On day three of Bill Cosby’s sexual assault trial, the comedian’s defence team attempted to paint his accuser as inconsistent, and their relationship as consensual – even romantic.
Mr Cosby is accused of sexually assaulting Andrea Constand, the former head of the women’s basketball program at Temple University, at his Pennsylvania home in 2004.
Ms Constand is the only one of more than 50 of Mr Cosby's accusers who has secured a trial. Mr Cosby has pleaded not guilty in the Constand case and denies all other allegations.
Ms Constand had previously testified that Mr Cosby drugged and molested her when she visited his home for dinner one night. She claimed to have “passed out” after taking what Mr Cosby told her were "herbal pills," and awoke to his hands moving underneath her clothes.
“In my head I was trying to get my hands to move or my legs to move, but I was frozen,” she said.
In a three-hour-long cross examination on Wednesday, Mr Cosby’s legal team attempted to cast doubt on Ms Constand’s version of events.
Bill Cosby: Career in pictures
Bill Cosby: Career in pictures
1/20 Bill Cosby
Winner of his first Emmy for 'I Spy' is Bill Cosby being congratulated by his wife Camille held at Americana Hotel, 1966
2/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby in 'I Spy', 1960s
3/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby in July 1973 in Perth
4/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby and Richard Pryor in 'California Suite', 1978
5/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby and Elmo in Sesame Street, 1989
6/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby poses for a picture with Florence Griffith-Joyner in June 1989
7/20 Bill Cosby
Comedian Bill Cosby back in 1992
8/20 Bill Cosby
A scene from a 1992 episode of 'The Cosby Show'
9/20 Bill Cosby
US Monica Seles breaks into laughter as she jokes with comedian Bill Cosby during a celebrity match in the stadium at the US Open for the Arthur Ashe AIDS Challenge on 27 August 1995
10/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby meets Toronto Blue Jays' All-Star Joe Carter after the Stars played the Stripes in the Celebrity All-Star game which preceded workouts for the 67th All-Star Game at Veterans Stadium on 8 July 1996 in Philadephia
11/20 Bill Cosby
Co-hosts Oprah Winfrey and Bill Cosby joke with each other during the opening of the 2000 Essence Awards 14 April 2000 at Radio City Music Hall in New York City
12/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby jokes with baseball great Hank Aaron after they both received the Presidential Medal of Freedom Award from U.S. President George W. Bush during a ceremony on 9 July 2002 at the White House in Washington
13/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby poses backstage after winning the 'Bob Hope Humanitarian Award' during the 55th Annual Primetime Emmy Awards at the Shrine Auditorium on 21 September 2003 in Los Angeles
14/20 Bill Cosby
'Tonight Show' host Jay Leno and comedian Bill Cosby laugh during a surprise visit by Cosby to sign a Harley-Davidson motorcycle that Leno is using to raise money for the victims of Hurricane Katrina at NBC studios on 9 September 2005 in Burbank, California
15/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby speaks during a taping of 'Meet the Press' at the NBC studios on 14 October 2007 in Washington
16/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby at the 12th annual Mark Twain Prize for American Humor at the John F. Kennedy Center on 26 October 2009 in Washington
17/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby speaks at the National Action Network's 20th annual Keepers of the Dream Awards gala in New York on 6 April 2011
18/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby during the 100th anniversary celebration of the Beverly Hills Hotel & Bungalows supporting the Motion Picture & Television Fund and the American Comedy Fund, 2012
19/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby speaks onstage at the Thurgood Marshall College Fund 25th Awards Gala on 11 November 2013 in Washington
20/20 Bill Cosby
Bill Cosby performs at the Treasure Island Hotel & Casino on 26 September 2014 in Las Vegas
Because the case lacks forensic evidence – and Mr Cosby is not expected to take the stand – the verdict rests largely on the jury’s interpretation of his accuser’s testimony. The defence relied largely on phone records and the 44-year-old’s prior statements to construct their case.
Much of the cross-examination focused on 16 March, 2004 – the date Ms Constand initially told police the alleged assault occurred. Later, she would testify that the assault happened before this, and that 16 March was the night she had planned to confront Cosby about it.
“March 16 is an important date in this case, because it went from the day – the night – that you were drugged and assaulted, to something else,” a defence attorney said.
“Yes ma’am, I said I was mistaken,” Ms Constand replied.
The defence tried to suggest Ms Constand had changed her narrative after accessing her phone records, and realising they conflicted with her version of events. Ms Constand maintains she never accessed such records.
Cosby’s attorneys also faulted Ms Constand for not initially disclosing the number of private meetings she had had with the actor. Ms Constand says the officers simply never asked.
Aside from the timing of Ms Constand’s meetings with Mr Cosby, the defence also raised questions about their nature.
The 44-year-old testified on Tuesday that she saw Mr Cosby as a “mentor,” and considered him “somewhat of an older figure”. The defence, however, painted a different picture.
In one incident, attorneys suggested, Ms Constand attended a private, fire-lit dinner with the comedian. The two drank brandy and lit incense, defence attorneys claimed.
“The lights were dim and the fire was going, correct?” an attorney asked Ms Constand.
“I don’t really remember how dim the lights were, but I did have to eat my dinner,” she replied.
The six-foot tall former athlete was reserved and quiet on Wednesday morning, answering the defence’s questions but not expanding on her version of events.
Security guards said the entire trial was quieter than the days proceeding, when curious community members and media packed the halls of the Montgomery County, Pennsylvania courtroom.
In previous days, the prosecution had called another of Mr Cosby’s accusers to the stand to testify. They hoped to prove a pattern of behaviour in the celebrity’s past.
If Mr Cosby is convicted, he could be sentenced to a jail term of up to 10 years.Reuse content