Safety of genetic evidence is put to test: Steve Connor reports on doubts over the use of DNA profiles in court

Six years after genetic fingerprinting was first used in a British court, there is grave concern that it is not the powerful identification tool it was initially said to be.

Defence lawyers in two recent court cases in the UK successfully challenged DNA evidence on the grounds that it could not be relied on to produce a safe conviction. One of the judges involved ruled that if scientists themselves could not agree on the value of genetic fingerprinting, it was unfair to expect a jury to do so.

Next week, forensic experts and leading geneticists will attempt to resolve the issue at a conference in London organised by the Metropolitan Police.

Some of the world's most eminent geneticists are astonished at the British court ruling. They believe anxieties - first expressed more than two years ago - should have been dispelled by now.

'It's the lawyers who keep the pot boiling,' Victor McKusick, professor of medical genetics at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, Maryland, said. 'It's their business to defend clients and anything they can say to cast doubt on genetic fingerprinting, they will. I think it's unjustified.'

Professor McKusick chaired a committee of American scientists who last year produced a report that should have answered the criticism. He said the report 'lays their concerns to rest'.

Although the committee, which was called together by the prestigious US National Academy of Sciences, confirmed the general reliability of the technique, the scientific consensus failed to prevent DNA evidence being thrown out by the courts.

Professor McKusick was mystified: 'I can't see why they find it unacceptable.'

Alec Jeffreys, professor of genetics at Leicester University and inventor of the technique, said the case against DNA fingerprinting was groundless. The dispute had led to a situation where 'scientific logic and legal logic get lost'.

The problems are perhaps the inevitable result of the technique's complexity. Defence lawyers have bombarded judges and juries with a welter of contradictory claims about scientific intricacies. Genetic fingerprinting works by comparing the DNA present in a tissue sample left at the scene of a crime - blood, semen, hair, skin or even saliva - with that of the defendant. Forensic scientists use a process of separating DNA fragments - dark bands in a gel - in an electric field. When the positions of two bands coincide, then they are said to match.

One of the arguments used by defence lawyers is that it is not always possible to agree on whether a 'match' is genuine. Even using the same scientific procedure on the same person can produce bands that end up in slightly different positions to each other.

However, Professor Jeffreys said the question of matching bands was not an issue because the interpretation of a match was biased in favour of a guilty defendant. But this has not stopped defence lawyers successfully challenging the forensic scientist's definition of a match.

More importantly, defence lawyers have raised the possibility that a 'match' between defendant and sample is the result of an innocent defendant and the guilty person sharing the same characteristics used in the analysis.

This is why DNA evidence is always accompanied by a statistical estimate of the probability of a chance match. There is more than one way of estimating this probability and different estimates can result in what appear to be huge discrepancies to a judge or jury. In one celebrated murder case in New York, the probabilities of a chance match were given as 1 in 500 using one statistical method, and 1 in 739 billion using another. This extreme example illustrates the difficulties of using a statistical procedure called the multiplication rule, whereby extremely small probabilities arise as a result of multiplying individual probabilities together.

The multiplication rule does not take sub-grouping of genetic traits - such as different races - into account because it assumes the genes in question are independent of each other. Defence lawyers have exploited this limitation.

Critics say there are subgroups of people - such as Scandinavians or Africans - who are likely to share the same genetic profile.

The argument's two chief proponents were Richard Lewontin, a geneticist at Harvard University, and Daniel Hartl, professor of biology at Harvard. They said genetic differences between races within a society mean that some genetic traits used in DNA profiling may not occur independently of each other.

Lewontin and Hartl were right in principle, but in practice it makes no difference, said Professor Jeffreys and others. For the genetic traits used in DNA profiling, there are no major differences between racial groups that could make the technique unsafe. In fact, genetic differences within races rather than between races are greater.

Professor McKusick's scientific committee concluded that even assuming there were differences between groups within the population, this could be taken into account by being ultra-conservative with the statistics, biasing the evidence in favour of the defendant.

Providing scientists follow this procedure and take due care in analysing tissue samples 'DNA typing should be able to provide virtually absolute individual identification', the committee said.

Professor Hartl accepted these conclusions and now endorses genetic fingerprinting. 'It's a terrific technique. It's so powerful at identifying people you don't have to fudge the data.' Even though probabilities will now have to be amended, so that some smaller estimates such as 1 in 100 million are changed to 1 in 10 million, they are 'still within the range that you can convict', he said.

Professor Lewontin, however, is sticking to his position, providing comfort for defence lawyers. 'I don't think it does change anything. I have the same problems I've always had,'he said.

Meanwhile, Professor Jeffreys is adamant that genetic fingerprinting is safe. 'It's here to stay.'

Sport
Thiago Silva pulls Arjen Robben back to concede a penalty
world cup 2014Brazil 0 Netherlands 3: More misery for hosts as Dutch take third place
Sport
Robin van Persie hands his third-place medal to a supporter
Van Persie gives bronze medal to eccentric fan moments after being handed it by Blatter
News
Ian Thorpe had Rio 2016 in his sights
people
Life and Style
Swimsuit, £245, by Agent Provocateur
fashion

Diving in at the deep end is no excuse for shirking the style stakes

PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
ebookA unique anthology of reporting and analysis of a crucial period of history
News
scienceScientists have developed a material so dark you can't see it...
News
Monkey business: Serkis is the king of the non-human character performance
peopleFirst Gollum, then King Kong - now the actor is swinging through trees in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
Arts and Entertainment
Blackman: Landscape of children’s literature does not reflect the cultural diversity of young people
booksMalorie Blackman appeals for a better ethnic mix of authors and characters and the illustrator Quentin Blake comes to the rescue
Voices
Mrs Brown's Boy: D'Movie has been a huge commercial success
voicesWhen it comes to national stereotyping, the Irish know it can pay to play up to outsiders' expectations, says DJ Taylor
Arts and Entertainment
Curtain calls: Madani Younis
theatreMadani Younis wants the neighbourhood to follow his work as closely as his audiences do
Life and Style
Douglas McMaster says the food industry is ‘traumatised’
food + drinkSilo in Brighton will have just six staple dishes on the menu every day, including one meat option, one fish, one vegan, and one 'wild card'
Life and Style
Once a month, waistline watcher Suran steps into a 3D body scanner that maps his body shape and records measurements with pinpoint accuracy
techFrom heart rates to happiness, there is little this fast-growing, self-tracking community won't monitor
Sport
Mario Balotelli, Divock Origi, Loic Remy, Wilfried Bony and Karim Benzema
transfersBony, Benzema and the other transfer targets
News
Soft power: Matthew Barzun
peopleThe US Ambassador to London, Matthew Barzun, holds 'jeans and beer' gigs at his official residence. He says it's all part of the job
Sport
Joe Root and James Anderson celebrate their record-beaking partnership
cricketEngland's last-wicket stand against India rewrites the history books
News
Gavin Maxwell in Sandaig with one of his pet otters
peopleWas the otter man the wildlife champion he appeared to be?
News
Rowsell says: 'Wearing wigs is a way of looking normal. I pick a style and colour and stick to it because I don't want to keep wearing different styles'
peopleThe World Champion cyclist Joanna Rowsell on breaking her collarbone, shattering her teeth - and dealing with alopecia
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Information Security Manager (ISO 27001, Accreditation, ITIL)

£70000 per annum: Harrington Starr: Information Security Manager (ISO 27001, A...

C# Developer (HTML5, JavaScript, ASP.NET, Mathematics, Entity)

£30000 - £45000 per annum + Benefits + Bonus: Harrington Starr: C# Developer (...

C# Integration Developer (.NET, Tibco EMS, SQL 2008/2012, XML)

£60000 - £80000 per annum + Benefits + Bonus: Harrington Starr: C# Integration...

Biztalk - outstanding opportunity

£75000 - £85000 per annum + ex bens: Deerfoot IT Resources Limited: Biztalk Te...

Day In a Page

Iraq crisis: How Saudi Arabia helped Isis take over the north of the country

How Saudi Arabia helped Isis take over northern Iraq

A speech by an ex-MI6 boss hints at a plan going back over a decade. In some areas, being Shia is akin to being a Jew in Nazi Germany, says Patrick Cockburn
The evolution of Andy Serkis: First Gollum, then King Kong - now the actor is swinging through the trees in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

The evolution of Andy Serkis

First Gollum, then King Kong - now the actor is swinging through the trees in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
You thought 'Benefits Street' was controversial: Follow-up documentary 'Immigrant Street' has got locals worried

You thought 'Benefits Street' was controversial...

Follow-up documentary 'Immigrant Street' has got locals worried
Refugee children from Central America let down by Washington's high ideals

Refugee children let down by Washington's high ideals

Democrats and Republicans refuse to set aside their differences to cope with the influx of desperate Central Americas, says Rupert Cornwell
Children's books are too white, says Laureate

Children's books are too white, says Laureate

Malorie Blackman appeals for a better ethnic mix of authors and characters and the illustrator Quentin Blake comes to the rescue
Blackest is the new black: Scientists have developed a material so dark that you can't see it...

Blackest is the new black

Scientists have developed a material so dark that you can't see it...
Matthew Barzun: America's diplomatic dude

Matthew Barzun: America's diplomatic dude

The US Ambassador to London holds 'jeans and beer' gigs at his official residence – it's all part of the job, he tells Chris Green
Meet the Quantified Selfers: From heart rates to happiness, there is little this fast-growing, self-tracking community won't monitor

Meet the 'Quantified Selfers'

From heart rates to happiness, there is little this fast-growing, self-tracking community won't monitor
Madani Younis: Five-star reviews are just the opening act for British theatre's first non-white artistic director

Five-star reviews are just the opening act for British theatre's first non-white artistic director

Madani Younis wants the neighbourhood to follow his work as closely as his audiences do
Mrs Brown and her boys: are they having a laugh?

Mrs Brown and her boys: are they having a laugh?

When it comes to national stereotyping, the Irish – among others – know it can pay to play up to outsiders' expectations, says DJ Taylor
Gavin Maxwell's bitter legacy: Was the otter man the wildlife champion he appeared to be?

Otter man Gavin Maxwell's bitter legacy

The aristocrat's eccentric devotion to his pets inspired a generation. But our greatest living nature writer believes his legacy has been quite toxic
Joanna Rowsell: The World Champion cyclist on breaking her collarbone, shattering her teeth - and dealing with alopecia

Joanna Rowsell: 'I wear my wig to look normal'

The World Champion cyclist on breaking her collarbone, shattering her teeth - and dealing with alopecia
Bill Granger recipes: Our chef gives raw ingredients a lift with his quick marinades

Bill Granger's quick and delicious marinades

Our chef's marinades are great for weekend barbecuing, but are also a delicious way of injecting flavour into, and breaking the monotony of, weekday meals
Germany vs Argentina World Cup 2014 preview: Why Brazilians don't love their neighbours Argentina any more

Anyone but Argentina – why Brazilians don’t love their neighbours any more

The hosts will be supporting Germany in today's World Cup final, reports Alex Bellos
The Open 2014: Time again to ask that major question - can Lee Westwood win at last?

The Open 2014

Time again to ask that major question - can Lee Westwood win at last?