Law Report: Lloyd's names' actions can proceed: Arbuthnott and others v Feltrim and others; Deeny and others v Gooda Walker Ltd and others - Court of Appeal (Sir Thomas Bingham, Master of the Rolls, Lord Justice Steyn and Lord Justice Hoffmann), 30 July 1993
The Court of Appeal dismissed appeals by the agents of Lloyd's names against Mr Justice Saville's decision on an issue of construction arising from the agreements between the names and the agents.
The plaintiffs, Lloyd's names, claimed damages against their agents for breach of contract in the conduct of underwriting for four syndicates. The names and agents were parties to a standard agency agreement. The agents claimed that clause 9 of the agreement precluded a name from bringing an action when the damages sought related to a cash requirement made on the name for underwriting liabilities which had not been met.
Bernard Eder QC and David Foxton; Bernard Eder QC and Simon Bryan (Elborne Mitchell) for the appellant agents; Anthony Boswood Qc and Stephen Moriarty (Richards Butler) for the names in the first action; Jonathan Mance QC and David Lord (Wilde Sapte) for the names in the second action.
SIR THOMAS BINGHAM MR said the scheme of the clause was clear and sensible. The duty of the name to pay sums required by the agent without prevarication was stated clearly. That reflected the overriding need to ensure that funds were available for prompt settlement of the claims of those who had insured or reinsured at Lloyd's. But that need did not require that names should forgo all rights to complain of negligent underwriting where there were still calls outstanding and unpaid.
Courts would never construe words in a vacuum. To seek to construe any instrument in ignorance or disregard of the circumstances which gave rise to it or the situation in which it was expected to take effect was pedantic, sterile and productive of error. Construction was a composite exercise, neither uncompromisingly literal nor unswervingly purposive: the instrument must speak for itself, but it must do so in situ and not be transported to the laboratory for microscopic analysis.
Lord Justice Steyn, agreeing, said that the agents' interpretation led to the extraordinary result that if the agent ruined a name by negligent underwriting, so that the name could not pay the cash call, the contract breaker or tortfeasor went scot-free. That result was inimical to the interest of policyholders and the Lloyd's market.
Lord Justice Hoffmann also concurred.
Ying Hui Tan, Barrister
- 1 Heavy metal producer's corpse to be mutilated by models as per his dying wish
- 2 Man who held up 'hire me' sign at Waterloo station returns a year later with 'I'm hiring' sign
- 3 Nineteen-year-old student left gifts for parents before taking her own life
- 4 Deliberately urinating before sex can increase risk of urinary tract infections
British Muslim leaders outraged after Eric Pickles says followers of Islam should 'prove their identity'
UK terror fears: My jihadist son returned from Syria mentally scarred – now he is being ignored
Nigel Farage: NHS might have to be replaced by private health insurance
Billy Crystal: 'Stop shoving gay sex scenes in my face'
French court convicts three over homophobic tweets, in case hailed as a 'significant victory' by LGBT rights campaigners
David Cameron says anyone criticising Eric Pickles' letter to Muslims 'really has a problem'
£15000 - £50000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Fantastic opportunities are ava...
Negotiable: Recruitment Genius: A Compute Engineer is required to join a globa...
£25000 - £28000 per annum + 25 days holidays & pension: Ashdown Group: PHP Web...
£35000 - £40000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: Based in London, Manchester, Br...