World

Mostly Cloudy with Showers 6° London Hi 9°C / Lo 6°C

Newlywed charity workers are latest victims of Chechen terror

Shaun Walker in Shalakhi witnesses the fear and grief provoked by a brutal double murder in the Russian region

Umar Dzhabrailov and Zarema Sadulayeva. The charity workers were killed after they were kidnapped from their offices in the Chechen capital Grozny on Monday

AFP/GETTY IMAGES

Umar Dzhabrailov and Zarema Sadulayeva. The charity workers were killed after they were kidnapped from their offices in the Chechen capital Grozny on Monday

The men mourned silently, raising their hands to their shell-shocked faces in prayer; the women sat on the other side of the courtyard in headscarves, wailing uncontrollably. They had come to bid farewell to two more victims of the horrifying systematic violence that plagues Ramzan Kadyrov's Chechnya.

Newlywed charity workers Zarema Sadulayeva and Umar Dzhabrailov were kidnapped from their offices in Grozny on Monday afternoon . Yesterday – in the early hours of what would have been Mr Dzhabrailov's 33rd birthday – their bullet-riddled bodies were discovered in the boot of his car just outside the Chechen capital.

Ms Sadulayeva, also 33, ran the charity Save the Generations, which helped disabled and injured children receive treatment and education. The brutal killings of her and husband come less than a month after the murder of Natalya Estemirova, Chechnya's most prominent human rights activist.

Yesterday, relatives and friends came to pay their respects at Ms Sadulayeva's family home in the village of Shalakhi, a 45-minute drive from Grozny. A heavily-armed military checkpoint had been erected at the main entrance to the village and locals said that plain-clothed officials had been combing the village watching the mourners, creating an atmosphere of fear around the funeral.

Inside the house, female relatives performed the grim task of preparing the body for burial, sponging down the naked corpse with wet cloths. The body showed signs of bullet and knife wounds, as well as heavy bruising on the wrists, knuckles and abdomen. An independent expert who was shown photographs of the body suggested that the abdominal bruises as well as broken blood vessels on her breasts could indicate that Ms Sadulayeva had been raped before she was murdered.

Abductions and extrajudicial executions have become a way of life in the Chechnya of Mr Kadyrov, a former rebel who switched sides to become a Kremlin hardman. Ms Estemirova was one of the few people brave enough to document these abuses until her untimely death on 15 July.

In the latest killings, fingers were not immediately pointed at Mr Kadyrov personally. Whereas Ms Estemirova was working on politically sensitive issues such as abduction and torture in Chechnya and was a frequent, vocal critic of Mr Kadyrov, Ms Sadulayeva was a low-profile figure who got on with her charity work.

"I know what kind of society we live in here and I warned her again and again not to make any controversial statements, not even the slightest hint," said one of the slain woman's relatives outside the family home.

One possible explanation of for Ms Sadulayeva's murder is that special forces may have come to kidnap Mr Dzhabrailov and then also kidnapped his wife after she resisted the attackers. Mr Dzhabrailov had served a four-year prison sentence for aiding Chechnya's Muslim insurgency but was freed under a wide-ranging amnesty earlier this year.

The only witness to the abduction was a colleague from the Save the Generations charity, say relatives. He told them that six men burst into the organisation's office about 2pm on Monday, four in combat fatigues and two in civilian clothing, and dragged the couple outside. They later returned to take their mobile phones and their car.

That the kidnappers were able to return calmly to the crime scene to retrieve these items is a striking indication of the level of impunity with which kidnappings occur in Chechnya. The witness is now "under protection" of the Chechen authorities and many fear he may simply disappear.

As the news of the kidnapping broke late on Monday, members of Chechnya's closely-knit human rights community began calling each other; spreading the news and formulating a game plan. By evening, a small group of about a dozen activists and relatives had gathered to demand information at a police station in a Grozny suburb where the parents of the victims had been called for questioning.

By the time the activists dispersed in the middle of the night, they already expected the worst and their fears were realised early in the morning when the bodies of the couple were discovered. Some of them felt that the killing was a signal that nobody was safe and they should stop their work.

"They killed Estemirova, Memorial [the group for whom she worked] closed down its offices in Chechnya; and now many other organisations are thinking whether they should carry on their work in Chechnya or not," said one activist who did not want to be named. "By killing one more person, this shows civil society that any humanitarian work in Chechnya is dangerous and will stop people from doing this kind of work."

If Mr Kadyrov is not responsible, the killing is instead a sign that his control over the various militias and security forces operating outside the law in Chechnya is dwindling. Yesterday, he called the double murder a "challenge to Chechen society" and promised to track down the killers.

At the funeral, family members had a more traditional Chechen solution to the problem, saying they did not trust the authorities and would find out who was responsible themselves. "We'll find the person who did this and they will never walk again on this Earth," said a male relative of Ms Sadulayeva, before returning to the prayers.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Speculation and slander are now the new standards of Western journalism
[info]fin_d_empire wrote:
Wednesday, 12 August 2009 at 11:37 am (UTC)
The Western Wurltizer media accuse Putin and Kadyrov even if it rains. Slanderous speculation that they would never dare to engage in when HM government assassinates whistleblowers like David Kelly is considered de rigeur for Russia.

Let me ask you, if you think Kadyrov is so brutal, who's the alternative? Have the West's darlings like Ahmed Zakayev performed any better? Wasn't Zakayev identified by an orthodox priest kidnapped by Chechen bandits as one his abductors? Wasn't Zakayev's brief reign characterized by an orgy of kidnapping, murder, extortion, and limb-severing Sharia justice, topped off by a bloody invasion of Dagestan?

How much better or worse than Hamid Karzai is Kadyrov? Is his defense minister the country's top narco-rapist-war-criminal warlord? Is his brother a notable drug baron? Is his head of anti-narcotics police a drug baron? Does he regularly pardon drug barons and bayonet-rapists? When compared to the Yank stooge in tribal Afghanistan, the Russian stooge in tribal Chechnya is a paragon of good governance and a huge success story.
Re: Speculation and slander are now the new standards of Western journalism
[info]algarda wrote:
Wednesday, 12 August 2009 at 03:52 pm (UTC)
Well put! But don't expect any balanced reporting on Chechnya. You won't see Russians rioting on the streets in protest, if the media writes something negative about them. And their ads are not likely to subsidise, or their entities take over, western media empires.
Re: Speculation and slander are now the new standards of Western journalism
[info]dashamonrovia wrote:
Sunday, 16 August 2009 at 10:31 pm (UTC)
Don't be so silly! Who says there was never any journalistic speculation about whistleblowers like David Kelly? The media in Britain ran story after story about it -,not to mention plays on TV and in the theatre. As they should.

This article is reportage on what happened and what people think happened and who was responsible. Why should it compare brutality against even more brutality? It isn't some playground game about which bully is worse. A nasty and brutal regime is at work, and it doesn't matter if there is a worse one around the corner. There is plenty in the British press about the dubious nature of Karzai's regime - dunno about the American press. However, this isn't a story about Afghanistan, it is about what is happening in Chechnya. To say that there are worse atrocities elsewhere is stating the bleeding obvious and does not excuse what is happening there.
Facts...and speculation
[info]ambricourt wrote:
Wednesday, 12 August 2009 at 03:50 pm (UTC)
Ambricourt

Once again Mr Walker links narow facts to broad speculations - and always to contemporary Russia's detriment.

His skill must be recognized.

But readers should also recognize that his reports are part of an information war against countries which the world-side (global) corporate alliance - led by U.S., U.K., Israel - disfavours. The Cold War continues...

Most popular in Europe

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date