Commentators

Showers (AM and PM) 5° London Hi 10°C / Lo 5°C

David Cameron: We cannot impose democracy at the barrel of a gun

Friday, 5 September 2008

I am a liberal Conservative. Liberal because I believe in freedom, human rights and democracy, and I want to see more of these things in our world. But Conservative, because I believe strongly in the continued relevance of the nation state and because I am sceptical of grand utopian schemes to re-make the world according to a politician's timetable. My instinct is to work patiently with the flow of culture, tradition and history.

For me, democracy is not just a goal in itself. It is our best available mechanism for lasting good government that delivers economic, social and environmental progress. Democracies tend not to go to war with each other. Democracies offer a structure in which differences – including territorial and ethnic disputes – can be debated and resolved. Democracy gives every citizen a say.

But the case for democracy needs to be re-made and refreshed in every generation. Because there are always powerful forces which seek to stifle the universal human hunger for freedom. And I use the word "universal" because democracy is not the property of the West, nor an import to the East, it's not a system we impose, nor a value unique to any culture. They said democracy could never take root in countries like Germany or Japan. They were, apparently, too militarist, too authoritarian, too anti-liberal. But both are now flourishing democracies – standing rebukes to the prejudices of the past.

It has been argued that there's really no appetite for democracy in Asia; that the great nations of the East have their own path which leads away from democracy. Tell that to the people of Burma. Or Thailand. Or the Philippines. Tell that to the dissidents of China.

Today people say that democracy can never take root in Muslim lands, or that democracy is un-Islamic. I regard that view as another prejudice, which seeks to deny human dignity. There is nothing in Islam, and nothing in Islamic nations, which means that those nations cannot be democracies. Not losing confidence in freedom, human rights and democracy: that is the liberal part of liberal Conservatism, and we should welcome the opportunity to make the case for the open and plural society once again. But we should also remember the Conservative part. We should accept that we cannot impose democracy at the barrel of a gun; that we cannot drop democracy from 10,000 feet – and we shouldn't try.

That was what was wrong with the "neo-con" approach, and why I am a liberal Conservative, not a neo-Conservative. I believe we should work steadfastly to advance liberal values wherever we can to build the characteristics of an open society wherever we can, confident that in time, democracy will result.

This is an edited extract from a speech given by the Leader of the Conservative Party in Islamabad this week

Interesting? Click here to explore further

"We should accept that we cannot impose democracy at the barrel of a gun; that we cannot drop democracy from 10,000 feet – and we shouldn't try."

Hiroshima. That soon got the Japanese voting. I don't care whether the people of China have democracy or not, as long as they can produce DVD's for a tenner thats all that counts. Hong Kong never had a Government nevermind a democracy and it became the fifth wealthiest region in the world. It achieved this because people like david cameron didn't go poking his nose in. I'm Conservative through and through. The great virtue of the average Conservative is the ability to mind his or her own business. David Cameron should mind his own business and leave Foreign policy to foreigners.


Posted by graham | 05.09.08, 21:09 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Cameron seems to have forgotten that having the barrel of a parliamentary gun for tyrants to stare down is precisely how democracy gets imposed. Without it, this country would still be ruled in accordance with the flow of 'culture, tradition and history' by a king oppressing us by divine right.

Until he shows he knows and appreciates something of the values and history of democratic struggle here, in this country, I am not going to take any lectures from Cameron or trust him to govern me.

Posted by Technomist | 05.09.08, 15:17 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

What silliness. What do you think happened in Tokyo Bay aboard the Missouri in 1945. Can't impose indeed.

Posted by steve c | 05.09.08, 14:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Whether democracy takes root in the middle east depends on whether civil law has sovereignty over religious law and officials have power above imams. Once you establish the idea of man made laws (and their flaws) democracy isn't far behind. If laws are immutable and god given, religious totalitarianism follows.

Still it's fun to watch a leader of a party trumpet democracy, when your party argued regional parliaments and the mayor of London were extra 'bureaucracy'. After the total power of the Thatcher government and the drift of the Major years, the Scots and Welsh parliament are the only reason you're so modest and partisan now!

Posted by TitlePK | 05.09.08, 11:44 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

yeah, yeah, yeah, tell it to the afghanis whose islamic govt was over thrown and a pro western democracy was imposed from the barrel of a gun, you are still supporting democracy being dropped from 10,000 feet there so pull the other one its got bells on it.

Abu Abdillah

Posted by Abu Abdillah | 05.09.08, 09:12 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I can fully subscribe to these words. Democracy is hard work, it does not just fall from the sky like rain. Liberal does not mean unbounded freedom but freedom without infringing on other people's freedom. And conservative does not mean backwards but carefully evaluating the merit of innovations.

Posted by Walter Leimgruber | 05.09.08, 08:42 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details