Commentators

Showers (AM and PM) 5° London Hi 10°C / Lo 5°C

Dr Fred Kavalier: Most doctors under 45 have never seen a case of measles – until now

Saturday, 21 June 2008

GPs' surgeries are full of young children with rashes and fevers. Sometimes the parent who brings the child to the surgery begins the consultation by saying: "I think he/she might have measles." But for the past 20 years or so in the UK, the parent has almost always been wrong. The truth is that most GPs under the age of 45 have probably never seen a child with measles – until this year.

There are quite a few infections and drug reactions that cause rashes that look a bit like measles. German measles (rubella) and scarlet fever (a rash linked to a throat infection), both look similar to measles. Reactions to antibiotics can cause a measles-like rash. There are at least a dozen other infections, from syphilis to parvovirus B19, that can mimic the measles rash.

But the distinguishing feature of real measles is that the child is usually really, really ill. In addition to the rash, measles causes a persistent high fever, red watery eyes and a dry cough. Children sometimes complain of sensitivity to the light, which (as all caring parents know) is also a symptom of meningitis.

In my first 20 years as a GP in inner-city London, the only time I saw children with measles was during a sabbatical break when I was working at a hospital in rural Uganda. In the developing world, where nutrition can be poor and medical care is often rudimentary, measles is a major killer of young children.

In the past year, measles has reappeared in the UK. Less than a month ago a mother brought two children to see me on a Sunday. Both had high temperatures, florid red rashes, very snotty noses, watery red eyes. Compared to the average toddler with a few red blotches and a mild temperature, these children were pretty ill. As they entered the consulting room, my first impression was that they probably did have measles.

My suspicion was confirmed when their mother told me that the children were at a school where there has been a confirmed outbreak of measles. One of the children had had only a single dose of MMR (measles, mumps and rubella) vaccine, and the other had not had MMR at all.

The news that measles is making a comeback simply confirms what public health doctors have been warning us about for quite a few years. As MMR immunisation rates have fallen, the population of the UK has begun to lose its "herd immunity". A single case of measles in a school can spread like a prairie fire. Most British children are reasonably well nourished and have easy access to good quality medical care. So we are unlikely to see many children who are killed or permanently damaged by measles. But the suffering that measles causes to otherwise healthy children is bad enough. And the sadness is that all this could have been prevented if the nation hadn't been seized by anti-MMR hysteria.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

"that is what made me determined to educate my self on this subject "
"Mercury in all its forms is poison "
:Posted by al | 22.06.08, 01:16 GMT
-----------------------------------------------------

al, you haven't managed very well. The UK MMR vaccine does not conntain mercury. Some of the US MMR vaccines did, as an additive called thiomersal, but the UK ones were always different.

Sad though your nephew's condition may be, you're blaming the wrong thing.

Posted by Comfy Chair | 23.06.08, 13:37 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

My nephew went from a giggly bubbly toddler to a deeply autistic child in front of my family's eyes,that is what made me determined to educate my self on this subject and there are many other family's who I have interacted with over the internet with very similar sad experiences iin the UK.
The odds may be fairly long that this will happen to your child but why take the risk??
If it ain't broke don't try and fix it as they say......
Mercury in all its forms is poison
DON'T LET THEM INJECT YOUR CHILD WITH POISON!


Posted by al | 22.06.08, 01:16 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

My children have all had the MMR, as have those of most of my friends. We have acquaintances - middle class, highly educated, and, dare I say it, with too much time on their hands and not enough to worry about - who have picked up on the MMR scare and not given the shot to their children. I was at school with kids who sported the wounds of serious childhood illness including measles and polio, and I am grateful for the huge public benfit bestowed by innoculation. I am incensed by the arrogance inherent in the middle class flight from the MMR which assumes their own children are too precious to have the jab, while expecting the rest of the population to take steps to help ensure their clinical safety. I blame Tony Blair for being coy about his young son in regard to the MMR, and thus stoking the flames.

Posted by J Holloway | 21.06.08, 18:48 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Media, esp. Daily Mail, are directly culpable for these deaths. Reactionary, uncritical reporting of MMR 'controversy' had led to this loss of herd immunity. The media in general should be ashamed, as should the gullible idiots that wouldn't vaccinate their kids.

Posted by Emilio | 21.06.08, 13:50 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

My 10 month old son was diagnosed with measles yesterday - as he hasn't had his MMR jab (usually given at 13 months) we are a little conerned and have yet to identify where it might have come from. Luckily he had an appointment with a consultant pediatriction (for another problem) that morning, who picked up on it straight away and whisked him into isolation. A stream of doctors, trainees etc were brought in to look at the rash as many had never encountered it before!! As an experienced mum I have seen all sorts of rashes, lumps and bumbs (especially with babies) and I'm sure, if a child had a mild dose of measles it might be put down as a viral rash or reaction to a new food and left! I honestly believe this culture of not innoculating with MMR due to risks of autism etc has a lot to do with the spread of what can be a life threatening illness. His three older brothers have had their MMR's and I would urge other parents to do the same.

Posted by Jacqui | 21.06.08, 12:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

My own daughter was just a year old back in 1988 when she got measles. My doctor didn't see a measles case either, even though I took her to see him. I was the parent who brings the child to the surgery saying: "I think he/she might have measles." and I was told I was wrong. It's comforting to know that it wasn't just my own doctor who couldn't diagnose a simple case of measles. Luckily, the emergency doctor called in the night could, and after wrapping her in towels drenched with cold water and a very anxious night spent watching a child with a high fever things gradually got better. Now the disease is on the increase again, let's hope the new generation of doctors are not as smug and dismissive as the last.

Posted by Kevin | 21.06.08, 11:53 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details