World

Partly Sunny with Showers 10° London Hi 11°C / Lo 7°C

As Taiwan typhoon clear-up begins, so do the questions

President is jeered on tour of disaster area as victims ask why he took so long to accept foreign aid

By Clifford Coonan in Kaohsiung, Taiwan

Survivors run towards a rescue helicopter in Namsha in Kaohsiung County, southern Taiwan yesterday. Thousands are still trapped in villages across southern and central Taiwan

CNA / AFP / GETTY IMAGES

Survivors run towards a rescue helicopter in Namsha in Kaohsiung County, southern Taiwan yesterday. Thousands are still trapped in villages across southern and central Taiwan

As Taiwan begins the painful process of recovery following last weekend's devastating typhoon, which left hundreds dead and missing, pressure is mounting on the country's President over his handling of the crisis.

President Ma Ying-jeou has been forced to apologise to survivors who say his government's rescue effort has been too slow. There have also been calls for a government reshuffle.

Yesterday he provided a new estimate of 500 deaths in the floods and mudslides unleashed by Typhoon Morakot. He gave the figure at a national security meeting – the first such emergency meeting Mr Ma has called since taking power 15 months ago. The official count of confirmed deaths still stood at 118.

Internal opposition has been further catalysed by Mr Ma having persistently declared that the country did not need foreign aid, only to subsequently perform an embarrassing U-turn. "I'm sorry," the beleaguered president said repeatedly as he visited a flood-ravaged Taoist temple and devastated orchards in the south-western county of Tainan earlier this week.

Arriving by helicopter at a relief centre in the town of Chishan, also in the south, he found himself jeered by angry locals. "We're busy here," they shouted. "Go and help the people, don't come here." At other stop-offs, protesters held banners saying: "The government is inept."

"The whole thing looks in disarray, in the public's opinion," Alex Chiang, a teacher of political science at the National Cheng Chi University in Taipei, told the Associated Press. "They were caught off-guard."

In the face of the strong criticism, the President called on rescue crews to step up their efforts yesterday, ordering the police force to add cadets to their post-disaster team and sending 10,000 more servicemen to the affected areas.

Although the government also announced an additional NT$3bn (£55m) in relief funds over the next two years, the momentum was against Mr Ma as a high-profile internet campaign asked the world for donations because – its organisers said – the government was doing nothing. President Ma has been forced to deny press reports that his government had refused US assistance.

Taipei has now accepted a relief donation of $250,000 (£150,000) from the American Institute in Taiwan. And rescuers who have been relying on under-powered helicopters to reach the worst-hit areas have now asked foreign governments for larger choppers capable of carrying earth-moving equipment and shelters. But the President's delayed acceptance of foreign help has come too late to avoid his handling of the disaster having an impact on forthcoming city and county elections, in which support for his Kuomintang Nationalist Party is expected to fall.

Premier Liu Chao-shiuan has avoided addressing the volte-face, focussing instead on having government agencies draw up a list of what help they need. Typhoon Morakot tore through Taiwan over two days, leaving nearly two thirds of central and southern Taiwan under waters over five metres deep in many places.

It hit a part of the country where Mr Ma has never been popular, even when he was swept to power by a large margin in March 2008, after his arch-rival Chen Shui-bian, currently in jail facing corruption charges, stepped down. The south of the country remains the power base of Mr Chen's Democratic People's Party, and their supporters have been visible wherever the Harvard-educated Mr Ma has gone in the typhoon zone.

Typhoon Morakot destroyed the homes of 7,000 people and caused agricultural and property damage in excess of NT$50bn. President Ma called it the most severe damage to the island in more than 50 years. "While the rescue operation is still going on, we have started rehabilitation and reconstruction work, which is just as pressing as relief efforts but might be even more difficult and cumbersome," he said.

So far, 15,400 villagers have been ferried to safety, and rescuers are working to save another 1,900 people still stuck. Mr Ma said the new estimated death toll includes about 380 people feared buried in the debris of a landslide in Hsiao Lin, the hardest-hit village.

The military finally opened a road to Hsiao Lin yesterday, but authorities have given up hope of finding anyone alive under the tons of mud that now cover the village. Kaohsiung county chief Yang Chiu-hsing said that instead of digging into some 170 mud-buried homes, a memorial park will be built on the site.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

mud slides
[info]slimemoldlives wrote:
Saturday, 15 August 2009 at 12:18 pm (UTC)
There's been lots of deforestation in the mountains, clearly leaving the villages vulnerable.
It's the 7th day...
[info]bonjour_taipei wrote:
Saturday, 15 August 2009 at 04:00 pm (UTC)
At first I didn't want to blame Ma's government because I thought it was more important to focus on rescue opperation. Yet, as we are racing to save villagers in remote mountain areas, it just makes me really angry to see how inept this government is! Typhoons are common at this time of year in Taiwan, but typhoon morakot is different...Although in terms of size it's small/or middle, it dumped more than 1/2 annual rain in most areas and 2/3 rain in the worst hit mountainous areas of the island.

It's hard to survive when the floods and landslide happen because they come too fast! But the disaster didn't just happen as soon as rain fell becaue it rained heavily for 2 days (since night on the 7th of August)!! At least the government had 1-day time to force the mountain residents to leave. Why couldn't the government react sooner so more mountain villagers could be evacuated before the disaster?

Please help my country. Here is the relief funds donations campaign website, including all updated information and all relief funds donations (government, religious groups, etc). Taiwan traditional Chinese version-> http://www.ptt.cc/emergency The English version is http://sites.google.com/site/emergencyptt/english

We appreciate any kind help you give. Thank you so much for your kindness.

Terrible red tape
[info]kathyatseattle wrote:
Monday, 17 August 2009 at 07:40 am (UTC)
Typhoon Morakot not only heavily damages the lives in Taiwan but also reveals the inability of this Ma government. This government has terrible management and worst administration system ever seen, could I please your media report more news about this situation? The pressure from foreign media will push this government to move fast, to save more lives if possible, and to help those mountain residents rebuild their home. This Ma government really needs to be monitored.

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date