Liberte, inegalite, fraternite: Is French elitism holding the country back?

The alumni of France's 'Grandes Écoles' have long had a stranglehold on the country’s top jobs. And that, according to a new book, is why the country’s in an economic hole

Imagine a large, potentially flourishing country which is held back by its own selfish, self-perpetuating elite.

Might that country be Britain, with its class system, old-boy-network and private schools? Or Russia, with its corrupt, crony-capitalism? Or China, with its hermetically sealed party oligarchy?

Non, non et non, according to Peter Gumbel, a British writer and university lecturer based in Paris. The country in question is France, the self-proclaimed inventor of liberty and equality, the republic which, in theory, executed its permanent elite over two centuries ago.

In 2010, Mr Gumbel, angered some French people, and delighted others, with a trenchant assault on France’s education system. His new book published in French and English this week – “France’s got talent. The woeful consequence’s of French elitism” – kicks out at an even bigger hornets’ nest.

In the name of “meritocracy” and “equality”, he says, France has built a system for selecting and formatting its political, administrative and business leaders which makes “Eton and Oxbridge” or the “Ivy League” look like a utopian experiment in social levelling. The “Grandes Écoles” – elite colleges, devised by Napoleon two centuries ago and re-invented after the Second World War – have become a machine for perpetuating a brilliant but blinkered, often arrogant and frequently incompetent ruling freemasonry.

“It’s a system that is able to produce a tiny number of brilliant and charming men and women who constitute the ruling class. Whether they are competent as leaders is another matter,” Gumbel writes . “The entire selection process leaves the vast majority of the population frustrated, de-motivated or feeling discarded.” In a sense, Mr Gumbel is saying nothing new. For decades, the French themselves have grumbled (as only the French can) about the pernicious stranglehold on government and big business of the products of the Grandes Écoles and especially the so-called “énarques”.

An “énarque” is a graduate of the École Nationale d’Administration (ENA), the state officer training college which is the ultimate, exquisitely narrow, pinnacle of the French education system. ENA, which recruits the cream of the graduates from other elite colleges, turns out  just over 100 people a year, numbered according to their brilliance. Oxford and Cambridge, by comparison, produce about 6,000 graduates a year. The top 10 pupils in each ENA year or “promotion” are pushed straight into senior jobs posts in the French administration.      

 “Énarques” you may have heard of include Valéry Giscard d’Estaing (ex-President), Jacques Chirac (ex-President), Lionel Jospin (ex-Prime Minister), Édouard Balladur (ex-PM), Laurent Fabius (ex-PM, now foreign minister), Dominique de Villepin (ex-PM),  Ségolène Royal (ex-Presidential candidate) and François Hollande (President of the Republic)  The last three were class-mates in the same ENA “promotion” in 1980.

All that is familiar enough in France. However, two aspects of Mr Gumbel’s book are likely to be eye-openers, even for the most cynical of French citizens. The first is his statistical comparison with Britain, which according to French orthodoxy is a country still riven by class distinction and asphyxiated by privilege. Compared to France, he says, Britain in 2013 “almost seems to be a paradise of social equality and diversity”.

In 1974, he says, 62 per cent of top jobs in British government and civil service were held by Oxbridge graduates. By 2007 the percentage had fallen to 42 per cent (and admission to Oxbridge was broader than it was in the 1970s). In 1987, 67 per cent of the bosses of largest 100 UK companies were Oxbridge products. In 2012, the figure was 21 per cent.

And France? Around half the ministers in the present government are products of ENA or another elite institution such as Sciences Po (where Peter Gumbel lectures and used to be communications officer). This is, historically, quite a low figure. But Mr Gumbel points out that over 60 per cent of President Hollande’s immediate staff in the Elysée Palace are graduates of ENA or the most prestigious of Grandes Écoles, Polytechnique (an engineering school where pupils have ceremonial uniforms). This percentage has not changed much in 40 years. Under Nicolas Sarkozy – a sworn enemy of the Grandes Écoles – the percentage fell very slightly to around 55 per cent.

A recent survey found that 84 per cent of the 546 top executives in France’s 40 biggest companies were graduates of a handful of elite colleges. Almost half of them came from three institutions: ENA, Polytechnique and the business school HEC. Does this matter? The system was devised to create an elite: to identify and train the most able minds in France and to project them into the top jobs. The Grandes Écoles and ENA are, the apologists say, doing what they are meant to do.

Gumbel’s demolishes this argument in two ways. First, he points out, that the Grandes Écoles system, although torturously difficult to enter and to survive, has tended to favour young people from well-off  or well-educated families. Secondly, he points out, the traditional system of selection and training in the Grandes Écoles is ludicrously rigid and narrow, favouring abstraction or deep analysis rather than creativity or imagination.

“The system turns out people who are brilliant at writing long, beautifully argued reports on what should or should not be done,” Mr Gumbel told The Independent. “It is hopeless at training people who know how to make things happen. Hence, many of the problems of  France today.”

Towards the end of his book, Gumbel acknowledges that the system is changing. The elite institutions are sending students abroad and welcoming foreign students to France. The Grandes Écoles are increasingly recruiting students who have not been through the grind of two year “preparatory classes”, which favour better off candidates.

Bright French students are shunning the system in droves and applying for university in Britain. (The bulk of the French university system is a disgrace, largely because money and official respect is channelled to the upper tier of elite institutions.)

Ten or 20 years from now, those changes might start to make a difference, Gumbel says. In the meantime, the power of the Grandes Écoles, and the stultifying effect of their freemasonry of old boys and girls, endures. “I am no French basher,” Gumbel said. “France has many things going for it. But we are also at a time when many people in France are turning to the Far Right and Far Left because they are exasperated with the performance of what they see as a self-perpetuating elite. I hope my book will help to crystallise a debate on how France could be more democratic, and more imaginative, in training its leaders”.

The book is available in French as Elite Academy, published by Denoel, €17 (£14).  In English, it can be bought as an e-book through Amazon.

Elitist, the French?

A study of the background of the top 10 people in the Socialist French government shows that “only” five out of 10 went to “elitist” institutions.

The stranglehold of  graduates of elite colleges is, on the whole, receding at ministerial level.

But according to Peter Gumbel, the educational elite occupy 60 per cent of the top posts in François Hollande’s Elysee Palace (compared to 55 per cent under Nicolas Sarkozy).

They also fill the top jobs in most ministries and occupy 80 per cent of senior posts in the leading 40 French companies.  

1. François Hollande, 59, President of the Republic

Hollande is a triple product of the machinery for training a French elite. He attended not only Institut d’études Politiques (Science Po) but also the elite civil service college, Ecole Nationale d’ Administration (ENA) and the top business school, HEC.

2. Jean-Marc Ayrault, 63, Prime Minister

Ayrault rose through provincial politics as Mayor of Nantes. He is said to blame a snobbish conspiracy of the “elite” for his many difficulties as PM. He studied German at Nantes University.

3. Laurent Fabius, 66, Foreign Minister

Fabius, like Hollande, went to three elite institutions: École Normale Supérieure; Science Po: and ENA. He graduated near the top of his ENA class and became the youngest ever French Prime Minister at 37 in 1984.

4. Pierre Moscovici, 55, Finance Minister

Another classic product of the system. Studied at Science Po and then ENA.  Graduated near the top of the class and was catapulted into the official audit agency, the Cour des Comptes.

5. Jean-Yves Le Drian, 65, Defence Minister

A rare working class Socialist minister, Le Drian, came up through student and provincial politics in Brittany. He studied at the University of Rennes.

6. Christiane Taubira, 60, Justice Minister

Another minister from a modest background, Born in French Guyana, Ms Taubira was one of five children of an unmarried home-help. After taking degrees from several non-elite French universities, she became a professor of economics.

7. Manuel Valls, 50, Interior Minister

The rising star of the French centre left, Spanish-born Valls is a graduate of grass-roots and student politics rather than the finishing schools of the elite. He studied history at the Sorbonne in Paris, which has not been an elite institution for a century.

8. Arnaud Montebourg, 50, Industry Minister

Montebourg, the self-appointed left-wing conscience of the government, studied at Science Po but failed the entrance exam for ENA. He was a lawyer before entering politics.

9. Vincent Peillon, 52, Education Minister

An intermittent student of philosophy at the Sorbonne, he became a steward on trains before training as a teacher and then entering politics.

10. Marisol Touraine, 54, Health Minister

Studied at Science Po and Harvard. Became a defence ministry official and then part of the prime ministerial staff before entering provincial politics.

***

Richard Descoings: The man who tried, and failed, to change the system

Peter Gumbel’s dissection of the French elite contains a gripping “book within a book”, his first-hand account of the rise and fall of a man who tried to change the system but imploded because he was, himself, a product of its worst excesses.

Richard Descoings was director of the Institut d’études Politiques de Paris, or Science Po, from 1996 until his sudden death in New York in April last year. He was celebrated, and idolised by some, for his successful efforts to recruit bright students from poor, multiracial suburbs to France’s premier political studies college.

A few months before his death, it emerged that Descoings, a close friend of former President Nicolas Sarkozy, was paying himself a large salary and bonuses by dubious legal means. Gumbel, a British journalist turned author and lecturer, reveals In his book that the amounts paid to Descoings were even higher than previously reported – more than €500,000 a year, twice the President’s salary.

He also describes the chaotic and autocratic Science Po management in the Descoings era. Although openly gay, Descoings was married and his wife was employed by Science Po on a large salary and bonuses. His sudden death, at the age of 54, was found to be “natural” and brought on by “hypertension”.

“Descoings did exactly the things needed to break open the elite system of education in France. I admired him very much at first,” Gumbel told The Independent. “But he was like a figure in a Shakespearean tragedy. He also had the faults – the arrogance, the sense of impunity, the ruthless willingness to exploit a web of connections – which came from being part of the system he said he despised.”

Arts and Entertainment
TVShow's twee, safe facade smashed by ice cream melting scandal
News
newsVideo for No campaign was meant to get women voting
Arts and Entertainment
tv
Life and Style
tech
PROMOTED VIDEO
News
ebooksAn evocation of the conflict through the eyes of those who lived through it
Sport
Alexis Sanchez celebrates after scoring his first goal for Arsenal in the Champions League qualifier against Besiktas
sportChilean's first goal for the club secures place in draw for Champions League group stages
Arts and Entertainment
Amis: 'The racial situation in the US is as bad as it’s been since the Civil War'
booksAuthor says he might come back across Atlantic after all
Extras
indybest
Life and Style
Google Doodle celebrates the 200th birthday of Irish writer Sheridan Le Fanu
tech
Arts and Entertainment
Vinyl demand: a factory making the old-style discs
musicManufacturers are struggling to keep up with the resurgence in vinyl
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Latest stories from i100
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition apps?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Systems & Data Lead – Oxfordshire – Permanent – Up to £24k

£20000 - £24000 Per Annum 28 days holiday, free parking, pension: Clearwater P...

Digital Media Manager

£38000 - £40000 Per Annum: Clearwater People Solutions Ltd: Our client based i...

Primary Supply Teacher

£115 - £140 per day: Randstad Education Luton: Primary supply teacher Hertford...

Primary Supply Teacher in Stevenage

£115 - £121 per day: Randstad Education Luton: primary teacher Hertfordshire

Day In a Page

Israel-Gaza conflict: No victory for Israel despite weeks of death and devastation

Robert Fisk: No victory for Israel despite weeks of devastation

Palestinians have won: they are still in Gaza, and Hamas is still there
Mary Beard writes character reference for Twitter troll who called her a 'slut'

Unlikely friends: Mary Beard and the troll who called her a ‘filthy old slut’

The Cambridge University classicist even wrote the student a character reference
America’s new apartheid: Prosperous white districts are choosing to break away from black cities and go it alone

America’s new apartheid

Prosperous white districts are choosing to break away from black cities and go it alone
Amazon is buying Twitch for £600m - but why do people want to watch others playing Xbox?

What is the appeal of Twitch?

Amazon is buying the video-game-themed online streaming site for £600m - but why do people want to watch others playing Xbox?
Tip-tapping typewriters, ripe pongs and slides in the office: Bosses are inventing surprising ways of making us work harder

How bosses are making us work harder

As it is revealed that one newspaper office pumps out the sound of typewriters to increase productivity, Gillian Orr explores the other devices designed to motivate staff
Manufacturers are struggling to keep up with the resurgence in vinyl records

Hard pressed: Resurgence in vinyl records

As the resurgence in vinyl records continues, manufacturers and their outdated machinery are struggling to keep up with the demand
Tony Jordan: 'I turned down the chance to research Charles Dickens for a TV series nine times ... then I found a kindred spirit'

A tale of two writers

Offered the chance to research Charles Dickens for a TV series, Tony Jordan turned it down. Nine times. The man behind EastEnders and Life on Mars didn’t feel right for the job. Finally, he gave in - and found an unexpected kindred spirit
Could a later start to the school day be the most useful educational reform of all?

Should pupils get a lie in?

Doctors want a later start to the school day so that pupils can sleep later. Not because teenagers are lazy, explains Simon Usborne - it's all down to their circadian rhythms
Prepare for Jewish jokes – as Jewish comedians get their own festival

Prepare for Jewish jokes...

... as Jewish comedians get their own festival
SJ Watson: 'I still can't quite believe that Before I Go to Sleep started in my head'

A dream come true for SJ Watson

Watson was working part time in the NHS when his debut novel, Before I Go to Sleep, became a bestseller. Now it's a Hollywood movie, too. Here he recalls the whirlwind journey from children’s ward to A-list film set
10 best cycling bags for commuters

10 best cycling bags for commuters

Gear up for next week’s National Cycle to Work day with one of these practical backpacks and messenger bags
Paul Scholes: Three at the back isn’t working yet but given time I’m hopeful Louis van Gaal can rebuild Manchester United

Paul Scholes column

Three at the back isn’t working yet but given time I’m hopeful Louis van Gaal can rebuild Manchester United
Kate Bush, Hammersmith Apollo music review: A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it

Kate Bush shows a voice untroubled by time

A preamble, then a coup de théâtre - and suddenly the long wait felt worth it
Robot sheepdog technology could be used to save people from burning buildings

The science of herding is cracked

Mathematical model would allow robots to be programmed to control crowds and save people from burning buildings
Tyrant: Is the world ready for a Middle Eastern 'Dallas'?

This tyrant doesn’t rule

It’s billed as a Middle Eastern ‘Dallas’, so why does Fox’s new drama have a white British star?