Size really doesn't matter to workers

Michael Heseltine's plan to scrap unfair dismissal protection for employees of small businesses is a discredited concept, a labour law expert tells Grania Langdon-Down

Scrapping the employment protection rights of workers in small businesses would be a return to the master and servant laws of the Victorian era, according to Dr John McMullen, a labour law expert .

"There is no country in Europe which does not have a law on unfair dismissal," he said, expressing surprise that the Government could even consider depriving 9 million workers of their employment rights.

"It would mean you would have no right to challenge your dismissal at all - however unfair or arbitrary it was. All civilised Western countries believe you should have a law to control arbitrary dismissals, otherwise you are going back to the master and servant laws of the Victorian age."

Dr McMullen, 41, is the national head of employment law for solicitors Pinsent Curtis, which has offices in London, Leeds and Birmingham. He is one of only a very few practising solicitors to cross the academic divide, combining his professional role with being Professor of Labour Law at Leeds University.

Pledges to cut red tape have been a recurring theme of the Government. But the suggestion that small business employees could lose their right to challenge unfair dismissal came out of the blue, Dr McMullen said.

"The idea is a surprise.The focus recently has been on changing industrial tribunals in relation to their efficiency - not in relation to people's rights to use them."

The inevitable controversy that followed the leaking of the proposal last week forced John Major to step in to deny any intentions to end unfair dismissal protection.

Although Downing Street sources were quick to play down the proposal, saying it was "on the back burner with the heat low", clearly, the heat could be turned back on if the Conservatives win the general election.

The majority of safeguards, such as rights to redundancy and to challenge unfair dismissal, come under the Employment Protection Consolidation Act 1978. The Wages Act 1986 controls the way employers can make stoppages from pay.

Dr McMullen stressed that small businesses already received some special treatment. When an industrial tribunal considers whether an employer behaved reasonably under Section 57 (3) of the 1978 Act, it is supposed to take into account the size and resources of the company.

Small businesses are able to sack people more easily if they are off sick and the business cannot manage, and they need less elaborate disciplinary procedures than large employers. Small businesses with fewer than 20 workers were also exempted from the 1995 Disability Discrimination Act.

Dr McMullen believed any further removal of employees' rights could be legally possible in some areas - but not where it touched on discrimination.

Small businesses employing five or fewer workers were originally exempt from the sex discrimination rules, for example, but that was found to be unlawful by the European Court.

Dr McMullen said the idea of removing employment protection rights was a "passe and rather discredited concept dating back to the early Eighties" that supporters justified by claiming it would encourage small businesses to take on more staff.

"There is no decisive empirical evidence whatsoever that removing small businesses from employment protection law would create new jobs," he said. "With regard to unfair dismissal, most people think any removal of employees' rights would be totally wrong. It is in small businesses that you most need protection.

"Why should you have two classes of employees - one protected and one not? Why should employers be allowed to behave badly?"

Dr McMullen pointed out that unfair dismissal protection was brought in by Edward Heath's government. The prime justification was to offer people a "civilised" way of dealing with a problem rather than by industrial action.

Since unionisation was often non-existent in small business, the law now provided employees with virtually their only protection.

"The whole point of a tribunal is to improve behaviour and provide a statutory stimulus to ensure employers follow proper procedures," Dr McMullen said.

There are on average more than 70,000 industrial tribunals a year, with the majority won by the employer. The number went up to about 120,000 this year because of 50,000 cases resulting from a European Court decision on part-time workers and pensions.

Compensation is limited to pounds 11,300, with average awards for unfair dismissal of about pounds 3,000.

small business leaders have long called for exemption from unfair dismissal claims. The Deputy Prime Minister, Michael Heseltine, has claimed such a move could save small firms up to pounds 200m in the cost of cases taken to tribunals.

Dr McMullen said: "That makes it sound as if it is all to do with businesses defending claims that should not have been brought in the first place. But only a small number are brought frivolously. Most of those defending claims should have got the procedures right in the first place."

He said it could be argued that there were problems with the tribunal system, in that employers did not recoup their costs if they won.

However, he said: "The tribunal system is supposed to be user-friendly. Claimants do not get legal aid and many rely on funding by a trade union or an organisation like the Equal Opportunities Commission. A claimant would only have to pay costs if they had acted frivolously."

At present, dismissal law is not covered by the European Union, but there are plans to harmonise the wide differences to be found among member states. In Germany, for example, employers have to show good cause before a judicial body before they can sack someone.

As Dr McMullen pointed out: "Our laws are not as tough as in some European Union countries. In some, there is a much greater emphasis on reinstatement, which only happens in 1 per cent of cases in this country."

If the safeguards were removed, the only way people could protect themselves would be to ensure they had a good contract with a generous notice period. "But how many would have the bargaining power to get a good contract? We are not talking City fat cats here but the average employee who gets what he is given," he said.

Arts & Entertainment
Ricky Gervais at a screening of 'Muppets Most Wanted' in London last month
tvRicky Gervais on the return of 'Derek' – and why he still ignores his critics
Sport
Gareth Bale dribbled from inside his own half and finished calmly late in the final to hand Real a 2-1 win at the Mestalla in Valencia
sport
Life & Style
Infant child breast-feeding with eyes closed
healthTo stop mummy having any more babies, according to scientists
Arts & Entertainment
James Franco and Chris O'Dowd in Of Mice and Men on Broadway
theatreReview: Of Mice and Men, Longacre Theatre
VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
News
news
Life & Style
Going down: Google's ambition to build an elevator into space isn't likely to be fulfilled any time soon
techTechnology giant’s scientists say there is no material strong enough for a cable from Earth into orbit
Arts & Entertainment
film
Sport
Vito Mannone fails to keep out Samir Nasri's late strike
sportMan City 2 Sunderland 2: Goalkeeping howler allows Man City to scrap a draw – but Premier League title is Liverpool's to lose
News
David Cameron sings a hymn during the enthronement service of The Most Rev Justin Welby as Archbishop of Canterbury, at Canterbury Cathedral last year
news
Life & Style
From long to Jong: Guy Pewsey gets the North Korean leader's look
fashionThe Independent heads to an Ealing hairdressers to try out the North Korean dictator's trademark do
Extras
indybest10 best smartphones
Arts & Entertainment
tvCreator Vince Gilligan sheds light on alternate endings
Life & Style
Google Doodle celebrates the 63rd anniversary of the Peak District National Park
tech
News
Paul Weller, aka the Modfather, performing at last year’s Isle of Wight Festival in Newport
people
Life & Style
Michael Acton Smith founded Firebox straight out of university before creating Moshi Monsters
techHe started out selling silliness with online retailer Firebox, before launching virtual creatures who took the real world by storm
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Energy Consultant – Building Management

up to £45,000 + benefits: The Green Recruitment Company: Our Client The Green ...

Senior Industrial Energy Consultant

Up to £45,000 + benefits: The Green Recruitment Company: Our Client The Green ...

Mechanical Building Services Energy Engineer

up to £45K basic + benefits: The Green Recruitment Company: Our Client The Gr...

Building Services Energy Engineer

up to £45K basic + benefits: The Green Recruitment Company: Our Client The Gr...

Day In a Page

Ricky Gervais: 'People are waiting for me to fail. If you think it's awful, then just don't watch it'

Ricky Gervais: 'People are waiting for me to fail'

As the second series of his divisive sitcom 'Derek' hits screens, the comedian tells James Rampton why he'll never bow to the critics who habitually circle his work
Mad Men series 7, TV review: The suits are still sharp, but Don Draper has lost his edge

Mad Men returns for a final fling

The suits are still sharp, but Don Draper has lost his edge
Google finds a lift into space will never get off the ground as there is no material strong enough for a cable from Earth into orbit

Google finds a lift into space will never get off the ground

Technology giant’s scientists say there is no material strong enough for a cable from Earth into orbit
Westminster is awash with tales of young men being sexually harassed - but it's far from being just a problem in politics

Is sexual harassment a fact of gay life?

Westminster is awash with tales of young men being sexually harassed - but it's far from being just a problem in politics
Moshi Monster creator Michael Acton Smith: The man behind a British success story

Moshi Monster creator Michael Acton Smith

Acton Smith launched a world of virtual creatures who took the real world by storm
Kim Jong-un's haircut: The Independent heads to Ealing to try out the dictator's do

Our journalist tries out Kim Jong-un's haircut

The North Korean embassy in London complained when M&M Hair Academy used Kim Jong-un's image in the window. Curious, Guy Pewsey heads to the hair salon and surrenders to the clippers
A History of the First World War in 100 moments: A forgotten naval victory in which even Nature played a part

A History of the First World War in 100 moments

A forgotten naval victory in which even Nature played a part
Vespa rides on with launch of Primavera: Iconic Italian scooter still revving up millions of sales

Vespa rides on with launch of the Primavera

The Vespa has been a style icon since the 1950s and the release this month of its latest model confirms it has lost little of its lustre
Record Store Day: Independent music shops can offer a tempting alternative to downloads

Record Store Day celebrates independent music shops

This Saturday sees a host of events around the country to champion the sellers of well-grooved wax
Taunton's policy of putting philosophy at heart of its curriculum is one of secrets of its success

Education: Secret of Taunton's success

Taunton School, in Somerset, is one of the country's leading independent schools, says Richard Garner
10 best smartphones

10 best smartphones

With a number of new smartphones on the market, we round up the best around, including some more established models
Mickey Arthur: Aussie tells ECB to stick with Ashley Giles

Mickey Arthur: Aussie tells ECB to stick with Ashley Giles

The former Australia coach on why England must keep to Plan A, about his shock at their collapse Down Under, why he sent players home from India and the agonies of losing his job
Homelessness: Why is the supported lodgings lifeline under threat?

Why is the supported lodgings lifeline under threat?

Zubairi Sentongo swapped poverty in Uganda for homelessness in Britain. But a YMCA scheme connected him with a couple offering warmth and shelter
A History of the First World War in 100 Moments: When the world’s biggest shed took over Regent’s Park

A History of the First World War in 100 Moments

When the world’s biggest shed took over Regent’s Park
The pain of IVF

The pain of IVF

As an Italian woman vows to keep the babies from someone else’s eggs, Julian Baggini ponders how the reality of childbirth is often messier than the natural ideal