Law Report: Husband's pension varied: Brooks v Brooks - Court of Appeal. (Lord Justice Neill, Lord Justice Hoffmann and Lord Justice Waite): 26 May 1994

The potential benefits given to a spouse of an employee under the employee's pension scheme were capable of rendering the scheme a post-nuptial settlement which could be varied in matrimonial proceedings. However, the court should not vary a pension scheme if the rights of third parties are likely to be affected.

The Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Hoffmann dissenting) dismissed the husband's cross-appeal against Mr Justice Ewbank's order upholding the district judge's variation of the husband's pension scheme and dismissed the wife's appeal against Mr Justice Ewbank's reduction of the wife's share of the sale proceeds of the former matrimonial home.

The marriage of the husband, 64, and the wife, 56, broke down in 1989 after 12 years. The husband was the sole shareholder of a building company which had ceased to trade. The company had established a pension scheme in 1980 for the benefit of the husband which entitled the husband, on retirement, to surrender a portion of his pension entitlement for the benefit of a spouse or dependant.

The district judge treated the pension scheme as a post-nuptial settlement which was capable of being varied under section 24(1)(c) of the Matrimonial Causes Act 1973, and varied it to give the wife a modest pension. That order was upheld by Mr Justice Ewbank who reduced the district judge's awards to the wife on the sale of the home from pounds 150,000 to pounds 110,000. She appealed from the downward variation of the order and the husband cross-appealed on the grounds that there was no jurisdiction to vary the terms of the pension scheme because they did not constitute a post-nuptial settlement.

John Elvidge (Girlings, Maidstone)for the husband; Martin Pointer (Paisners) for the wife.

LORD JUSTICE WAITE said that the wife, so long as she remained a wife, had a potential interest in the fund as a potential appointee under the husband's power to surrender part of his pension rights in her favour. Was that sufficient to render the scheme a post-nuptial settlement? The husband was entitled to the benefits of the policy and he had the power to surrender part of those benefits. It was that power which gave the scheme the character of a settlement, and it was the inclusion of a spouse within its objects which gave the settlement its nuptial element. The scheme amounted to a post-nuptial settlement.

The next question was whether the jurisdiction to vary a scheme was limited on policy grounds. Courts were empowered to compensate spouses for loss of pension through lump sum and property adjustment orders. Private pension schemes were too varied to be treated empirically as a class. It had to be accepted that many pension schemes in which provision was made for an employee's wife or widow would qualify technically as 'post-nuptial settlements' and would theoretically be open to invasion of their funds by the matrimonial jurisdiction.

In practice, however, the courts would be most unlikely, save in very unusual and exceptional circumstances, to allow the variation power to be used to reduce or disturb the rights or potential rights of people outside the marriage.

The touchstone test, therefore, would be to inquire whether any proposed variation of the pension arrangements would be liable to affect the rights of third parties. If there was any risk that it might, the court would abandon consideration of any direct interference under section 24 and would use its general powers.

If it was not apparent to the district judge whether rights of persons other than the spouses and their children would be affected by any variation of the pension, the judge would direct the necessary information to be provided. If reasonable objection was made to the proposed variation by the third parties potentially affected, it was most unlikely that the variation would be allowed to proceed. Here no third-party rights arose. There was no objection of principle or policy to the scheme being varied to make limited pension provision for the wife. The husband's cross- appeal would be dismissed.

Turning to the wife's appeal, the criticisms of the judge's downward variation did not vitiate the judge's conclusions.

Lord Justice Hoffmann, dissenting, said that the pension scheme conferred benefits on the husband solely in the character of employee and was not a post-nuptial settlement, although it arguably gave the husband power to create one on retirement.

Lord Justice Neill, agreeing with Lord Justice Waite, said that the policy paid proper regard to the husband's obligations to provide for the wife and was part of the family assets. This was not a fund from which the pensions of other individuals might become payable. As a general rule, the court should not attempt to vary the terms of a pension scheme if the rights of third parties were likely to be affected.

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebooks
ebooksA special investigation by Andy McSmith
  • Get to the point
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Internal Sales Executive

£20000 - £22000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An exciting opportunity has ari...

Recruitment Genius: Sales Executive

£20000 - £25000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This is a fantastic opportunity...

Recruitment Genius: Finance / Accounts Manager

£25000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Well established and expanding ...

Recruitment Genius: Bench Locksmith / Engineer / Technician

£14000 - £20000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This leading Key Cutting equipm...

Day In a Page

The saffron censorship that governs India: Why national pride and religious sentiment trump freedom of expression

The saffron censorship that governs India

Zareer Masani reveals why national pride and religious sentiment trump freedom of expression
Prince Charles' 'black spider' letters to be published 'within weeks'

Prince Charles' 'black spider' letters to be published 'within weeks'

Supreme Court rules Dominic Grieve's ministerial veto was invalid
Distressed Zayn Malik fans are cutting themselves - how did fandom get so dark?

How did fandom get so dark?

Grief over Zayn Malik's exit from One Direction seemed amusing until stories of mass 'cutting' emerged. Experts tell Gillian Orr the distress is real, and the girls need support
The galaxy collisions that shed light on unseen parallel Universe

The cosmic collisions that have shed light on unseen parallel Universe

Dark matter study gives scientists insight into mystery of space
The Swedes are adding a gender-neutral pronoun to their dictionary

Swedes introduce gender-neutral pronoun

Why, asks Simon Usborne, must English still struggle awkwardly with the likes of 's/he' and 'they'?
Disney's mega money-making formula: 'Human' remakes of cartoon classics are part of a lucrative, long-term creative plan

Disney's mega money-making formula

'Human' remakes of cartoon classics are part of a lucrative, long-term creative plan
Lobster has gone mainstream with supermarket bargains for £10 or less - but is it any good?

Lobster has gone mainstream

Anthea Gerrie, raised on meaty specimens from the waters around Maine, reveals how to cook up an affordable feast
Easter 2015: 14 best decorations

14 best Easter decorations

Get into the Easter spirit with our pick of accessories, ornaments and tableware
Paul Scholes column: Gareth Bale would be a perfect fit at Manchester United and could turn them into serious title contenders next season

Paul Scholes column

Gareth Bale would be a perfect fit at Manchester United and could turn them into serious title contenders next season
Inside the Kansas greenhouses where Monsanto is 'playing God' with the future of the planet

The future of GM

The greenhouses where Monsanto 'plays God' with the future of the planet
Britain's mild winters could be numbered: why global warming is leaving UK chillier

Britain's mild winters could be numbered

Gulf Stream is slowing down faster than ever, scientists say
Government gives £250,000 to Independent appeal

Government gives £250,000 to Independent appeal

Donation brings total raised by Homeless Veterans campaign to at least £1.25m
Oh dear, the most borrowed book at Bank of England library doesn't inspire confidence

The most borrowed book at Bank of England library? Oh dear

The book's fifth edition is used for Edexcel exams
Cowslips vs honeysuckle: The hunt for the UK’s favourite wildflower

Cowslips vs honeysuckle

It's the hunt for UK’s favourite wildflower
Child abuse scandal: Did a botched blackmail attempt by South African intelligence help Cyril Smith escape justice?

Did a botched blackmail attempt help Cyril Smith escape justice?

A fresh twist reveals the Liberal MP was targeted by the notorious South African intelligence agency Boss