'British Army chief risked soldiers' lives,' says US colonel

Senior American officer in Afghanistan makes astonishing claim about deputy Isaf commander over his advice to soldiers

The actions of one of the British Army's most senior officers have boosted the Taliban and put soldiers' lives at risk, according to an astonishing attack made by a former colleague.

Lieutenant General Nick Carter, deputy commander of the International Security Assistance Force (Isaf) in Afghanistan, is said to have declared that soldiers may have to die rather than defend themselves against the enemy to limit civilian casualties, according to a US Army memo obtained by The Independent on Sunday.

In the document, written by US Colonel Harry Tunnell, former commander of the 5th Stryker Brigade, 2nd Infantry Division, he also tells superiors of Lt Gen Carter's "poor military performance".

British military officials last night played down the remarkable comments by the outspoken colonel – described as "quite a junior officer in the grand order of things" – who has since left the military. Lord Richard Dannatt, former head of the British Army, said that [then] Maj Gen Carter was following Nato strategy. He added: "There was little scope for a 'British' approach as opposed to the Nato plan."

The MoD last night refused to comment on the letter, but insisted British forces work closely with the Americans, adding: "UK troops in Afghanistan have the inherent right to self-defence and accusations that we have placed troops in unnecessary danger are nonsensical."

But the document, sent to John McHugh, Secretary of the US Army, in August 2010, highlights serious tensions between some US and British commanders during one of the most critical phases in the protracted battle against the Taliban.

Col Tunnell said: "A gross lack of concern for subordinates manifests in guidance that 'zero' civilian casualties are acceptable and coalition soldiers may have to be killed rather than defend themselves against a potential threat and risk being wrong and possibly resulting in injury or death of civilians – a verbal order from Maj Gen Carter."

The British commander is said to have assumed command with "a one page plan" in what was an "overly simplistic approach", and deliberately placed incoming units into "highly lethal areas".

The eight-page memo is a scathing assessment of the Isaf operation. Civilian casualties have been a constant concern and weeks after writing his memo Col Tunnell saw five of his soldiers accused of murdering three Afghan civilians. Four were convicted at courts-martial last year, and a US Army investigation absolved the commander.

The memo also attacks the notion of training Afghans, stating that: "It is very unlikely that we will be able to provide Afghans with a level of education and training to make them an independent and reliable force."

The views contrast sharply with the assessment presented by UK officials at a Commons hearing last week. Mark Sedwill, Political Director and Special Representative for Afghanistan and Pakistan at the Foreign Office, told MPs: "If we make the right decisions, there is a good prospect that Afghanistan will continue to achieve the campaign objectives. We have had very good relationships between successive ambassadors and the deputy commander of Isaf, the senior British officer in theatre."

Lord Dannatt added: "There will always be differences of opinion within a multinational force especially at the tactical level. In 2010, Major General Nick Carter was subordinate to the US Nato General in overall command and following his plan ... had his professional peers not thought that he had done a good job in 2010, he would not be back there in 2012 in a more senior position."

Arts and Entertainment
Kirk Cameron is begging his Facebook fans to give him positive reviews
film
Sport
premier leagueMatch report: Arsenal 1 Man United 2
Arts and Entertainment
Jason goes on a special mission for the queen
tvReview: Everyone loves a CGI Cyclops and the BBC's Saturday night charmer is getting epic
Sport
Jonny May scores for England
rugby unionEngland 28 Samoa 9: Wing scores twice to help England record their first win in six
PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
ebooksNow available in paperback
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Senior Project Manager

£45000 - £65000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This is a fantastic opportunity...

Recruitment Genius: Shopfitter

Negotiable: Recruitment Genius: This is an opportunity to join a successful an...

Recruitment Genius: Digital Sales Account Manager

£25000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A Digital Sales Account Manager...

Recruitment Genius: Trainee Sales Account Manager

£20000 - £25000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A Trainee Sales Account Manager...

Day In a Page

Mau Mau uprising: Kenyans still waiting for justice join class action over Britain's role in the emergency

Kenyans still waiting for justice over Mau Mau uprising

Thousands join class action over Britain's role in the emergency
Isis in Iraq: The trauma of the last six months has overwhelmed the remaining Christians in the country

The last Christians in Iraq

After 2,000 years, a community will try anything – including pretending to convert to Islam – to avoid losing everything, says Patrick Cockburn
Black Friday: Helpful discounts for Christmas shoppers, or cynical marketing by desperate retailers?

Helpful discounts for Christmas shoppers, or cynical marketing by desperate retailers?

Britain braced for Black Friday
Bill Cosby's persona goes from America's dad to date-rape drugs

From America's dad to date-rape drugs

Stories of Bill Cosby's alleged sexual assaults may have circulated widely in Hollywood, but they came as a shock to fans, says Rupert Cornwell
Clare Balding: 'Women's sport is kicking off at last'

Clare Balding: 'Women's sport is kicking off at last'

As fans flock to see England women's Wembley debut against Germany, the TV presenter on an exciting 'sea change'
Oh come, all ye multi-faithful: The Christmas jumper is in fashion, but should you wear your religion on your sleeve?

Oh come, all ye multi-faithful

The Christmas jumper is in fashion, but should you wear your religion on your sleeve?
Dr Charles Heatley: The GP off to do battle in the war against Ebola

The GP off to do battle in the war against Ebola

Dr Charles Heatley on joining the NHS volunteers' team bound for Sierra Leone
Flogging vlogging: First video bloggers conquered YouTube. Now they want us to buy their books

Flogging vlogging

First video bloggers conquered YouTube. Now they want us to buy their books
Saturday Night Live vs The Daily Show: US channels wage comedy star wars

Saturday Night Live vs The Daily Show

US channels wage comedy star wars
When is a wine made in Piedmont not a Piemonte wine? When EU rules make Italian vineyards invisible

When is a wine made in Piedmont not a Piemonte wine?

When EU rules make Italian vineyards invisible
Look what's mushrooming now! Meat-free recipes and food scandals help one growing sector

Look what's mushrooming now!

Meat-free recipes and food scandals help one growing sector
Neil Findlay is more a pink shrimp than a red firebrand

More a pink shrimp than a red firebrand

The vilification of the potential Scottish Labour leader Neil Findlay shows how one-note politics is today, say DJ Taylor
Bill Granger recipes: Tenderstem broccoli omelette; Fried eggs with Mexican-style tomato and chilli sauce; Pan-fried cavolo nero with soft-boiled egg

Oeuf quake

Bill Granger's cracking egg recipes
Terry Venables: Wayne Rooney is roaring again and the world knows that England are back

Terry Venables column

Wayne Rooney is roaring again and the world knows that England are back
Michael Calvin: Abject leadership is allowing football’s age-old sores to fester

Abject leadership is allowing football’s age-old sores to fester

Those at the top are allowing the same issues to go unchallenged, says Michael Calvin