A CNN journalist reporting on the huge warehouse fire in the Chinese port city of Tianjin has been accosted by angry locals outside a hospital.
Will Ripley was speaking live to the studio via Skype on his mobile phone when he was approached by an increasingly irate group of men, shouting over and appearing to shove the reporter.
The incident, broadcast on CNN, was captured by Ripley’s increasingly shaky camerawork before the feed went black and the network cut back to the studio.
CNN is believed to have initially described the incident as Ripley getting “shut down by officials” outside the hospital in Tianjin, where he was describing the aftermath of a series of explosions that have killed at least 50 people and injured more than 700.
That description was later changed to Ripley getting “swarmed by distraught survivors” in an online CNN posting headlined “Emotions run high at Chinese hospital after blasts”.
Ripley himself wrote on Twitter that tempers were “obviously running high after an awful night in #Tianjin”. He added: “I'm fine. A lot of people here aren't.”
He also retweeted New York Times reporter Andrew Jacobs, who said “grief-stricken relatives inexplicitly [sic] attack foreign journalists shouting ‘stop the foreigners from reporting’”.
Chinese social media users painted a different picture, however. In postings on Weibo and YouTube, they suggested Ripley had tried to sneak inside the hospital with a selfie-stick to “take pics of the dead”.
Tempers obviously running high after an awful night in #Tianjin. I'm fine. A lot of people here aren't. At least 400 injured & 17 killed.— Will Ripley (@willripleyCNN) August 12, 2015
Outside hosptial in Tianjin, grief stricken relatives inexplicitly attack foreign journalists shouting "stop the foreigners from reporting."— Andrew Jacobs (@AndrewJacobsNYT) August 13, 2015
A version of the footage posted was also posted online with a caption saying that the people were shouting “sorrow”, and accused CNN of sending “one unprofessional journalist to try to break into the hospital with only an iPhone for equipment”.
In response, Jacobs described this as a “complete fabrication”, saying the tussle was sparked by a man who was angry at his grieving friend being filmed.
The fire in Tianjin was mostly under control by mid-afternoon on Thursday, local time, when local government officials suspended the work of firefighters so that chemical experts could examine the site.
Tianjin Explosion - In Pictures
Tianjin Explosion - In Pictures
1/14 Tiajin Explosion
A man wearing a mask walks past overturned shipping containers after explosions hit the Binhai new district in Tianjin. Two massive explosions caused by flammable goods ripped through an industrial area in the northeast Chinese port city of Tianjin late on Wednesday, killing 17 people and injuring around 400, official Chinese media reported.
A screen grab from taken from state broadcaster China Central Television (CCTV) footage on August 12, 2015 shows a huge explosion in the northern Chinese port city of Tianjin.
3/14 Tianjin Explosion
Excavators work near the site of the explosions at the Binhai new district, Tianji
4/14 Tianjin Explosion
A man who was injured following the massive explosions at the Binhai new district in Tianjin receives medical treatment at a hospital.
5/14 Tianjin Explosion
View of the destruction after explosions in the port area of Tianjin, northern China,
6/14 Tianjin Explosion
A emergency worker is lifted by a crane as smokes plumes from the explosion site in Binhai new district in Tianjin
7/14 Tianjin Explosion
A damaged truck is seen on a highway near the site of the explosions at the Binhai new district in Tianjin
8/14 Tianjin Explosion
Flames rise as a banner in the background reads "no illegal operations" at the site of a series of explosions in Tianjin, witnesses described a fireball from the blasts ripping through the night sky.
9/14 Tianjn Explosion
Smoke rises from shipping containers after explosions at Binhai new district in Tianjin, China.
10/14 Tianjn Explosion
Firefighters take a break after trying to put fire down at the explosion site in Binhai new district in Tianjin,
11/14 Tianjn Explosion
A survivor talk on his mobile phone at the site of the explosions at the Binhai new district in Tianjin
12/14 Tianjin Explosion
Firefighter's truck and other rescue vehicles are pictured as smoke rises among shipping containers after explosions at Binhai new district in Tianjin
13/14 Tianjn Explosion
Damaged cars are seen near the site of explosions at the Binhai new district in Tianjin
14/14 Tianjn Explosion
A paramilitary policeman wears a mask as he blocks the road leading to evacuated residential area and the explosion site in Binhai new district in Tianjin
The safety of emergency workers at the scene has become an increasingly contentious point among Chinese social media posts, with at least 12 of those killed in the blasts confirmed to be firefighters.
This may be the most retweeted Weibo posting as of now pic.twitter.com/3lwCkbzl9b— Guobin Yang (@Yangguobin) August 13, 2015
One of the most widely-shared images on Weibo has been one showing a firefighter in orange walking towards a fire as everyone else runs away.Reuse content