World

Rain (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 10°C / Lo 6°C

Uprising in Moldova as Communists win election

President agrees recount as mob attacks parliament

By Shaun Walker in Moscow

People shout slogans during a protest in the centre of Chisinau, protesters denouncing a Communist election victory in Moldova seized the president's offices on Tuesday and broke into parliament where they hurled furniture and computers into the street

REUTERS

People shout slogans during a protest in the centre of Chisinau, protesters denouncing a Communist election victory in Moldova seized the president's offices on Tuesday and broke into parliament where they hurled furniture and computers into the street

Violence rocked the Moldovan capital of Chisinau yesterday as thousands of protesters stormed the presidential administration building and parliament in a second day of street protests. Footage showed the protesters, mostly young men, hurling rocks at the windows of the presidential administration building and setting it on fire as large crowds looked on.

The riots came after parliamentary elections at the weekend gave President Vladimir Voronin's Communist Party around 50 per cent of the votes. Protesters shouted "Freedom!" and "Down with the Communists!" and clashed with riot police. They waved flags of neighbouring Romania, the EU member with which Moldova has cultural and linguistic links, as well as blue and yellow EU flags.

Government offices were ransacked, with papers and computers thrown from windows as protesters overran the buildings. Moldovan state television reported that 34 protesters had been injured in the disturbances, two of them seriously. Around 80 police officers also received treatment, and there were reports of a young woman dying of carbon monoxide poisoning in the parliament building.

Activists from the three leading opposition parties that contested the elections said that they did not believe that the published results of the voting were accurate. The opposition parties want to see closer integration with the EU, and Romania in particular, as well as more transparent and democratic government in the country.

Mr Voronin said that protesting against the election result was a "pretext" for people trying to destabilise the country and called for an end to the "bacchanalia". Late in the afternoon the President met opposition leaders for talks, and it was announced that there would be a full and thorough recount of the ballots, which could take up to 10 days.

The Moldovan President, who has been in power since 2001, is head of one of the last Communist governments in Europe, although analysts say that his government pays only lip service to Marxist ideals, using the label as a convenient way to gain affection among older segments of the population. Most of those protesting were students, determined to see a more modernising and effective government.

The election results give the Communist Party control of the parliament, which will elect a new president. Mr Voronin is unable to serve a third term as president, but he is expected to attempt to remain influential. One possibility is that he will follow Vladimir Putin in Russia by moving from the presidency to the prime ministership.

Although seen by Russia as within its sphere of interest, Moldova has also been keen to develop ties with the EU. It is the poorest country in Europe and was last month included in a list of six eastern European states to which the EU will offer financial aid.

"International election observers noted in their preliminary findings that the elections met many international standards and commitments, but that further improvements were required," said the EU foreign policy chief, Javier Solana. He encouraged both the protesters and the authorities to show restraint.

Of particular concern to the EU will be the fate of Moldova's breakaway Transdniester region, where Moscow-backed separatists run a strip of land that is not internationally recognised as a country but has its own government and currency. The situation is in some ways reminiscent of events in South Ossetia in the run-up to last summer's conflict between Russia and Georgia, although few observers expect a similar full-scale military conflict to erupt.

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

uprising
[info]anonimf wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 12:41 am (UTC)
"Most of those protesting were students, determined to see a more modernising and effective government."

They want a government which serves their narrow privileged interests instead of one that gives minimum support for the rest of the population.

It would have been nice for "the independent" to point out that the vote was described as "free and fair" by the thousands of election monitors present in the country instead of presenting an ambiguous and out of context quote by Javier Solana to imply that there is even a shred of evidence of electoral fraud here. But then again who can resist another pathetic "potato revolution" in Eastern Europe against those backwards "anti-west" policies.
[info]irishinrussia wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 01:44 am (UTC)
completely agree with anonimf, especially about twisting of Solana's words. The government may not be a good one, but it appears to be the one chosen by the people. As for the protesters, the writer also skims over the fact that they seem to be very pro-Romania, which I understand is not a majority opinion in Moldova. Worse than that they would appear to want union with Romania, which essentially makes them treasonous, unless the popular will is for Union. I would certainly not be pleased to see people on the streets of Dublin protesting in favour of union with England, and I would imagine most Moldovans feel similar about union with Romania. These people seem to look to Romania and thereby EU membership as quick fix for their problems. They are not democrats or liberals (that said, my moldovan friend tells me the current government is corrupt as hell). This type of display just adds more credibility to the Russian belief that certain interested parties have been orchestrating so called colour revolutions against governments that are more or less pro-Russia.
When is free and fair NOT free and fair?
[info]philfaebuckie wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 08:53 am (UTC)
I just listened to an interview on Estonian TV with one of the leading election monitors and it was her opinion that the actual voting, tallying and declaration procedure of the election was free and fair. However it was also her opinion that the lead-up to the election was canted so far in favour of the Communist Party that any other result but a Communist victory would have been unthinkable.

Firstly, a very large proportion of citizens who would have voted for the opposition live and work outside Moldova due to the limited economic opportunities within the country. The CP had absolutely no incentive to offer a simple absentee ballot system for these foreign Moldovans - it would be akin to turkeys voting for Christmas - so the result was that anyone wishing to vote had to register and be present in their electoral district on the day unless they had taken complex steps to secure an absentee ballot.

Secondly, the state media was one long advertising campaign for the CP and the opposition parties were offered the bare minimum of recognition on TV, radio etc.

Thirdly, on the day before the election bread prices were reduced across the country in an act of munificence by the government AKA the CP.

At this juncture my telephone rang and I was unable to follow the rest of the interview but it seemed that there were further dubious electoral practices being outlined.
Moldova
[info]sahrian wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 12:38 pm (UTC)
You don't know about what you are talking. The Republic of Moldova is the periphery of our historic province of Moldavia, periphery stolen by Russia in 1812, united with Romania in 1918 and later stolen again by the Soviet Union in 1940. The fact that after so many years of Russianization and brain-washing there is still Romanian feeling there you call treason?
a more correct analogy
[info]linksonice wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 02:09 pm (UTC)
IrishinRussia - you make the analogy "I would certainly not be pleased to see people on the streets of Dublin protesting in favour of union with England". The more correct analogy here would be - how do you feel about people on the streets of Belfast protesting in favor of union with Ireland? It's not so simple any more now, is it?
Moldova
[info]vincybhoy wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 04:50 am (UTC)
I lived in Moldova for three years and can assure you that Moldova is not a democracy and Voronin is no democrat. Moldova is an old fashioned dictatorship along the lines of a mid fifties Latin American state - benevolent mostly but a dictatorship none the less.
Moldovia Election Frauded
[info]alexweir1949 wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 06:20 am (UTC)
Moldovia Election Frauded

This illustrates the folly of the West's reliance on Election Obersver Missions. These achieve nothing more than to rubber-stamp elections which are often frauded. Only a voting system which is fraud-proof will solve this problem of dictatorship, corruption, massive presidential-level fraud, and the continuation of poverty. There exist on paper voting systems which can deliver real and raw democracy to the Third World, but because of selfish and greedy financial self-interest the International Community brutally suppresses such initiatives. Mr Alex Weir, Gaborone and Harare
communist elections
[info]doru001 wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 06:56 am (UTC)
I have lived a long while under a communist regime, and I have never seen or heard of any fair election under a communist government, ever.

Voronin declared that the election was correct, because the Central Election Committee has not received any complaint. He also noted that students in Moldavia are happy, because last year was some sort of anniversary year for students, and they received attention.

The Internet connection with Moldavia appeared to have been cut selectively yesterday, and this may explain the first two comments.

I believe that Western observers bear some responsibility for violences both in Georgia and Moldavia. When they accepted election frauds, they increased tensions within those societies.
Re: communist elections
[info]irishinrussia wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 09:24 am (UTC)
check out cyprus for the victory of a communist in free and fair elections
Re: communist elections
[info]doru001 wrote:
Thursday, 9 April 2009 at 07:53 am (UTC)
I said a fair election under a communist government. The communists can win fair elections, under a non-communist government. They can never lose elections under their own government.

In Georgia, the election was frauded by an anti-Russian politician. I said that this was wrong, too, and led to increased tensions.

Can you get anything right? You remember me low quality products and services under the communist regime. In case you do this for free, do it better.

And I don't buy the "we in the West" syntagm. You are a well educated Russian. For example, the idea of communist parties winning elections in West was a Russian obsession. I did not discuss that here, you only thought I did. In West, communists can win elections, because elections are free.
Re: communist elections
[info]irishinrussia wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 09:41 am (UTC)
very interesting- when the OSCE and other election observers declare an election victory for someone we like to be free and fair then they did a good job. When they declare an election victory for someone we do not like unfree and unfair it justifies colour revolution. When they declare an election victory of someone we don't like free and fair, then colour revolutions are still justifiable, it would seem according to some posters.
I s it a big surprise there were some irregularities? We in the west are far from perfect democracies. In Ireland we have a traditional saying- vote early and vote often, and I have heard not just of multiple voting, rare as it is, but even of dead people voting. However these practices are rare and not widespread. As for the UK-neither Margaret Thatcher nor Tony Blair ever received a majority of the votes cast yet both acheived huge majorities in Parliament,indeed in the last election Labour received about 35 % and the Tories about 32%, yet labour maintain a comfortable majority in Parliament- control of the minority over the majority is not democracy.
Also many countries don't offer absentee ballots- I can't vote in Ireland- I don't live there now, pay taxes there and I am not directly affected by government decisions, so no vote for me- If there was an absentee ballot the influence of non-residents on Irish elections would be huge and unfair.
What color for this "revolution?"
[info]findempire wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 08:59 am (UTC)
The neocon era must well and truly be over since the media has still not called this right-wing anti-democratic riot a "revolution" and assigned it a color. I guess Soros and Freedom House have no change to spare in these hard times for toppling elected leaders they don't lke.
the truth
[info]marius_em wrote:
Wednesday, 8 April 2009 at 12:02 pm (UTC)
Republic of Moldova is a multiethnic country, with the majority consisting on moldovans (2/3) and than there are russians and ukranians. What are moldavians? Moldovans are the romanians that live in the Province of Moldova, which consists of what is now the Republic of Moldova, a large part of Romania, and some small parts of Ukraine. Following WW2, what is now Republic of Moldavia became part of the Soviet Union, and the population was either russified, or deported to Siberia. So what is now the situation? Now, we have the uneducated parts of population, the old people, who lived under the Soviet Union, who were russfied, and we have a young generation, a generation that calls itself romanian, that also subscribes for romanian citizenship, that wishes for closer relations with Romania and EU, that wishes to have a european country. The russians and the russified molovans support the pro-russian communists, and on the other hand the young generation supports the pro-european democrats. So, as they see it, the young people think it's their time, they think they don't have to waste their life because of people still living in the past. That is, in a nutshell, what is happening in Moldova.
Moldovas Communist Party
[info]makro_22 wrote:
Saturday, 11 April 2009 at 02:30 pm (UTC)
The WEst has for years been trying to rid the present government of corruption. Loans from the World Bank such as a recent one for a big ring road around Moldova to improve tourism was withdrawn because of corruption in its management. Commentators note in applications for the EU would not be considered because of human rights violations (prisoners are tortured). American observers say that thereis still not enough government officials being prosecuted for corruption.
This is the government which it seems is being said to have allowed a 'free and fair' election. The reason for low investment in the country is that, according to a Chamber of Commerce article' in Chisinau 20% of goods imported are filched by corruption. etc etc
Russian Influence
[info]avalonadam wrote:
Tuesday, 14 April 2009 at 08:46 pm (UTC)
the Russian goverment seeks to extend its influence to alll its neighbouring states Evidence of this can be seen in the constant cyber attacks perpetrated on teh Baltic States, Ukraine and Asian ex soviet republics. I treat any result of an election where Russia has had an influence. Cast your minds back to the situation in Ukriane when the non Communist president was poisoned. Call me a cynic , but coming from Lithuania and experienceing the big bear neigbour, I have ceased to believe a fair election can take place without th eRussian government tenticles reaching out.
THis is no critism of the Russian people who have suffered for so long under there communist and supposed free non communist government.

Most popular in Europe

Article Archive

Day In a Page

Sun | Mon | Tue | Wed | Thu | Fri | Sat

Select date