Saudi women appeal for legal freedoms
Monday, 21 April 2008
In Riyadh, the college day begins for female students behind a locked door that will remain that way until male guardians come to collect them. Later, in a female-run business, everyone must vacate the premises so a delivery man can drop off a package. In Jeddah, a 40-year-old divorced woman cannot board a plane without the written permission of her 23-year-old son. Elsewhere, a female doctor cannot leave the house at all as her male driver fails to turn up for work. These scenes make up the daily reality for half of the Saudi Kingdom, the only country where women legally belong to men.
After more than a decade of lobbying, the New York-based group Human Rights Watch (HRW) has finally been granted access to Saudi Arabia, where it has uncovered a disturbing picture of women forced to live as children, denied basic rights and confined to a suffocating dependency on men.
Wajeha al-Huwaider, a critic of Saudi's guardian laws that force women to seek male permission for almost all aspects of their lives, is one of a growing number demanding change. "Sometimes I feel like I can't do anything; I am utterly reliant on other people, completely dependent. If you are dependent on another person, you've got nothing. That is how the men like it. They don't want us to be equals."
The House of Saud, in alliance with an extremist religious establishment which enforces the most restrictive interpretation of sharia, Islamic law, has created a legal system that treats women as minors unable to exercise authority over even trivial daily matters.
The most egregious consequences of this repressive regime occasionally filter out from the Gulf Kingdom: the notorious case in Qatif of the girl who was jailed after being gang raped on a charge of consorting with a male non-relative; the schoolgirls believed to have burnt to death in Mecca as religious police would not let them leave the fiery premises without headscarves; or the happily married Fatima Azzaz from Mansour, forced to divorce her husband at the whim of her half-brothers.
Beyond these high-profile cases is a demoralising and sometimes ridiculous reality in which women cannot open bank accounts for their children, take them to the dentist or even on a field trip without the written permission of the father.
Petty humiliations are endemic. Two women who spoke to HRW said, in a report released today, that judges had refused them the right to speak in court as their voices were "shameful" – only their guardians were allowed to speak on their behalf. Saudi courts require a mu'arif (a male to identify her under the full face veil) before a woman can even attempt to testify.
"The Saudi government sacrifices human rights to maintain male control over women," said Farida Deif from HRW. "Saudi women won't make progress until the government ends the abuses that stem from these misguided policies."
The oil-rich kingdom lies at the bottom of the UN rankings on female empowerment and women make up only 4 per cent of the workforce.
The frustrations of Dr M are typical of those faced even by educated women:
"When I take my daughter to the doctor's, they ask me where my husband is, and refuse to do anything until he comes to authorise it. Even if it is something small like an ear infection."
Another woman who, despite the legal barriers, owns her own business, describes the farcical difficulties she faces: "Only women can enter my premises. If a delivery man needs to drop something off we have to exit the premises first. It is ridiculous."
Trumpeted reforms from King Abdullah have had little impact on women's lives. Too often, sex segregation results in an "apartheid" system in which facilities for women are either grossly inferior or non-existent. Women were denied the right to vote in the kingdom's first municipal elections because there were no separate voting booths for them.
Even progress that is achieved often serves to underline the fundamental problem – that of legal guardianship of men over women. In the words of one Saudi woman: "We still need to get a male guardian – husband, father or brother – to sign a form saying where we are allowed to work and when. It is like we are their property."

Comments
67 Comments
Those of you who have a different perspective of Islam should read this book. http://www.soundvision.com/Info/gender/
Gender Equity in Islam
Basic Principles
by Jamal Badawi, Ph.D.
Islam and Saudi Arabia are not the same thing! :)
Posted by Mostak | 26.04.08, 07:16 GMT
this is really sad to see all these people hating .... may god help all good people in this world ..and guied all who is bad... in islam jews chrictians and muslims all can go to heaven as long as they belive in god alone ..................... we all have the same god ...........(allah is GOD)..... and if you look at the tora bible and quraan all preach the same thing ... only small differnces like alcahole and pigs.....hahaha....no beer........... they all tell the same stories .......... plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz stop the hate.... god made us with differnt backrounds for us to get to know each other .............. and U.K. israel and u.s.a. stop killlllllllllllllllllllllllllllllllling and making war and playing your games ...you are why the arab and muslim world is mad ..... plzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz no more dead men women childern...........God is peace...............
Posted by jason | 25.04.08, 04:07 GMT
Greg you are an absolutely awful person... I hope your mother is proud she carried you for 9 months and sufferered childbirth - for you then to shame her like this, you utter fool. I can't even be bothered to argue against these ridiculous and generalised statements...
Here's what this complete moron wrote: "The trouble with women is if you give them an inch, they demand a mile. They have really phuked men in the work world in the US. they have also phuked men in the household by being the persons responsible for over 90 percent of divorce filings in the US. They break up the American family in their greed and their avarice. So.........maybe the Saudis are right.
Posted by Greg | 22.04.08, 03:48 GMT"
Posted by Nicola | 24.04.08, 20:31 GMT
I sincerely believe, the Islamic way of live is the most perfect way of living, if implemented correctly. Segregation of people according to their sex in public and taking proper care of womanhood is the cure of many western nations. We know the social, family, Teenage nightmare these countries are facing. There are some social problems in Saudi Arabia, as there are social problems elsewhere in every corner of the planet. The Saudis have the solution. I mean.. they got the point. The fundamental core of the sociological complications modern countries are facing. What they are not good at are, to convince their beloved female fellowship, and make them understand the unique way they have chosen to protect them and their dignity, that their sisters in other parts of the world have lost long time ago and are now dreaming of it.
Mind you I am not a Saudi Arabian, but I have been there for work. I admire their life style I am Danish.
Posted by Xabat | 24.04.08, 19:37 GMT
Our mothers are women too. We treat our mothers much better compared to yours! Our women are treated with respect; they do not have to become sub-human to earn a living or live in a senior home.
Only some high society women are crying because they cannot drive their Porsche and go around dating and drinking. I do not hear them complaining for the mistreatment of the workers here! Since they are the ones who mistreat most of their maids. Both men and women workers of third world origin are treated like slaves. Never heard of the western media complain about that!!!
You seem more interested in de-clothing the Muslim women than really standing up for human rights.
Posted by Mostak | 24.04.08, 12:04 GMT
If this article is anything similar to what real Saudi Arabia is, then I am not living in Saudi Arabia. You are comparing Apples with Oranges. Mind you Saudi Arabia and Islam are not the same thing. Yes some part of the sharia is followed in Saudi Arabia and that makes it a better place to live compared to the Western countries.
The more Saudi Arabia becomes westernized, by following the western cultures and so called western values, the more trouble people of this country is getting into.
Women here are treated much better than in many countries. If someone misbehaves with his wife, daughters and other female members of their families, then it is his fault. The law, government or the system is not to be blamed for that.
For your information I am not Saudi also.
Posted by Mostak | 24.04.08, 11:57 GMT
The article states, "Later, in a female-run business, everyone must vacate the premises so a delivery man can drop off a package". Even if this statement was true, which situation is worse: a country and code of law where men aren't allowed to touch or even glance at a woman who is not in their marriage or family circle; or a country where newspapers daily publish a nude photo of someone's mother or someone's daughter so that thousands of men unkown to her can gape at her body - neither the public nor the government say a word to stop this?
Posted by A Khadijah | 24.04.08, 11:34 GMT
If you are willing to die for Islam:
Please die now.
Posted by Nisse | 23.04.08, 11:47 GMT
Aqilah>These laws in Saudi are against Islam and are in direct contradiction to the rights Allah has given to women.
It seems you have not studied the Koran enough. The Koran specifically sets out many rules regarding Women's rights.
1. women have inferior rights of divorce and inheritance
2. polygamy is allowed
3. the veil must be worn to stop men getting too excited
4. women are also not allowed to travel by themselves, or be alone with a man who is not a relative.
5. wife beating is condoned. Muhamad beat his wives.
6. Under Islamic law, rape can only be proven if the rapist confesses or if there are four male witnesses.
7. Child marriage is allowed. Mohammad married a 6 year old and had sex with her when she was 9.
Because all of this is enshrined in the Koran, and in most cases are actual acts of Mohammed, it is impossible under the proper application of Islamic law for women to have anything like equality.
Posted by Mark | 23.04.08, 01:46 GMT
These laws in Saudi are against Islam and are in direct contradiction to the rights Allah has given to women. If men feel that they need to dominate women and not give them their rights than they need to look at their own nafs and shortcomings. A real Muslim wants for his Brother and SISTER what he wants for himself. No one should want to oppress another let alone the whole other half of humanity...read your Qur'an, read your Hadith and stop practicing Hislam.
Posted by Aqilah | 22.04.08, 21:46 GMT
67 Comments