Harassment, intimidation and secrecy - UN chief engulfed in sex scandal

News in pictures
News in pictures
On Facebook
From the blogs

Tyrannosaur and Drive: The difference between loneliness and being alone

The prospect of loneliness is probably one of the biggest fears that humans have to contend with. Mo...

The Woman in Black: From page, to stage, to film

Director James Watkins and screenwriter Jane Goldman discuss how they kept up the constant high leve...

The future of academic publishing

These are the most uncertain times in living memory for academic publishing. After decades of bumpin...

Books with soundtracks: no, really, this one works…

Books with soundtracks. The idea is so glaringly obvious, and so obviously feeble, that I hesitate t...

One of the United Nations' most senior officials is likely to face fresh pressure to resign over allegations of sexual harassment and intimidation after
The Independent obtained a confidential internal report into the claims.

One of the United Nations' most senior officials is likely to face fresh pressure to resign over allegations of sexual harassment and intimidation after The Independent obtained a confidential internal report into the claims.

Ruud Lubbers, the UN's high commissioner for refugees, was found guilty of misconduct involving sexual harassment by an official investigation carried out by the UN's watchdog, it can be revealed. The secret document has never before been released.

Kofi Annan, the UN secretary general, took internal and external legal advice after studying the 15-page report on the allegations, before deciding he was unable to take action against Mr Lubbers. Instead, he issued him with a strong warning about his conduct.

As high commissioner, Mr Lubbers, 65, formerly the longest serving Dutch prime minister, is responsible for marshalling the aid effort for the world's 17 million refugees. The investigation ­ carried out by the UN's office for internal oversight services (OIOS) ­ began after a complaint of sexual harassment by a female employee at the refugee agency. She alleged Mr Lubbers placed his hands on her waist, pulled her back towards him and pressed his groin into her at the end of a meeting with male colleagues in Geneva on 18 December 2003.

In its note to the secretary general, the report says: "Mr Lubbers did engage in unwanted physical contact with a subordinate female staff member. New allegations that came to the OIOS's attention during the investigation were also examined and indicate a pattern of sexual harassment by Mr Lubbers."

It continues: "OIOS is also of the view that Mr Lubbers abused his authority as high commissioner by his intense, pervasive and intimidating attempts to influence the outcome of this investigation."

As part of their inquiry, the investigators, led by Dileep Niar, the under-secretary general for internal oversight services, learnt of several other instances of alleged sexual misconduct. Four women subsequently agreed to be questioned on condition of anonymity, saying they were afraid of "retaliation and public humiliation". They declined to make official complaints.

Woman A told the OIOS she was invited to Mr Lubbers' home with others to discuss work. She said, instead, she was alone with him, and he wanted to discuss only personal matters while sitting close to her and touching her in a sexual way. She left quickly because she felt he was trying to go further and she became afraid.

Woman B described an incident at a UNHCR function at which Mr Lubbers grabbed and embraced her, pulling her body against his. She was shocked and embarrassed, and pushed him away.

Woman C said Mr Lubbers had attempted to grope her. She had pushed him back, and threatened to slap him if he attempted to do the same again.

Woman D said Mr Lubbers twice made unwelcome advances and asked her to come to his hotel. She said Mr Lubbers told her he was "feeling lonely".

The revelations come at a time when the UN is under fire on many fronts ­ranging from the oil-for-food scandal in Iraq to sexual exploitation by peacekeepers of the very people who they were sent to protect in the Congo. A right-wing campaign in the US also threatens it.

The report on Mr Lubbers was handed to Mr Annan last summer. After legal advice, he told UNHCR staff in a letter that the complaint could not be sustained. But he did not exonerate Mr Lubbers and said he had carpeted him. In the letter, Mr Annan said that he had conveyed to Mr Lubbers "in the strongest terms, my concerns about the incident that gave rise to the complaint and about subsequent events during the investigation, some of which may have been construed as likely to influence the course of the investigation."

Mr Annan told the staff he had underlined to Mr Lubbers that staff had the right to make complaints about "all forms of misconduct and must be protected from any type of reprisal or retaliation against them".

The Independent gave Mr Lubbers 24 hours to respond to a series of questions arising out of our investigations. In a statement last night, Mr Lubbers said the OIOS report was confidential, and that it should have remained so. He said: "First, the complaint of alleged sexual harassment filed with the OIOS could not be substantiated. Neither of the two witnesses who were present in the room at the time of the alleged incident reported seeing sexual harassment. Regarding the 'four other cases', I was confronted by OIOS with details of only one alleged occurrence which in no way constituted sexual harassment. As I reported to my own staff in May 2004, there was no such complaint. In fact, I challenged OIOS to substantiate their claim of other cases, but they did not.

"I have criticised the OIOS report because it alleges 'a pattern of misconduct' without anything to substantiate this ­ contrary to your statement. One can only conclude that the claim of the 'other cases' is baseless. It is noteworthy that during the investigation, several UNHCR female colleagues came forward to vouch for my character and integrity but this expression of support was ignored by OIOS.

"The secretary general closed the case in mid-July 2004, after considering ­ as part of due process ­ not only the OIOS report but my own detailed response. He declared that he took all circumstances of the case into account, and decided the allegations could not be substantiated. Obviously, the secretary general considered my response convincing, and the allegations and OIOS accusations unfounded."

Mr Lubbers took up his post on 1 January 2001. Appointed to a three-year term, Mr Annan extended his tenure for another two years before the allegations were made.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus

Day In a Page

Silent revolution at the Baftas as the French take top awards

Silent revolution at the Baftas

The Artist wins in seven categories, with Meryl Streep the other big success story
Whitney Houston: The diva who had – and lost – it all

The diva who had – and lost – it all

Nick Hasted charts the highs and lows of Whitney Houston's life
How Picasso won over (some of) the British

How Picasso won over (some of) the British

Winston Churchill and Evelyn Waugh hated his work, but Picasso provided inspiration for a whole generation of UK artists
Topshop: A Decade Of Design

Topshop: A Decade Of Design

When London Fashion Week starts on Friday, Topshop will celebrate 10 years backing its brightest young stars
John Prescott: 'My wife thought I'd just retire, but I'm not a slippers man'

'My wife thought I'd just retire, but I'm not a slippers man'

At 73, John Prescott isn't mellowing. In fact he's taking a shot at becoming a police commissioner
Jim Gamble: We are losing the race to protect our young

Jim Gamble: We are losing the race to protect our young

Technology and the children who use it won't wait for slow-moving child-protection services and police to catch up
Sarah Sands: A friend is not the one you turn to, but the person who turns to you

Sarah Sands on friendship

A friend is not the one you turn to, but the person who turns to you
Andy Burnham: 'It's a genie out of the bottle moment'

Andy Burnham interview

'It's a genie out of the bottle moment'
Leveson: What we've learnt so far

Leveson: What we've learnt so far

Ingenious hacks, shifty editors and attacks of Sudden Memory Loss Syndrome – Matthew Bell assesses the state of play at the Royal Courts of Justice
Modern lovers: The 'sexual body warriors' and pioneers transforming 21st-century relationships

Modern lovers: The 'sexual body warriors'

Sarah Morrison meets the people redefining love in the 21st century.
'I was angry, so angry': How heartbreak, betrayal and Su Pollard helped Estelle find pop success

Estelle: 'I was angry, so angry'

The singer talks about heartache, betrayal and bouncing back.
Choc tactics: Bill Granger's Valentine's recipes for chocoholics

Bill Granger's Valentine's recipes for chocoholics

Should it be white, milk or plain? Can you make a melt-in-the-mouth pudding without using any?
Male, pale & stale: Could more women on the board help Mothercare – and other ailing firms?

Male, pale & stale

Could more women on the board help Mothercare – and other ailing firms?
Upstairs, downstairs, 2012-style

Upstairs, downstairs, 2012-style

There are now more domestic workers in Britain than in Edwardian times
Boos in Berlin for Jolie's war drama

Boos in Berlin for Jolie's war drama

Hollywood star defends her hard-hitting and controversial story set during the 1990s Bosnian conflict