UK

Mostly Cloudy with Showers 8° London Hi 9°C / Lo 5°C

It's not so good to talk – BT is named worst landline provider

By Martin Hickman, Consumer Affairs Correspondent
Tuesday, 8 April 2008

null

Scott Barbour/Getty Images

BT was voted the worst-performing landline provider

Related Articles

Britain's biggest phone operator, BT, has been named the worst landline provider in a customer satisfaction poll.

In an internet survey of 11,000 customers, BT had the lowest score for all but two of 11 categories for home phones, making it the worst performer in an industry with a poor record of customer service.

Three million of BT's 10 million landline customers are dissatisfied, according to the research for the price comparison site uSwitch.com.

It follows three surveys in the past year that have suggested BT offers poor value for money and repeatedly fails to sort out problems. In January, Citizens Advice found that 89 per cent of all landline complaints were about BT. A separate poll for uSwitch last month ranked BT's broadband the worst value, while last summer Which? ranked BT 17th of 28 broadband providers, giving it the lowest rating for value for money.

Yesterday, BT admitted that thousands of customers had experienced poor service between August 2007 and January after the introduction of a new computer system. "Unfortunately there were teething problems and some people having a lot of delays and other people had engineers turning up at the wrong time," said a spokesman, who maintained the "bad times" were over.

He accused uSwitch of distorting its latest landline survey to promote rival phone companies.

BT, one of the flagship privatisations of the Thatcher era, still enjoys a dominant position in the UK's £25bn-a-year telecoms business, with a 68 per cent share of landlines and one in five broadband customers.

While it built a reputation for customer service in the 1990s, the former state monopoly has so enraged customers in the past year that protests have spread on the internet. Eighty-nine per cent of those polled at the website Btcomplaint.com rated their treatment as "awful".

More than 1,300 people are members of anti-BT groups on Facebook such as "I Hate BT", far more than for other large companies such as British Gas.

One wrote: "I would suggest that you go to money claim online and issue a county court summons. Ringing them on the phone is a waste of time."

A freelance designer Clare Keil contacted The Independent after complaining that BT was taking months to restore her phone service – after it allocated her number to a nearby house.

"It just went on and on," recalled Mrs Keil. "I was sent to Delhi and Cape Town and just about everywhere in the world, standing in a freezing phone box. Nobody wanted to know. We really didn't know what to do, from breaking down in tears to threatening to call the Samaritans."

BT said the survey had been conducted before recent price cuts. "BT is sceptical of these results as they simply don't tally with our own research. Our research, carried out by an independent company on a much larger scale, shows far higher levels of customer satisfaction."

Thousands call up to complain

*Many telecoms companies, not just BT, offer poor service. Complaints about mobile phone contracts to the Consumer Direct hotline soared by 49 per cent last year – making them the second-most complained-about subject after used cars. The Telecommunications Ombudsman received 105,000 customer contacts in 2006/07 – up from 91,000 the year before. In a poll last year, the Citizens Advice Bureau found that 90 per cent of landline customers were dissatisfied with their service – and most of those were signed up to BT.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

54 Comments

We moved house in October and had booked a line connection for move in day. It took 7 days and multiple calls - standing in phoneboxes often holding for over an hour. Eventually they offered to send out an engineer but not before warning us that there would be a £116 charge as there was no problem with our line test. When the engineer arrived he repaired a broken wire in their box and we had a connection. It was so frustrating. We have BT broadband and it is hopeless - up to a maximum of 1 mb on their own line test and often it goes off altogether - the signal is so weal the home hub only works in the off peak times. Their service is so poor and the call centre staff do not really offer any help. They say the problem is my equipment which I paid a computer shop to check. They say it is perfect but BT broadband is very poor in our area because we are 9 miles from the exchange. I could have gone with another provider if I had known that before the move. After 12 mths I am out of this contract and going with someone else - definately not BT!

Posted by Alex | 11.04.08, 12:38 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

We had a similar experience to Mrs Keil, our number suddenly changed when they unexpectedly gave us a service destined for a neighbour, they also cancelled our account and direct debit (and had to refund the £96 we were in credit). When it was pointed out, they cut our service completely for several days. When the phone service was finally reconnected they did it by giving our line to the neighbours and connecting us to a noisy pair, which finally terminated our broadband and they said I would have to sign up again with my service provider (and pay a new service fee). When I finally gave in the service provider couldn't reconnect us since BT still had a 'termination of service' notice logged against our line, I spent hours on the mobile to India, South Africa, Sheffield and finally direct to local offices. Since I actually do work for BT, I started pulling names from contacts (I very nearly had my hands on Ben Verwaayen's phone number at one point), even then I could find no one who would actually resolve the problem. After one particularly frustrating day I got home literally shaking with anger, my wife thought I was destined for a heart attack.
BT didn't get off their arses to resolve anything on my behalf, I had to chase them every inch.
Eventually the termination notice timed out and strange as this may sound I signed up with BT for Broadband simply so that I can get on the phone and nag them directly without having other people involved.
I work in telecoms amongst other things and I can only say 'god help Joe average against these imbeciles', there seems to be absolutely no means of checking when changes are made and no accountability for the people who mess up.

As soon as I can terminate with them, I shall, but I want to go to someone with no line rental to BT there are many people putting equipment in the exchanges now, the choice is getting better, people should vote with their feet.

Posted by Graham Denton | 09.04.08, 21:18 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

On my last bill, i noticed that there was a £4.50 charge for "processing your bill"! How on earth can they justify that?
On my next bill I will not pay this fee. See into this if you will,
Thank you,
J Taylor.

Posted by John Taylor | 09.04.08, 19:36 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I had bad dealings with BT in the past, and poor service, so I decided to go with Talk Talk when choosing my new broadband service. As I had just moved in to my house, and couldn't find the BT phone connection, Talk Talk advised me to ask BT if there was a line in to the house, and if there was a number attached to it.

I phoned BT and was treated rudely. I was offered a BT Broadband package, which I answered quite firmly "No, I'm going with Talk Talk thank you." I was offered a BT package a number of times, to which I gave my same reply.

Imagine my surprise when my first BT bill comes in the next month. Amounting to £35. I phoned up BT and told them I hadn't agreed to any BT contract, and wanted the charges to be dropped, as I had a Talk Talk account live at that time.

I was basically told to prove that I hadn't agreed to the BT line, and as I didn't record the time, date and operator names involved with the call, there was no way I could do this. Furthermore, there would be a £75 disconnection fee, for the service I didn't want in the first place.

The lesson I have learned time and again from my dealings with BT is this: STAY AWAY FROM THEM. It is unsafe to even speak to them on the phone. They have no scruples.

Posted by Emma | 09.04.08, 10:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I live in a block of flats where the telephone wiring is in a cupboard on a communal walkway. There has long been a problem with BT engineers not locking the cupboard. They are too lazy to fetch the key from the caretaker so they leave the bolt off and only push the doors together. Next time they visit they prise the doors open with a screwdriver. The doors were only recently replaced because they had destroyed the edge of the door doing this.

In the recent high winds, the doors of the cupboard on our floor blew open and one door was blown completely off its hinges, leaving the BT equipment exposed and the lines to seven flats open to vandalism.

Ten days after being told about this, BT hadn't done anything about it. When they did arrive they announced that the doors were nothing to do with them and suggested I might be charged for the call out! Presumably the safety and security of customers' lines doesn't come into it?

About 8 years ago the wiring in the cupboard was in such a state that I was accidentally disconnected by their engineers 7 times in 18 months. Each time the phone was off for at least several days. Nothing happened to resolve it until I wrote to my MP and the Chief Executive.

Fifteen years ago BT was getting £150 per quarter from me. Now I've switched every possible thing I can away from them and they get less than £40. I would dearly love never to have to deal with them and that is my ultimate goal. Boycott them!

Posted by Robert | 09.04.08, 09:22 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Last year a phone pole came down across our road, the wires still attached and blocking all traffic. This was an emergency situation. It took 20 mins on the phone to BT before I eventually got to speak to someone who realised this was not a standard enquiry, and even then I had to argue that they must send engineers immediately because it was dangerous, and not in a couple of days time. I was astounded at how difficult it was to get to speak to a real person, and then to the right person, and then to get them to actually listen to what I was saying.

I'm proud to say I am NOT a BT customer - I switched to a company that has real people on the end of the phone every time - and based in Britain so there are no language and cultural problems.

Posted by Dorothy Lumb | 08.04.08, 23:00 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

My BT broadband was perpetually having problems. When I phoned to get help, I had to wade through interminable menus before eventually being connected to an Indian call centre manned by people who didn't have the slightest idea what they were doing. The final straw was when my wife's mother died. It took months to sort the bills out and my wife had to endure appalling insensitiity from, you guessed it, the same Indian call centre. We dumped BT, O2 and all the rest of the sorry shambles.

Posted by Mike | 08.04.08, 22:48 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Our attempts to connect a landline with BT in August took over 2 months, with multiple phone calls, waiting on hold for between 50-80minutes, to staff some of who were crying with stress. BT staff agreed we were caught in their system, but staff, supervisors and the managers were unable to have the power to fix their system. We complained direct to the BT Chairman, comprising 15 pages of notes of our BT experiences, and this too was met with no response. When BT finally connected us, they compounded their blundering service by listing us in the BT phone book when there were clear instructions to be ex-directory. BT have failed on service, truthfulness and accountability. It seems no-one is responsible.

Posted by CT | 08.04.08, 22:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I haver jet been chargedd £189 for by to take 2 visits to fix a line fault they admit was their problem. When I combined a very polite Indian gentleman who could not get my name right claimed he was only able to offer me a £90 refund. Apauling

Posted by chris | 08.04.08, 21:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Coming from Australia, I never thought my country had particularly good customer service - friendly but not particularly efficient might be the best way of describing it. However...I never thought I would experience such a shambolic outfit as BT. Even when you want them to sell you a service (ie get a line connected) the phone does not answer for over an hour - you dare not hang up however for you may have to wait longer next time. Soon after our connection went on the tele sales calls started from all sorts of businesses - I asked BT to stop these - apparently it takes about a month before your number is placed on the "don't call" list. We are still getting calls from companies using all sorts of misleading intros and refusing to identify themselves.

The only thing you can do when faced with a monster like this is to keep a diary by the phone, note every conversation with BT staff, try and get them to identify themselves and where they are based, write down any undertakings they give you and keep copies of any emails or correspondence they send you. Complain to Ofcom each time you fail to get a satisfactory response. Ofcom are a weak organisation whose brief is to regulate with a "light touch" but don't let them off the hook - make them do their job properly.

I feel sorry for the poor staff in India particularly having to try and clean up the mess left by the overpaid BT executives.

PM

Posted by PM | 08.04.08, 20:42 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

54 Comments

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date