How the House of Lords became a private club for peers and their friends
Despite a ban on using the Palace for business, many are still holding corporate events there. Melanie Newman and Oliver Wright report
Peers are using the House of Lords as a private club to wine and dine business clients – despite a ban on them using the facilities for commercial purposes, an investigation by The Bureau of Investigative Journalism and The Independent has found.
The revelation will add to concerns that members of the Lords may be using their position to advance their own financial interests and those of their family and friends, with few checks to ensure that they stay within the rules.
After Lord Heseltine, a director of the publisher Haymarket, used the peers' dining room to launch a magazine in 2008, new guidance was issued forbidding peers from sponsoring promotional events in the Lords for companies in which they have a financial interest.
But an investigation has found that peers are still using the Palace of Westminster for corporate dinners and parties. Such events offer guests the opportunity to network in parts of the historic Palace which are off-limits to the public. Beautifully decorated, the function rooms are among the grandest in the building with wood panelling, high decorated ceilings and deep red carpets.
The peers include the former Metropolitan Police Commissioner Lord Stevens of Kirkwhelpington, who hosted a "customer event" for 140 people in the peers' dining room for the private forensic science firm LGC.
Lord Stevens is a non-executive director as well as a shareholder in the firm, which made headlines in March after a rape case collapsed because LGC had allowed evidence to be contaminated.
At the party he hosted for the company in the Lords, Lord Stevens praised the firm's "dedication to pushing the boundaries of forensic science" in a speech. LGC's website afterwards described the night as a "customer event".
LGC "showcased its full range of cutting-edge forensic services to representatives from various UK civil and military police forces, the RAF, the Forensic Regulator, Crown Prosecution Services, Coroner's Office and the private sector," the website said.
The forensic science firm's newsletter later hailed the evening as a "great success" and "a perfect opportunity ... for our existing and potential customers to realise the full range of service we provide".
Lord Stevens was not available for comment yesterday but a spokesman for LGC insisted: "This was not a promotional event. Those attending would have no responsibilities for procuring our services. The point of the event was to educate those attending about the wide range of methods and technologies within the world of forensics and to allow them to discuss the latest innovations with relevant scientists."
The Cholmondeley Room is the most sought-after location in the House of Lords, allowing guests the chance to walk on to the Terrace and view the Thames. And so it was the Cholmondeley Room that the Conservative peer Lord Sheikh booked for the launch of his insurance broking firm, Macmillan Sheikh, last April.
A page on the firm's website announcing the launch – which was removed after Lord Sheikh was contacted by journalists – said the space was "filled to capacity" with guests including insurers, brokers and loss adjusters. Speakers included Omar Faruk, who introduced himself as the peer's "chief of staff on the political side".
Another speaker, Nigel Dyer, an industry consultant, said insurance underwriters could expect a "long-term relationship" with Macmillan Sheikh "provided they price the product sensibly".
"We are here today celebrating the arrival of a new professional insurance brokerage," he added.
Lord Sheikh said the event was a social gathering which was "in no way intended as a source of business development in any shape or form" and that business was not discussed. He added that he had not received payment from Macmillan Sheikh and despite being a director and chairman of the firm, did not own shares in it.
According to company accounts filed in 2011, the peer's daughter Zarina is the majority shareholder in the firm.
Some peers have "flipped" sponsorship of events. For example, every year since at least 2007 the IT firm 2e2 has held an evening reception for several hundred people at the House of Lords. Until 2009, Lord St John, a paid adviser to the firm, sponsored the reception. But rules forbidding sponsorship of promotional events by peers with financial interests then came into force. So the following year, the man who shares his office in the Palace, Lord Erroll, took over the role. He also appears to have an interest in IT.
However Lord St John continued to attend the events and a copy of the invitation to the September 2011 event on 2e2's website said: "Hosted by Lord St John of Bletso, a sitting member of the House of Lords and strategic adviser to the 2e2 Board, this is a fantastic opportunity for invited guests to visit the Lords and enjoy canapés and drinks with 2e2's senior executives, partners and peers on the terrace of Westminster."
2e2 declined to say why Lord St John was listed as host on the invitation; why the event was now sponsored by Lord Erroll rather than Lord St John; or whether guests at the 2011 reception included customers, clients or journalists.
A spokeswoman said: "As an IT services provider we are not best placed to comment on the way that the Palaces [sic] of Westminster conduct their affairs."
Lord Erroll said: "I share an office with Anthony St John and knew that it needed a new host, so I offered to do it. I find these events a useful alternative to spending a day at a conference. The failure to change the named host on the invitation was an oversight, presumably by their PR department."
The peer seemed uncertain of the company's name when contacted by the Bureau, referring to it as C2E and C3E. "The annual event which C2E sponsor is a useful forum in which parliamentarians, civil servants and industry professionals can meet and bring each other up-to-date," he said.
Lord Erroll added: "I made the opening speech at the C3E events and welcomed the guests. I introduced Anthony [St John] who said a few short remarks and there were some other industry speakers, but I can't remember who. Speeches were kept short as the purpose was to network, not to promote anything."
Lord St John said: "Lord Erroll and I share an office in the House of Lords and we both have a keen interest on IT-related issues.
"He agreed to host the event for 2e2 where he had the opportunity of hearing developments in the sector.
"I, similarly, agreed to host an event for him, sponsored by Flexeye in 2010 where Lord Erroll was on the Advisory Board and I had no financial interest."
- 1 Stoke City investigate 'religious abuse' after 'pig's head is found in Kenwyne Jones' locker'
- 2 Gove’s lesson: spare the comma, spoil the child
- 3 You thought Ryanair's attendants had it bad? Wait 'til you hear about their pilots
- 4 Join Ryanair! See the world! But we'll only pay you for nine months a year
- 5 It’s official: thanks to Stephen Hawking's Israel boycott, anti-Semitism is no more
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
£30000 - £40000 per annum + BENS: Progressive Recruitment: Drupal Developer A ...
£45000 - £50000 per annum + bens: Progressive Recruitment: C# WEB DEVELOPER Le...
£240 - £260 per day: Progressive Recruitment: WPF Developer (C#, VB.Net) North...
£85 - £120 per day: Randstad Education Cheshire: KS2 teacher needed to do PPA ...