opportuni...

## Should we really be making money out of the First World War anniversary?

A line is crossed when making money becomes the goal

## How climate change helped Genghis Khan

Scientists believe a sudden period of warmer weather allowed the Mongols to invade with such success

## Wellcome Image Awards

The most striking images from the world of science

## What are the best first lines in fiction?

Novelists say they must write snappier first lines in order to grip today's distracted readers

## Two planes, a Rolls-Royce and an Aston Martin

Meet the fracking millionaires of Kenedy, Texas

## The real Dr Dolittle

Scottish scientist 'develops method for talking to animals'

## Who said print was dead?

The relaunch of ‘Newsweek’ as a print magazine shows there’s an appetite for long-form journalism

## Shaken and stirred

How a small town in Texas decided that something had to be done about fracking

## Broken Britain

Ruins inspire at the Tate Britain

## Western leaders cannot face a ‘looming’ war

So I guess they'll patch something up - and let Russia gobble part of Ukraine

## Patrick Cockburn's World View

To see what Ukraine's future may be, just look at Lviv's shameful past

## Stewart Lee: Beware - this man may be only joking

To some he is toxic and scornful. But behind the contemptuous on-stage persona is a family man who wants his own garden – and counts his luck

## The BBC in crisis: We all need a place to make mistakes

Axeing the youth-oriented BBC3 from terrestrial television will please some, but we have to pay for quality television and nurture its talent

## Jenny Willott: 'Free childcare from 12 months should be our aim... and Lord Rennard is a nice guy'

Jane Merrick talks to the minister for women and employment

## Stevia wonder

The plant that's a super sugar alternative – and free from calories and carbs