World

Partly Sunny with Showers 9° London Hi 12°C / Lo 6°C

Britain's 'shameful' failure to respond to UN calls for aid

By Daniel Howden in Nairobi

The UK has been singled out for its "shameful" failure to send aid to the world's worst refugee crisis unfolding on the remote border between Kenya and war-torn Somalia.

A flood of refugees fleeing the relentless conflict in Somalia has crossed into the already poverty-stricken north of Kenya prompting an emergency appeal from the UN for fresh funds to avert a humanitarian catastrophe.

The UK is among a handful of rich nations who have so far ignored the UN call for $92m and have failed to offer any assistance according to the respected NGO Human Rights Watch.

Three camps around the town of Dadaab are now sheltering 260,000 people, the largest concentration of refugees anywhere in the world, in appalling conditions.

Gerry Simpson, a refugee researcher with Human Rights Watch described Britain's failure to answer the appeal or contribute to the existing UN refugee agency budget for Dadaab as "shameful".

"The UK has given nothing which is extremely disappointing considering its close ties to Kenya," Mr Simpson said at the launch of a new report on the refugee crisis, "From Horror to Hopelessness". "It's also questionable considering UK involvement in international policy for Somalia."

Somalia was convulsed in late 2006 by a US-backed Ethiopian invasion aimed at overthrowing an emerging Islamic government since which the refugee population in Dadaab has swollen by more than 50 percent. The UK lent its support to the intervention which has been widely criticised for making a bad situation worse in the Horn of Africa. The subsequent failed occupation has seen the already ravaged country become more unstable and some 330 people are reported to be crossing into Kenya every day.

Massive overcrowding and chronic lack of facilities mean those who are trying to escape the continuing war face dire conditions ranging from food and water shortages, cholera outbreaks, to attacks and extortion at the hands of corrupt Kenyan police, the rights group claimed.

The bulk of the present inadequate funding comes from the US, Japan and the European Commission, while Italy, Germany, Sweden and Norway all contribute to the USD19m annual budget for the existing camps. Those camps need to be supplemented by at least three new facilities, according to the UN's refugee agency UNHCR, and USD92m is being urgently sought from international donors. However, those appeals have so far gone unanswered, with some analysts suggesting that donors are waiting for the crisis to worsen before taking any action.

" At the moment it's like pulling teeth. Donors aren't increasing their funding, it seems they're waiting for a fresh crisis to break out," said Mr Simpson.

That crisis could be a conflict between local Kenyans and the refugees, a fresh outbreak of disease or even a catastrophic fire in the arid and overcrowded camps.

In another recent report the UK charity Oxfam described conditions at Dadaab as "conducive to a public health crisis."

Philippa Crosland-Taylor, head of Oxfam GB in Kenya, said: "Conditions in Dadaab are dire and need immediate attention. People are not getting the aid they are entitled to. Half of the people in the camp do not have access to enough water."

Kenya's decision to close the border with its troubled northern neighbour in 2007 in order to stem the flow of suspected Islamic militants has made the situation even worse, said the rights group.

The Somali refugees are also being preyed upon by a "corrupt and predatory police" who are arbitrarily arresting asylum seekers and forcibly deporting those that can't or won't pay bribes. After conducting extensive interviews in the Dadaab camp the rights group found that women had been raped by police, while others had been shot or beaten while in custody. The Kenyan police strongly rejected the report.

"It is not worth the paper it is written on," police spokesman Eric Kiraithe said. "I challenge you to do one thing: Go to the areas mentioned, with a copy of that report, then you will come to realize that a lot of it is imagined."

Earlier this month they were accused by the UN of running death squads and carrying out hundreds of extra-judicial killings, claims they also rejected.

The lack of even basic funding for the refugee crisis in Dadaab contrasts sharply with the billions of dollars of military and civilian assets that have been mustered to deal with the problem of piracy off the Somalia coast. A huge EU taskforce, including British vessels, has joined the US navy, and ships from Japan and India among others in a costly operation to stop the hijackings in the shipping lanes in the Gulf of Aden.

The daily budget for these operations dwarves the amount the UN is appealing for to help the human fallout from the conflict in the same country.

"When there are commercial interests at stake there is always money to solve the problem," said Mr Simpson. "When it's just women and children in camps there is not."

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Gerry Simpson talks crap
[info]repton4 wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 03:39 am (UTC)
Gerry Simpson talks a load of crap just how much money and help do the people of Britain have to give to theses people, he forgets to say year after year the British people give millions to third world countrys and what do we get in return this idiot spouting off about how shameful we are, We are nation going bust we look after enough immigrants and asylum seekers as it is, And before some one pulls out the racist card which is used to silence critics, intimidate opponents, i am not racist, i am just honest and tell it how it is

Re: Gerry Simpson talks crap
[info]jo_sparkles wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 06:33 am (UTC)
Repton4; I agree with you to an extent. We seem to do so much for people in need in 3rd world countries. It is awful to see people suffering, but I wonder which other 'rich' European countries have contributed as much as the UK?

There are people and organisations in need in the UK and I hope the government uses any available resources to look after them first before seeing to others' needs.
So why is it shameful?
[info]gondorplace wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 06:47 am (UTC)
It is the nature of this country to ignore the consequence of its own exploitation. We bomb people for their own good. We give no benefits to immigrants, we tax them over the limit, yet we blame them for the failures of British bankers. Why is not giving money to an African country a problem?
hmm cant help them all
[info]bowesy wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 07:36 am (UTC)
well sadly africa is africa and no matter what comes in this type of situation will always exist. Millions upon millions have been given and wasted in Kenya alone by corrupt politicians and misspent by NGO's.

If you have lived around the third world you will see NGO's driving big landcruisers burning up money on a sort of party aid basis. THe real problems are where the money is spent and by whom - giving cash willy nilly fails.

What car do you drive there Mr Simpson and where do you live?
I wouldn't give any money to the UN either...
[info]pronk153 wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 07:41 am (UTC)
Im writing this in Somalia where i work for an NGO that actually gets things done. The UN here and in Nairobi is corrupt, inefficient and funding them is a complete waste of time and money. The main reason is that the UN takes donor money, takes 20% MINIMUM in management fees, and then hands it out to NGO's who are actually able to do the work. Hopefully the UK government has realised this and is funding the NGOs directly. An awful lot of any money donated in good faith to the UN goes on maintaining fancy lifestyles for incompetent UN bureaucrats in Nairobi...would you be content as a UK taxpayer to know that the UN overnight allowance rate for Nairobi (additional to already large salaries and good benefits) is around $250 per night? I support the UK government on this, hopefully if more governments reduce funding to the UN it will force them into reform. The suffering people in Somalia and in the refugee camps in Kenya are so very poorly served by the UN
Commonwealth vs lose wealth.
[info]auntyeunice wrote:
Tuesday, 31 March 2009 at 07:59 am (UTC)
I have to agree with the author, not enough is being done to help people in the third world especially Africa. According to my MEP Britain sends £6.3 million an hour to fat corrupt Europeans in the EUck. I have read that European Commission aid takes a year to organise and takes a fair percentage of the aid money to pay for the Eurocrats. Perhaps we could help both ourselves and those who are desperate in Africa if we should leave the undemocratic EUck and give the money to the starving to help them stay alive instead of sending it to the fat to keep them fat. We are part of the Commonwealth, funnily enough so is Kenya, so why don't we help them with their refugee problem. Bind ourselves wholeheartedly with the Commonwealth and we have more countries spread over the world to work with and gain influence through than those in Europe, and help millions while we are at it.
Who should Pay
[info]xyberia44 wrote:
Wednesday, 1 April 2009 at 07:07 pm (UTC)
Well the obvious one to pay for Somalian refugees is China, who is Arming the Somalian Militias, This is typicalof the Chinese Involvement in Africa, Supply arms to Opressive regimes, militias and anyone who wants a gun for some minerals, Chian reap all their natural resources and let the west pay for humanitarian Aid.....It is Time China starts to Pay for its Flow of Cheap Landmines, and Cheap Guns and Ammunition to proven human rights abusers all over Africa...

If any nation should be on the List of terrorist nations it Should be CHINA........Iran and North Korea are just boyscouts in comaprisson to the Chinese....

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date