Law Report: Subcontractor is judged liable for fire damage to Uppark House: National Trust v Haden Young Ltd. Court of Appeal (Lord Justice Nourse, Lord Justice Russell and Lord Justice Henry). 26 July 1994.

The fact that the employer was required, under one clause of a JCT standard building contract, to insure against fire damage to the property while work was being carried out, did not relieve the contractor, and therefore a subcontractor engaged on the same terms, from liability to the employer, under another clause, for fire damage to the property caused by the negligence of the subcontractor's workmen.

The Court of Appeal dismissed an appeal by the defendant, Haden Young Ltd, and affirmed the decision of Mr Justice Otton in April 1993, that it was liable in damages for negligence in respect of a fire, on the 30 August 1989, at Uppark House, South Harting, West Sussex, which destroyed much of the building and most of its contents. The estimated cost of reconstruction was pounds 20m.

The action was brought by the National Trust, which acquired the 17th- century house by gift of its owner in 1954, and opened large parts of it to public view, other parts remaining occupied by the owner's family. In 1989, the Trust decided to carry out extensive repairs, including renewal of lead roofing. The main contractor was a local company, Midhurst & Fernhurst Buildings Ltd (MFB), while Haden Young was the specialist subcontractor for the roof work.

Haden Young admitted before trial that the fire was caused by the negligence of two of its employees, but nevertheless contended that it was relieved from liability under the contractual arrangements in force.

Kenneth Rokison QC and Richard P Gray QC (Kennedys) for Haden Young; Jonathan R Playford QC and Andrew Prynne (Davies Arnold Cooper) for the Trust.

LORD JUSTICE NOURSE said the main contract between the Trust and MFB was written in the JCT standard form for minor building works (January 1987 revision). There was no written subcontract between MFB and Haden Young, which was content to proceed on the footing that it would carry out the works specified in the relevant sections of the main contract subject to the terms and conditions therein contained.

Under cl 6.2, 'the contractor shall be liable for . . . any injury or damage whatsoever to any property real or personal (other than injury or damage to the works) insofar as such injury or damage arises out of or in the course of . . . the carrying out of the works and . . . is due to any negligence . . . of the contractor, his servants or agents, or of any person employed or engaged by the contractor'. It also provided that the contractor should take out insurance against such liability and cause any subcontractor to do so too. Under cl 6.3B, 'the employer (the Trust) shall in the joint names of employer and contractor insure against loss or damage to the existing structures (together with the contents. . .) and to the works . . . by fire. . .' If cl 6.2 was read on its own, it was clear that the contractor became liable to the employer for the loss in respect of the damage to the house and contents. The damage was to property real or personal, it arose in the course of the carrying out of the works, and it was caused by the negligence of a person engaged on part of the works.

But Haden Young argued that when cl 6.2 was read with cl 6.3B, the contractor was not intended to be liable for damage to the existing structures and their contents by fire, even if the fire was caused by the contractor's or a subcontractor's own negligence. That was an impossible construction. Clause 6.2 imposed liability on the contractor for damage caused to any real or personal property (other than the works) by his own or a subcontractor's negligence. The liability was unlimited and the requirement to insure against it ancillary.

In contrast, cl 6.3B required the employer to insure specific property, namely the existing structures and their contents, and the works and materials, against specific risks. More significantly, it said nothing about liability, and the only basis for suggesting it was intended to limit that which had been declared to be unlimited, was the probability that the employer's insurance would cover a fire caused negligently by the contractor or subcontractor.

That was no basis for doing such violence to the terms of cl 6.2. It only meant there was a potential overlap between the two provisions, with the employer's recoverable damages under cl 6.2 being liable to be reduced by the amount recoverable under the insurance, or vice versa. It went no further.

LORD JUSTICE RUSSELL and LORD JUSTICE HENRY agreed.

Arts & Entertainment
A stranger calls: Martin Freeman in ‘Fargo’
tvReview: New 10-part series brims with characters and stories

Arts & Entertainment
Shaun Evans as Endeavour interviews a prisoner as he tries to get to the bottom of a police cover up
Review: Second series comes to close with startling tale of police corruption and child abuse
Sport
Raheem Sterling and Luis Suarez celebrate during Liverpool's game with Norwich
football Another hurdle is out of the way for Brendan Rodgers' side
Life & Style
Guests enjoy food and cocktail parings by Chefs Jimmy Bannos, Jimmy Bannos Jr, Daniel Rose and Mindy Segal with mixologists Josh King and Alex Gara at Bounty & Barrel: A Jack Daniel's Single Barrel Dinner Series at Heaven on Seven on April 9, 2014 in Chicago, Illinois.
news Sprinkle Palcohol 'on almost any dish' for 'an extra kick' firm says...
VIDEO
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
Arts & Entertainment
Charlotte Brontë, the English novelist, poet and the eldest of the three Bronte sisters who lived into adulthood, has been celebrated with a Google Doodle depicting her most famous novel, Jane Eyre.
arts + ents "Reader, they doodled her".

Arts & Entertainment
Schwarzenegger winning Mr. Universe 1969
arts + entsCan you guess the celebrity from these British Pathe News clips?
News
Portrait of Queen Elizabeth-II by David Bailey which has been released to mark her 88th birthday
peoplePortrait released to mark monarch's 88th birthday
Arts & Entertainment
The star of the sitcom ‘Miranda’ is hugely popular with mainstream audiences
TVMiranda Hart lined up for ‘Generation Game’ revival
Life & Style
The writer, Gerda Saunders, with her mother, who also suffered with dementia before her death
healthGerda Saunders on the most formidable effect of her dementia
Sport
Manchester United manager David Moyes looks on during his side's defeat to Everton
footballBaines and Mirallas score against United as Everton keep alive hopes of a top-four finish
News
The troubled star is set to give fans the biggest insight into her life away from the headlines
peopleThe Mean Girls star’s life takes another sad turn
Sport
Tour de France 2014Sir Rodney Walker on organising the UK stages of this year’s race
Arts & Entertainment
Jessica Brown Findlay as Mary Yellan in ‘Jamaica Inn’
TVJessica Brown Findlay on playing the spirited heroine of Jamaica Inn
News
YouTube clocks up more than a billion users a month
mediaEuropean rival Dailymotion certainly thinks so
Arts & Entertainment
The original design with Charles' face clearly visible, which is on display around the capital
arts + ents
Arts & Entertainment
‘Self-Portrait Worshipping Christ’ (c943-57) by St Dunstan
books How British artists perfected the art of the self-portrait
News
People
News
Sir Cliff Richard is to release his hundredth album at age 72
PEOPLE
Independent
Travel Shop
the manor
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on city breaks Find out more
santorini
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on chic beach resorts Find out more
sardina foodie
Up to 70% off luxury travel
on country retreats Find out more
Have you tried new the Independent Digital Edition iPad app?
Independent Dating
and  

By clicking 'Search' you
are agreeing to our
Terms of Use.

iJobs Job Widget
iJobs General

Geography Teacher

£130 - £140 per day: Randstad Education Ilford: Secondary Geography Teacher Lo...

Do you want to work in Education?

£55 - £70 per day: Randstad Education Cheshire: Are you a dynamic and energeti...

SEN Teaching Assistant

Negotiable: Randstad Education Group: SEN TAs, LSAs and Support Workers needed...

Private Client Senior Manager - Sheffield

£50000 - £60000 per annum: Pro-Recruitment Group: The Sheffield office of this...

Day In a Page

Rubin ‘Hurricane’ Carter: The man who could have been champion of the world - and the Bob Dylan song that immortalised him

The man who could have been champion of the world

Rubin ‘Hurricane’ Carter and the Bob Dylan song that immortalised him
Didn’t she do well?

Didn’t she do well?

Miranda Hart lined up for ‘Generation Game’ revival
The Middle East we must confront in the future will be a Mafiastan ruled by money

The Middle East we must confront in the future will be a Mafiastan ruled by money

In Iraq, mafiosi already run almost the entire oil output of the south of the country
Before they were famous

Before they were famous

Can you guess the celebrity from these British Pathe News clips?
Martin Freeman’s casting in Fargo is genius

Martin Freeman’s casting in Fargo is a stroke of genius

Series is brimming with characters and stories all its own
How I brokered a peace deal with Robert Mugabe: Roy Agyemang reveals the delicate diplomacy needed to get Zimbabwe’s President to sit down with the BBC

How I brokered a peace deal with Robert Mugabe

Roy Agyemang reveals the delicate diplomacy needed to get Zimbabwe’s President to sit down with the BBC
Video of British Muslims dancing to Pharrell Williams's hit Happy attacked as 'sinful'

British Muslims's Happy video attacked as 'sinful'

The four-minute clip by Honesty Policy has had more than 300,000 hits on YouTube
Church of England-raised Michael Williams describes the unexpected joys in learning about his family's Jewish faith

Michael Williams: Do as I do, not as I pray

Church of England-raised Williams describes the unexpected joys in learning about his family's Jewish faith
A History of the First World War in 100 moments: A visit to the Front Line by the Prime Minister's wife

A History of the First World War in 100 moments

A visit to the Front Line by the Prime Minister's wife
Comedian Jenny Collier: 'Sexism I experienced on stand-up circuit should be extinct'

Jenny Collier: 'Sexism on stand-up circuit should be extinct'

The comedian's appearance at a show on the eve of International Women's Day was cancelled because they had "too many women" on the bill
Cannes Film Festival: Ken Loach and Mike Leigh to fight it out for the Palme d'Or

Cannes Film Festival

Ken Loach and Mike Leigh to fight it out for the Palme d'Or
The concept album makes surprise top ten return with neolithic opus from Jethro Tull's Ian Anderson

The concept album makes surprise top ten return

Neolithic opus from Jethro Tull's Ian Anderson is unexpected success
Lichen is the surprise new ingredient on fine-dining menus, thanks to our love of Scandinavian and Indian cuisines

Lichen is surprise new ingredient on fine-dining menus

Emily Jupp discovers how it can give a unique, smoky flavour to our cooking
10 best baking books

10 best baking books

Planning a spot of baking this bank holiday weekend? From old favourites to new releases, here’s ten cookbooks for you
Jury still out on Manchester City boss Manuel Pellegrini

Jury still out on Pellegrini

Draw with Sunderland raises questions over Manchester City manager's ability to motivate and unify his players