Boyd Tonkin: Shunning this play is a pitiable act of prejudice understanding
Latest in Commentators
Opinion blogs
Tunnel, light at end of
At some point, doom and gloom about the economy is likely to turn round. Obviously, if the eurozone ...
Paul Volcker stands tall against the banking lobby
Why is Europe, which likes to present itself as an opponent of speculative "Anglo-Saxon" finance, li...
“Not growing inequality”
What do we want? “A fairer sharing of rewards not growing inequality.” Well said, Ed Mil...
Any student or theatre-goer who chooses to reject "The Merchant of Venice", just as the city's smug Christians spurn Shylock will cut themselves off from one of the liveliest, toughest and most necessary conversations about art, prejudice and performance in Western culture.
From the play's text, it seems likely that the quarrel over anti-Semitism began in Shakespeare's imagination in the mid-1590s. Traits of the stereotypical Jewish villain found (but also subverted) in Christopher Marlowe's play " The Jew of Malta"fused with events such as the execution in 1594 of Elizabeth I's Jewish physician, Dr Rodrigo Lopez, on a trumped-up spying charge.
Ogre and hero, monster of implacable revenge and noble accuser of Christian hypocrisy and injustice, Shakespeare's Shylock allows for a rainbow of different – and clashing – interpretations. In print, on stage and on screen, from the age of Edmund Kean to that of Al Pacino, he has never stopped attracting them.
Crucially, the arguments about both Shylock and the play have, over the past century, been pushed forward by Jewish actors, writers, directors and critics. In the early 1900s, the celebrated Yiddish actor Jacob Adler broke with Henry Irving's late-Victorian "sympathetic Shylock" to emphasise the character's pride. Adler's Shylock did not plea for indulgence, but demanded rights.
More recent Jewish responses – from the critic Harold Bloom, for example, or the playwright Arnold Wesker – have refused to sidestep or mitigate the anti-Semitism charge. Yet the most compelling Shylock of recent times came from another great Jewish actor: Henry Goodman. And so on ...
This is a wrangle that has exercised many of the finest creative minds of the past 200 years. What could be more pitiably prejudiced than to refuse to engage with it?
- 1 Hamish McRae: Living standards will start to get better sooner than you think
- 2 Kate Allen: It's time for America to put an end to this shameful scandal
- 3 Christina Patterson: The struggle against police racism has just got a lot harder
- 4 Matthew Norman: There's always the Human Rights Act, Trevor
- 5 Leading: Now stand by for Act II of this Greek drama
- 6 Dominic Lawson: Spare me these orgies of self-congratulation
- 7 Mark Steel: If religion is 'marginal', I'm the Pope
- 1 How Koscielny became prince of the Emirates
- 2 Apple admits it has a human rights problem
- 3 Spotify: 1 million plays, £108 return
- 4 Six Grammys, five years off: Adele puts love before career
- 5 Lightning kills an entire football team
- 6 Police confiscate passport from Brooks' assistant
- 7 Nauru and Abkhazia: One is a destitute microstate marooned in the South Pacific, the other is a disputed former Soviet Republic 13,000km away, so why are they so keen to be friends?
- 8 I was born to be a killer. Every night I see the Devil in my dreams
- 9 Mark Steel: If religion is 'marginal', I'm the Pope
- 10 Rothschild loses libel case, and reveals secret world of money and politics
Free trial of new Independent iPad app
Get your daily dose of the best of British journalism, sponsored by American Airlines
Win a three-week coastal jaunt
Spend three weeks exploring every nook and cranny of gorgeous Atlantic Canada.
Amazing restaurant offers
Three glasses of free champagne and a special menu at 46 top London restaurants.
Latest Independent competitions
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.
Commercial thought leaders
Watch the best in the business world give their insights into the world of business.
Career Services
Day In a Page
No secularism please, we're British
Working as a jail torturer ruined my life
New Arsenal face an old question of credibility in San Siro




Comments