The pundit rating: how good are they?: City economists think they are masters of the media universe, but Richard Thomson wonders whether we should listen to them

Turn on the television in these days of financial turmoil and you are liable to be confronted by a man in a suit telling you what the Government's latest economic blunder means for interest rates or the stock market. By now he is all too familiar. He (very occasionally she) is a City economist, a breed of pundit that has shot to prominence as the economic news grows ever more confusing.

Their presence in the media, explaining and making sense of it all, gives them an instant appearance of authority. But who are they, and do they know what they are talking about? Should we, in short, pay any attention to them?

If money were anything to go by, we should. Most leading City economists earn well over pounds 100,000, with many in the pounds 200,000 to pounds 400,000 bracket. Gavyn Davies, a partner at the US securities house Goldman Sachs and one of the most frequently quoted top analysts, is reputed to earn about pounds 1m a year.

Despite the famous jibe by Denis Healey when he was Chancellor in the 1970s - later echoed by Nigel Lawson - that the economists were mere 'teenage scribblers', most are in their late thirties or early forties.

They are paid to forecast and interpret the economy for their City employers and their clients, the huge investment and pension funds. They are used to making snap judgements on the fast-moving events of the financial markets. 'A lot of what we say is right off the top of our heads - but that is how the markets react too,' says Ruth Lea, economist at Mitsubishi Bank.

This makes them ideal television commentators, ready with a slick sound-bite in plain English rather than in the incomprehensible jargon too often used by academic economists in universities and business schools.

They also love the publicity, and so do their employers, who see it as free advertising for themselves. On Wall Street this has reached an extreme. Some analysts are required under their contracts to engineer a certain number of media appearances each year to get their employer's name up in lights. It has not yet come to that in Britain, although, according to Ruth Lea, 'you have to be something of a thespian in this job'.

Some experts think things have already gone too far. 'Nowadays the job of many of these people is 60 per cent public relations,' said Professor Gordon Pepper of the City University, who virtually invented the role of the City economist more than 20 years ago. 'It's a typical example of something taken to excess.'

Moreover, although these commentators sound authoritative, they are often horribly wrong. The only economists who have been more wrong are those at the Treasury, whose record of failure in predicting the economy accurately over the past few years is quite remarkable.

'One reason people trust us is that they think we give an honest, independent opinion in an environment where the Treasury is putting out a lot of propaganda,' says Keith Skeoch, chief economist at stockbrokers James Capel. But the independence is somewhat illusory.

The reason, as Professor Pepper put it, is that 'these economists are all very inbred. They all say the same things and they are all wrong'.

The economists have often studied with each other in the same universities. Some go into government, some into the City, some do both.

As our line-up of six of the most prominent analysts shows, a remarkable number of City economists have worked at the Treasury or in government think-tanks before landing up at banks or stockbrokers. 'Many of us left public service to earn more money,' says Giles Keating, chief economist at Credit Suisse First Boston.

They not only share the same thinking as the Government, they share similar methods of forecasting. For example, they use the same economic 'models' - computer programs which process economic data to produce forecasts. The models at the Treasury and the London Business School were even constructed by the same man: Sir Terry Burns, who is now permanent secretary to the Treasury. This means the 'independent' analysts end up with much the same forecasts as the Government.

All too often, therefore, when the Treasury gets its forecasts wrong, the City gets it wrong too. Almost all City economists failed to see how bad the recession was going to be in 1990, just as the Government did. And many of them erroneously believed that recovery would be on the way this year, just as the Treasury did.

Very few have shown the consistent and profound pessimism that forecasting this recession has actually required. Professor Wynne Godley at Cambridge University is one of the few mavericks who did.

Most pundits, however, stick with the crowd. 'They go with the herd,' said one former analyst. 'You get less blame if you are wrong when everyone else is than if you are wrong on your own.'


Midland Montagu

Oxford, dealer at Citibank, stockbroker at Capel Cure Myers. Age 40.

Record Correctly forecast the overheating of 1988-89 boom and predicted the sharp rise in interest rates. Slow to see the recession coming in 1990, but by 1991 avoided the mistake of forecasting recovery before the last election. Was in favour of sterling going in to the ERM two years ago and in favour of sterling coming out again three weeks ago.

Verdict Somewhat erratic record but less inaccurate than many other economists.


Phillips & Drew

Exeter and Cardiff Universities, Department of Trade 1973-81, Central Policy Review Staff 1881-83. Age 41.

Record Slow to spot the depth of the recession in 1989 and 1990. However, he became more accurate than most in foreasting low rates of economic growth over the last two years. Correctly foresaw there would be no recovery at this stage. Opposed ERM entry.

Verdict Slow starter, but relatively accurate for the past two years. Good at spotting the effects of Government policy.


James Capel

Sussex and Warwick Universities, Government Economic Service. Age 36.

Record Successfully forecast the coming recession in 1989 ahead of most of the City. Accurately predicted a fall in economic output for 1990. Also accurate on inflation in 1991 and 1992. Misjudged recovery this year, however, by predicting a bounce in consumer spending and strong economic growth. Verdict Good track record, with tendency to be rashly optimistic. Perhaps excessively devoted to ERM.


Mitsubishi Bank

York and Bristol Universities, Treasury, Civil Service College, Treasury, Central Statistical Office, Department of Trade and Industry. Age 45.

Record More pessimistic than most of the City over the depth of the recession in 1989 and 1990. Misjudged length of recession and initially expected an upturn in 1992. Then forecast flat economic growth, also over- optimistic.

Verdict In general not gloomy enough, but this newcomer lacks a real track record.


Goldman Sachs

Cambridge and Oxford, Downing Street Policy Unit 1974-79, Phillips & Drew, Simon & Coates. Age 41.

Record Accurate about the first phases of recession by being more pessimistic than the Treasury and most of the City in 1990. Completely misjudged recovery by claiming it had already begun last year. His 1991 forecasts, therefore, were largely wrong; corrected his views in mid-1992. Strong ERM supporter.

Verdict Tendency to get things impressively right and at times impressively wrong.


Credit Suisse First Boston

Oxford, CBI economist, research at LSE, wrote textbook on economic forecasting.

Age 37. Record Forecast onset of the recession in 1989, but failed to predict its current severity. Was consistently optimistic about prospects for recovery which never happened. He even predicted 'green shoots' early in 1991.

Became more pessimistic only this year.

Verdict Over-optimistic tendencies. Something of a maverick.

(Photograph omitted)

Start your day with The Independent, sign up for daily news emails
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
ebooksAn introduction to the ground rules of British democracy
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Recruitment Genius: Massage Therapist / Sports Therapist / Physio / Osteopath

£12000 - £24000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: An opportunity has arisen for o...

Recruitment Genius: Account Manager / Sales Executive - Contract Hire

£35000 - £60000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This industry leader provides c...

Recruitment Genius: Project Coordinator

£28000 - £30000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: A Project Coordinator is requir...

Recruitment Genius: Area Sales Manager - Midlands

£20000 - £25000 per annum: Recruitment Genius: This is an exciting opportunity...

Day In a Page

John Palmer: 'Goldfinger' of British crime was murdered, say police

Murder of the Brink’s-MAT mastermind

'Goldfinger' of British crime's life ended in a blaze of bullets, say police
Forget little green men - aliens will look like humans, says Cambridge University evolution expert

Forget little green men

Leading evolutionary biologist says aliens will look like humans
The Real Stories of Migrant Britain: An Algerian scientist adjusts to life working in a kebab shop

The Real Stories of Migrant Britain

An Algerian scientist struggles to adjust to her new life working in a Scottish kebab shop
Bodyworlds museum: Dr Gunther von Hagens has battled legal threats, Parkinson's disease, and the threat of bankruptcy

Dying dream of Doctor Death

Dr Gunther von Hagens has battled legal threats, Parkinson's disease, and the threat of bankruptcy
UK heatwave: Temperature reaches 39.8 degrees on Central Line - the sweatiest place in London

39.8 degrees recorded on Tube

There's hot (London) and too damn hot (the Underground). Simon Usborne braved the Central line to discover what its passengers suffer
Kitchens go hi-tech: From robot chefs to recipe-shopping apps, computerised cooking is coming

Computerised cooking is coming

From apps that automatically make shopping lists from your recipe books to smart ovens and robot chefs, Kevin Maney rounds up innovations to make your mouth water
Jessie Cave interview: The Harry Potter star has published a feminist collection of cartoons

Jessie Cave's feminist cartoons

The Harry Potter star tells Alice Jones how a one-night stand changed her life
Football Beyond Borders: Even the most distruptive pupils score at homework club

Education: Football Beyond Borders

Add football to an after-school homework club, and even the naughtiest boys can score
10 best barbecue books

Fire up the barbie: 10 best barbecue books

We've got Bibles to get you grilling and smoking like a true south American pro
Wimbledon 2015: Nick Bollettieri - Junk balls and chop and slice are only way 5ft 1in Kurumi Nara can live with Petra Kvitova’s power

Nick Bollettieri's Wimbledon Files

Junk balls and chop and slice are only way 5ft 1in Kurumi Nara can live with Petra Kvitova’s power
Ron Dennis exclusive: ‘This is one of the best McLaren teams ever – we are going to do it’

‘This is one of the best McLaren teams ever – we are going to do it’

Ron Dennis shrugs off a poor start to the season in an exclusive interview, and says the glory days will come back
Seifeddine Rezgui: What motivated a shy student to kill 38 holidaymakers in Tunisia?

Making of a killer

What motivated a shy student to kill 38 holidaymakers in Tunisia?
UK Heatwave: Temperatures on the tube are going to exceed the legal limit for transporting cattle

Just when you thought your commute couldn't get any worse...

Heatwave will see temperatures on the Tube exceed legal limit for transporting cattle
Exclusive - The Real Stories of Migrant Britain: Swapping Bucharest for London

The Real Stories of Migrant Britain

Meet the man who swapped Romania for the UK in a bid to provide for his family, only to discover that the home he left behind wasn't quite what it seemed
Cheaper energy on the way, but it's not all sunshine and rainbows

Cheaper energy on the way, but it's not all sunshine and rainbows

Solar power will help bring down electricity prices over the next five years, according to a new report. But it’s cheap imports of ‘dirty power’ that will lower them the most