Chris Bryant: The Church of England needs to forget its silliness about homosexuality
Monday 16 January 2012
Latest in Opinion
Related articles
Opinion blogs
The ugly face of TV: How Jeremy Clarkson brought facial prejudice to a head
If you saw someone with a facial disfigurement walking down the street, would you A) Laugh at them B...
George Osborne lines up with the banking lobby
Paul Volcker thinks the argument that forbidding US banks from trading British or other nations' sov...
Is Tony Blair became a “Reptilian”?
I forgot about this Question to Which the Answer is No in my last round-up. I put it on Twitter a we...
Anyone who has ever heard Jeffrey John preach, read his poetry or met him knows that he is a man of immense spirituality who should have been made a bishop years ago.
Sadly, the Church of England has got its cassocks so firmly in a twist that it seems completely incapable of coming to the same conclusion, purely and simply because he's gay.
In the old days it was all very simple. Homosexuality was a deliberate choice, a perversion, a sin.
Gay men were skipping along the rose-pink path to the everlasting bonfire and gay clergy who were caught in the act were dismissed, disgraced and defrocked.
But nobody seriously believes that anymore. Most church leaders know your sexuality is not something you choose, but something you discover. So you could even argue that God has made some people gay, which is why the Church of England no longer condemns anyone for just being gay. Indeed, it even teaches that homophobia is immoral.
But in a classic twist of English logic, the Church still maintains that it's fine and dandy to be gay just so long as you don't do anything about it.
Celibacy is the rule – especially for the clergy – as same-sex sex is definitely off-limits.
There are two problems with this. For a start it is a great big lie. It ludicrously pretends that Jeffrey would be the first-ever gay bishop.
But I remember terribly anguished and frighteningly closeted gay bishops in my theological college back in the Eighties. One became quite a close friend, and his relief the moment he retired and took up residence with his lover of 20 years was a sad joy to behold.
And 10 years ago a bishop asked me, in all seriousness, whether it was wrong that he had just decided that he had to appoint a straight man to a particular inner-city parish because literally every other vicar in the area was gay.
What is even worse, though, is that the Church's double-speak is so cruel. It condemns people to a life without the joy of sexual intimacy – and all to placate a theology that is as misplaced and out of date as Christianity's onetime advocacy of slavery.
Is it too much to hope that one day the Church of England will get this silliness out of its system?
- 1 Robert Fisk: 'If only Hague and Clinton would listen to Yusuf Islam'
- 2 Christina Patterson: If you want a job, 'slave labour' at Tesco isn't a bad place to start
- 3 Ian McKellen: What's wrong with us? Should we not aspire to happiness?
- 4 Mark Steel: Iraq was such a laugh, let's do it to Iran
- 5 The Daily Cartoon
- 6 The dark side of Dubai
- 7 John Walsh: Will Germany ever be allowed to feel that its past is not its present?
- 1 Last bow for Blur at Brit awards?
- 2 How an A-grade prank by a hacker closed a school for a day
- 3 Copenhagen, probably the best city in the world
- 4 Robert Fisk: 'If only Hague and Clinton would listen to Yusuf Islam'
- 5 How did a man buried in this frozen car for two months come out of it alive?
- 6 The sci-fi movie Hollywood would not dare to make
- 7 Ian McKellen: What's wrong with us? Should we not aspire to happiness?
- 8 Mark Steel: Iraq was such a laugh, let's do it to Iran
- 9 Aborted baby lived 45 minutes
- 10 Journalists killed in Syria rocket strike 'were targeted'
Win an adventure with Subaru XV
Enjoy a three-night family adventure for four to Slaley Hall in Northumberland.
Delivering network infrastructure for London 2012
Cisco is maximising connectivity for the Olympic and Paralympic Games.
Free trial of our new iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
Can we pull the plug on the plug?
The 10 Best Lecture Series
Michael Frayn: Still making a big noise




Comments