World

Mostly Cloudy with Showers 13° London Hi 16°C / Lo 8°C

My heartbreak over Bill's affair. But does Hillary's story ring true?

Mrs Clinton's keenly awaited memoirs come out on Monday and those wanting scandal will not be disappointed

By Rupert Cornwell in Washington

As holidays from hell go, they can't come much more hellish than the one Bill and Hillary Clinton spent on Martha's Vineyard in the summer of Monica in 1998. "I felt nothing but profound sadness, disappointment and unresolved anger," writes the wronged spouse. "I could barely speak to Bill and when I did it was a tirade. I read. I walked on the beach. He slept upstairs and I slept downstairs."

As holidays from hell go, they can't come much more hellish than the one Bill and Hillary Clinton spent on Martha's Vineyard in the summer of Monica in 1998. "I felt nothing but profound sadness, disappointment and unresolved anger," writes the wronged spouse. "I could barely speak to Bill and when I did it was a tirade. I read. I walked on the beach. He slept upstairs and I slept downstairs."

Thus Hillary Clinton felt on the ghastly days immediately after her husband finally reversed seven months of lies to confess to her that he had indeed engaged in "an inappropriate intimacy" with the White House intern - the episode that inevitably will dominate the hoop-la over her memoirs, one of the most keenly awaited publishing events of the year.

Living History, 580 pages of it, appears in the book stores on Monday, preceded by a prime-time interview on Sunday night with Barbara Walters, and by an advance print run of a million by Simon & Schuster.

Mrs Clinton said yesterday: "I've touched on the good times and not so good times." But forget the debacle over her plan to reform America's health care or the rollercoaster of Middle East peace-making. Punters will be parting with $28 (£17) for one thing above all: Hillary's version of the Monica Lewinsky affair, which threatened her marriage, overshadowed Bill Clinton's eight years in the White House and led to the first impeachment of a sitting president in 130 years. The excerpts obtained by Associated Press suggest that they will not be disappointed.

Ever since the first reports of the dalliance surfaced in January 1998, the 42nd president insisted nothing had happened: "I did not have sexual relations with that woman." To Hillary he insisted that he had befriended the intern when she asked for help in getting a job and that he had "talked to her a few times". But when Mr Clinton was summoned before a grand jury, the game was up. On the morning of Saturday 15 August, 1998, two days before he was to testify, he woke up his wife, paced at her bedside "and told me that the situation was far more serious than he had previously acknowledged".

Whether Mrs Clinton should have been surprised is arguable, after the Gennifer Flowers affair, the Paula Jones allegations and sundry other tales of Mr Clinton's philanderings in his days as Governor of Arkansas. But surprised she seems to have been, and devastated. "I could hardly breathe," she recounts. "Gulping for air I started crying and yelling at him, 'What do you mean? What are you saying? Why did you lie to me?' I was furious and getting more so by the second. He just stood there, saying over and over again, 'I'm sorry. I'm so sorry. I was trying to protect you and Chelsea.'"

Until then, according to Mrs Clinton, she truly had been convinced the whole Lewinsky affair was - in the phrase that has entered the United States' political vocabulary - a "vast right-wing conspiracy" mounted by her husband's political enemies, who could still not accept the results of two White House elections.

"I was dumbfounded, heartbroken and outraged that I'd believed him at all," Mrs Clinton writes. On 17 August, President Clinton gave his cringe-making testimony to the grand jury ("it depends what the meaning of 'is' is") and a few days later, the family left for their long-scheduled holiday on the Vineyard. With some understatement yesterday, Lisa Caputo, press secretary to Mrs Clinton when she was First Lady, said the atmosphere at the Clintons' borrowed house at the exclusive resort island was "a bit surreal". As Mrs Clinton tells it: "Buddy the dog came along to keep Bill company. He was the only member of our family who was still willing to."

Whether or not Mrs Clinton was naive in accepting her husband's initial denials, few wronged women have had to live out their humiliation and embarrassment in such public circumstances. She gives a hint of her anguish when she writes that "the most difficult decisions I have made in my life were to stay married to Bill and to run for the Senate from New York". In fact, she says, the latter helped to heal the wounds between them, allowing the couple to talk about something other than the future of their relationship. "Over time we both began to relax," she says. Whatever the precise state of the Clinton marriage, it seems certain to survive.

Indeed, Living History is probably as much a springboard for the future as a record of a turbulent past. Mrs Clinton, by all accounts, has been a resounding success on Capitol Hill since she became Senator in January 2001 and many Democrats wish - none too privately - that she would throw her hat into the ring to challenge George Bush next year.

In fact, 2004 is out. Far more likely is a presidential bid by Mrs Clinton in 2008, assuming Mr Bush is re-elected this time round. She has been careful not to rule out the possibility. In the meantime, she is the Democratic party's most effective fundraiser after her husband.

Her summer-long national tour to promote the book is bound to eclipse the toilings of the nine declared Democratic candidates as they struggle to win national attention. Polls show that if she were to run, Mrs Clinton would beat the lot of them hollow.

First, however, she will have to banish the ghosts of the past, and Living History, billed as a "complete and candid" telling of her White House years, is clearly part of that process. She insists that Whitewater, the arcane story of an Arkansas land deal gone wrong "never seemed real because it wasn't". The only mistake of the Clintons lay in the poor public relations employed as the controversy grew.

For its part, Simon & Schuster, which shelled out an $8m (£4.9m) advance, is hoping that the old rule holds true, that books by first ladies sell much better than ones by presidents. Proof will come next year, when Bill Clinton is expected to publish his own memoirs, for which Alfred Knopf has paid a staggering $10m advance.

THE OTHER WOMEN

JUANITA BROADDRICK

She was a Democratic party volunteer for Bill Clinton's bid to be elected governor of Arkansas in 1978. Twenty years later she claimed Mr Clinton had raped her in a hotel room during a conference. Mr Clinton denied the charges, and the case never went to court.

GENNIFER FLOWERS

During the 1992 election campaign, Gennifer Flowers alleged that she had an affair with Mr Clinton while he was governor of Arkansas. She sold tapes of their phone conversations, prompting the Clintons to admit on television to problems in their marriage.

PAULA JONES

In 1994 Paula Jones filed a formal complaint alleging that Mr Clintonmade sexual advances to her in his hotel room in 1991, when he was governor of Arkansas. Jones said that she was demoted as a result of the incident. The case was thrown out for lack of evidence.

MONICA LEWINSKY

Ms Lewinsky was an unpaid White House intern when Mr Clinton took an interest in her. The president was impeached in 1998 on perjury and obstruction of justice charges relating to the affair, but the Senate declined to have him removed from office.

Post a Comment

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.


Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date