Driver liable for fatigue illness after accident

LAW REPORT: 12 May 1995

Page v Smith, House of Lords (Lord Keith of Kinkel, Lord Ackner, Lord Jauncey of Tullichettle, Lord Browne-Wilkinson and Lord Lloyd of Berwick).

11 May 1995.

A driver of a car who negligently causes an accident is liable for psychiatric illness suffered by a victim of the accident, even if the victim suffered no physical injury since any driver should reasonably foresee that if he drives carelessly he will be liable to cause injury, either physical or psychiatric or both, to others involved in an accident.

The House of Lords (Lord Keith and Lord Jauncey dissenting) restored Mr Justice Otton's award of damages to the plaintiff of £162,153.

The plaintiff, who had suffered from myalgic encephalomyelitis or chronic fatigue syndrome, was driving at about 30mph when the defendant cut across the road. There was a collision. Although the plaintiff suffered no bodily injury, his condition of chronic fatigue became permanent. He claimed damages for personal injuries caused by the defendant's negligence. Mr Justice Otton found in the plaintiff's favour.

The Court of Appeal allowed the defendant's appeal on the basis that psychiatric illness which had not resulted from physical injury was not reasonably foreseeable in a person of ordinary fortitude.

Colin Mackay QC and Jennifer Richards (Edward Lewis) for the plaintiff; Julian Priest QC and Andrew Hogarth (Harry R Pearce) for the defendant.

LORD LLOYD said the plaintiff was directly involved in the accident and well within the range of foreseeable physical injury. He was the primary victim. Those who were not directly involved in an accident but who suffered from what they saw or heard were the secondary victims.

Foreseeability of psychiatric injury remained a crucial ingredient when the plaintiff was the secondary victim for the very reason that the secondary victim was almost always outside the area of physical impact and therefore outside the range of foreseeable physical injury. But where the plaintiff was the primary victim, the defendant was under a duty of care not to cause the plaintiff foreseeable physical injury, and it was unnecessary to ask whether he was under a separate duty of care not to cause foreseeable psychiatric injury.

In an age when medical knowledge was expanding fast, and psychiatric knowledge with it, it would not be sensible to commit the law to a distinction between physical and psychiatric injury. Nothing would be gained by treating them as different "kinds" of physical injury so as to require the application of different tests in law.

It could not be right that a negligent defendant should escape liability for psychiatric injury just because, though serious physical injury was foreseeable, it did not in fact transpire.

In the case of secondary victims, foreseeability of injury and a degree of proximity were required as control mechanisms to limit the number of potential claimants. Those mechanisms were not required in the case of a primary victim. Nor, in the case of a primary victim, was it appropriate to ask whether he was a person of "ordinary phlegm". In the case of physical injury the negligent defendant took his victim as he found him.

There was no difference between an eggshell skull and an eggshell personality. It was only when shock was followed by recognisable psychiatric illness that the defendant might be held liable. It was enough to ask whether the defendant should have reasonably foreseen that the plaintiff might suffer physical injury. It was unnecessary to ask as a separate question, whether the defendant should reasonably have foreseen injury by shock; and it was irrelevant that the plaintiff did not suffer any external physical injury.

LORD ACKNER and LORD BROWNE-WILKINSON concurred.

LORD KEITH, dissenting, said that a reasonable man in the position of the defendant would not have have foreseen that such an accident might inflict on a person of normal susceptibility such mental trauma as to result in illness.

LORD JAUNCEY, also dissenting, said that it was not foreseeable that the plaintiff would suffer nervous shock as a result of this accident.

Ying Hui Tan, Barrister

PROMOTED VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
News
ebookA unique anthology of reporting and analysis of a crucial period of history
Sport
Manchester United's kit for the 2014/15 season
football
News
Nadine Gordimer died peacefully at home yesterday
peopleNobel laureate was a powerful anti-Apartheid voice
Extras
indybest
Arts and Entertainment
Neil Young performs on stage at Hyde Park
musicAnd his Hyde Park set has rhyme and reason, writes Nick Hasted
News
Women have been desperate to possess dimples like Cheryl Cole's
people Cole has secretly married French boyfriend Jean-Bernard Fernandez-Versini after just three months.
News
Ian Thorpe has thanked his supporters after the athlete said in an interview that he is gay
people
News
The headstone of jazz great Miles Davis at Woodlawn Cemetery in New York
news
News
newsBear sweltering in zoo that reaches temperatures of 40 degrees
Arts and Entertainment
Professor Kathy Willis will showcase plants from the Royal Botanic Gardens at Kew
radioPlants: From Roots to Riches has been two years in the making
Extras
indybestThe tastiest creations for children’s parties this summer
Arts and Entertainment
TV The follow-up documentary that has got locals worried
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Marketing Comms / Digital Marketing Specialist

Not Specified: Recruitment Genius: An exciting and rewarding role exists for a...

Search Engine Optimisation/ SEO Executive

£25000 - £28000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Excellent opportun...

Electronics Design Engineer

£35000 - £45000 per annum + Benefits: Progressive Recruitment: My client are l...

Programme Planner

£30000 - £45000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Our client based i...

Day In a Page

Super Mario crushes the Messi dream as Germany win the 2014 World Cup in Brazil

Super Mario crushes the Messi dream

Germany win the 2014 World Cup in Brazil
Saharan remains may be evidence of the first race war, 13,000 years ago

The first race war, 13,000 years ago?

Saharan remains may be evidence of oldest large-scale armed conflict
Scientists find early warning system for Alzheimer’s

Scientists find early warning system for Alzheimer’s

Researchers hope eye tests can spot ‘biomarkers’ of the disease
Sex, controversy and schoolgirl schtick

Meet Japan's AKB48

Pop, sex and schoolgirl schtick make for controversial success
In pictures: Breathtaking results of this weekend's 'supermoon'

Weekend's 'supermoon' in pictures

The moon appeared bigger and brighter at the weekend
Iraq crisis: How Saudi Arabia helped Isis take over the north of the country

How Saudi Arabia helped Isis take over northern Iraq

A speech by an ex-MI6 boss hints at a plan going back over a decade. In some areas, being Shia is akin to being a Jew in Nazi Germany, says Patrick Cockburn
The evolution of Andy Serkis: First Gollum, then King Kong - now the actor is swinging through the trees in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes

The evolution of Andy Serkis

First Gollum, then King Kong - now the actor is swinging through the trees in Dawn of the Planet of the Apes
You thought 'Benefits Street' was controversial: Follow-up documentary 'Immigrant Street' has got locals worried

You thought 'Benefits Street' was controversial...

Follow-up documentary 'Immigrant Street' has got locals worried
Refugee children from Central America let down by Washington's high ideals

Refugee children let down by Washington's high ideals

Democrats and Republicans refuse to set aside their differences to cope with the influx of desperate Central Americas, says Rupert Cornwell
Children's books are too white, says Laureate

Children's books are too white, says Laureate

Malorie Blackman appeals for a better ethnic mix of authors and characters and the illustrator Quentin Blake comes to the rescue
Blackest is the new black: Scientists have developed a material so dark that you can't see it...

Blackest is the new black

Scientists have developed a material so dark that you can't see it...
Matthew Barzun: America's diplomatic dude

Matthew Barzun: America's diplomatic dude

The US Ambassador to London holds 'jeans and beer' gigs at his official residence – it's all part of the job, he tells Chris Green
Meet the Quantified Selfers: From heart rates to happiness, there is little this fast-growing, self-tracking community won't monitor

Meet the 'Quantified Selfers'

From heart rates to happiness, there is little this fast-growing, self-tracking community won't monitor
Madani Younis: Five-star reviews are just the opening act for British theatre's first non-white artistic director

Five-star reviews are just the opening act for British theatre's first non-white artistic director

Madani Younis wants the neighbourhood to follow his work as closely as his audiences do
Mrs Brown and her boys: are they having a laugh?

Mrs Brown and her boys: are they having a laugh?

When it comes to national stereotyping, the Irish – among others – know it can pay to play up to outsiders' expectations, says DJ Taylor