Rushdie vs Greer

He says she's a 'double racist' over stance on Monica Ali's 'Brick Lane' movie. She wants a public debate

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

Something for the weekend in London: February 17-19

To some, February is the month of lurrrve, to others it's the month of rain, snow and flu, but for u...

CC kills more people than cervical cancer; why haven’t we heard about it?

There is a disease whose incidence is rising in the UK and most of the industrialised world. However...

We need to avoid another ‘lost generation’

A tiny green shoot one day, and then a chill wind the next. Anyone hoping for signs of economic spr...

More than half of Afghanistan’s families live in extreme poverty

Leila is watching her baby intently, as his mouth moves trying to swallow the small blob of yellow p...

The author and journalist Salman Rushdie has launched an outspoken attack on fellow literary heavyweight Germaine Greer.

The row, sparked by the controversial filming of Monica Ali's Brick Lane in east London, erupted yesterday when, in a letter in The Guardian, Rushdie attacked Greer over her support for those trying to block the project. Rushdie described Greer's stance as "philistine, sanctimonious and disgraceful, but not unexpected".

He accused the celebrated feminist of "double racism", and then attacked her over her refusal to sign a petition defending Rushdie at the height of the storm over his The Satanic Verses in the early 1990s. "As I well remember, she has done this before," he wrote. "At the height of the assault against The Satanic Verses, Germaine Greer stated, 'I refuse to sign petitions for this book of his, which was about his own troubles.' She went on to describe me as 'a megalomaniac, an Englishman with dark skin'. Now it's Monica Ali's turn to be deracinated by Germaine."

Greer provoked heated debate last week when she defended Bangladeshi activists who threatened to take to the streets to stop filming of Ali's novel in the area where much of it is set. Her stance drew the scathing riposte from Rushdie, whose 1989 novel gave rise to a fatwah on his life.

In an echo of those protests, some activists in east London have indicated that they would be willing to see copies of Brick Lane burnt. "She [Ali] has the right to freedom of speech; we have the right to burn books," a protester said last week.

Some Bangladeshis, mainly from the Sylhet area in north-eastern Bangladesh, claim the novel portrays them as uneducated and "dirty".

Writing in The Guardian herself last week, Greer attacked Ali for ignoring the feelings of people in the Sylhet community. "As British people know little and care less about the Bangladeshi people in their midst," wrote Greer, "their first appearance as characters in an English novel had the force of a defining caricature."

On Thursday the film's production company, Ruby Films, announced that on police advice it would shoot the remaining scenes at sites away from Brick Lane. However, a demonstration is still due to take place today.

Last night, Greer refused to be riled by Rushdie's words. She told the IoS: "Salman may go on about this as much as he likes. But I believe there should be a public debate on the subject."

Brick Lane, shortlisted for the Booker Prize in 2003, follows a Bangladeshi woman as she moves to London, marries a Bengali man, and has two children. The book made Ali, 38, an overnight literary sensation.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

New technology means doctors will soon be able to regulate and monitor drug intake remotely – as long as patients remember to swallow their chips
Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Former Libertine talks frankly and exclusively about Kate Moss, Amy Winehouse, his baby daughter and why he paints with his own blood
Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10 (but Blair's still the leading earner)

Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10...

... but Blair's still the leading earner
The West Bank's Bobby Sands

The West Bank's Bobby Sands

Khader Adnan's two-month hunger strike has made him a hero among Palestinians outraged by Israel's policy of arbitrary detention
Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Paul McCartney has given up smoking dope. Simon Usborne charts a career of highs and lows
MI5 helped US in fruitless search for Charlie Chaplin's Communist past

Investigating Charlie Chaplin

MI5 helped US in fruitless search for star's Communist past
Eat, drink, man, woman: Is there such a thing as a gastronomic gender divide?

Is there such a thing as a gastronomic gender divide?

A dainty piece of sushi for the lady? And perhaps a rare steak for the gentleman?
A very good cuppa: Some of our best restaurants are embracing the afternoon tea tradition

A very good cuppa: Restaurants embrace afternoon tea tradition

You don’t have to visit a tourist trap, says Luke Blackall
The 10 Best Juicers

The 10 Best Juicers

From the Bistro drip-stop to Cook's Essentials' retro juicer...
How to make cheese in a matter of minutes

How to make cheese in a matter of minutes

You won't even need to go to the shops for supplies, as Will Dean discovers.
The day I danced for a place in Danny Boyle's Olympics spectacular

The day I danced for a place in Danny Boyle's Olympics spectacular

Tom Peck auditioned for the London 2012 opening ceremony. But was he asked back?
Is Wenger finished at Arsenal?

Is Wenger finished at Arsenal?

Milan debacle shows manager has let Gunners become an average team who are set to fall further
Ronnie Henry: Tale of the two Ronnies shows that it really is a funny old game

Tale of the two Ronnies shows that it really is a funny old game

Ronnie Henry won '61 Double with Spurs. His grandson failed to make it at the Lane but will now captain Stevenage when the clubs meet in the FA Cup
Dereck Chisora: From drugs and weapons to a fight with Dr Ironfist

Dereck Chisora interview

From drugs and weapons to a fight with Dr Ironfist
London Eye: A taste of the high life from the man who found Bleasdale

Simon Turnbull's London Eye

A taste of the high life from the man who found Bleasdale