Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 5° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Janet Street-Porter: Forget local TV if you want to know what's happening

Wednesday, 1 October 2008

Facing plummeting ad revenue, ITV gained approval from Ofcom to reduce regional news bulletins and cut local programming by half. Yesterday it was announced that about 430 staff would be made redundant, although the broadcaster claimed it would provide some form of local service – with the number of bulletins drastically reduced – until 2012. In the Border region, for example, the number of programmes will plummet from 17 to just nine.

I've worked in television for four decades and I won't mourn the demise of local news. In North Yorkshire, I have the misfortune to watch the local bulletins during the BBC news at 10pm. They are appalling – like telly from the 1950s. The set is unattractive. Most of the items seem to be shot on a council estate somewhere in Leeds or outside the local court. Sport is always among the so-called newsworthy events. The area served is vast, probably the size of Luxembourg, stretching from revitalised former mining communities south of Wakefield to miles of moorland in Upper Nidderdale, where I live.

Harrogate, the richest and most cosmopolitan town in the region, barely figures, unless a member of royalty is visiting or the Yorkshire Show is on. Whether it's on the BBC or ITV, the presentation of local fare is lacklustre. When there was a local disaster – severe flooding in Doncaster and Sheffield in 2007 – the live coverage would have disgraced a group of media students.

When I'm in Whitstable, Kent, it's just as bad. Newsroom Southeast covers from London to Southampton to Dover and Margate! Kent and Yorkshire are fascinating, rich and varied counties, with masses of newsworthy happenings, but you won't see many of them on local television.

Local news, hampered by limited budgets, annoys more people than it serves. I once worked in Carlisle, producing a series for Channel 4, and the nightly bulletins, featuring murders from Manchester or redundancies in Newcastle, seemed irrelevant in a farming community. Ofcom sets the standards which broadcasters must adhere to, and they want local news to continue on ITV. I disagree. The BBC must provide it as part of its public service remit and ITV should be relieved of the burden. The BBC has more staff and better facilities – indeed it has a whole news channel broadcasting around the world. But it serves Dubai better than Dover or Durham. The BBC also trains staff to multi-task, filing bulletins to television and radio. The problem is that most of the talent doesn't want to work in local news. It's the poor relation, the training ground, and that's what you see on the screen.

The way forward is to make regional news even more local and the areas it serves much smaller. New technology could mean that ordinary people could file to local BBC bulletins from hubs in village halls, shopping malls and town centres. Local news should be multi-platform, using the internet as a message board and discussion tool replacing local news papers. Soon, we will be able to time-shift all programming, and so truly local documentaries can be made by teams of people from villages and towns, and swapped around a local network. The old way of doing news – a chap in a suit reading a bulletin in a studio at 10.20 at night – has had its day. Thanks goodness.

Don't blame the poor Bridget Joneses. They're in a trap

His nickname might be "Two Brains" but David Willetts, the shadow Secretary of State for Innovation, Universities and Skills, has boobed, claiming that a new generation of university-educated, Bridget Jones-style women contribute to family breakdown because they are likely to be the breadwinners. Bridget Jones was a girl who was desperate to find a chap, so it's the wrong analogy. The vast majority of people on the minimum wage are female, and many of them have no choice but to "bring home the bacon", to use Mr Willetts's naff expression.

Growing your own veg is like having sex

One of the most unpopular policies this government could have remedied relatively cheaply is the lack of single-sex wards in the NHS. Judging by my post and emails, many of you agree. Now the Tories promise to double the number of single rooms, creating 45,000 extra within five years of coming to power, at a cost of £1.6bn. Post-natal women and mental patients will all be offered them as a matter of course, and not before time. Can someone now deal with hospital car parking charges, which cause immense distress to families visiting their relatives? NHS Trust executives should pay for their own parking. That would help.

*According to a government adviser, we can deal with spiralling prices and food shortages by growing our own veg. It's true some prices have risen 30 per cent in the last year – potatoes, carrots, onions and tomatoes cost more because of poor harvests, lousy weather and high transport costs. But returning to the Good Life isn't without pitfalls. Growing your own is an emotional roller-coaster – big expectations, fervent prayers, a brief period of abundance interspersed with abject failure. A bit like most people's sex lives.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

14 Comments

If you think Look North broadcast from Leeds is bad, try the Newcastle version. It is unbelievably appalling. Every night it starts with a "Aren't Geordies great" news item, extolling the virtues of Tyneside and it's people. I live in the northern part of North Yorkshire and this programme has absolutely no relevance to me whatsoever. If anything the programme takes great delight in running down Teesside and N Yorks (although the "national" news also manges to do that very effectively as well). I have a Sky box and I have often watch BBC Spotlight programme from Devon & Cornwall (where I spend my holidays) as the programme is far more interesting, if a bit ametuarish as mentioned by other commentators. But at least I don't have to put up with the rubbish served up by my "local" BBC News service.

Posted by Mike | 01.10.08, 22:00 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I know Look North (or was it Calender) had hit rock bottom when they launched 'Tom Ingle's Forgotten Railways' feature. The internet is a far better source than TV these days anyway.

Posted by Ian | 01.10.08, 16:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

"Growing your own veg is like having sex"

But do you agree with this Robert? (If not then you didn't have to wait very long for the planets to realign). Not to mention the highly unrelated paragraph just below discussing single sex wards and politics. Not a bit like vegetables. Or sex, for that matter.

Unless of course the 'sex' in the title is referring to gender and the vegetables to David Cameron?

Posted by Sara | 01.10.08, 16:44 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Like how many houses does Janet have? It must feel great to look down on local news from her role as side kick to Neil Tenant and Elton John. Oh and she gets PAID to write this stuff.

Posted by Steven | 01.10.08, 16:22 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Yet Look North continues to claqim it's the best. I have satellite telly (not for much longer) and have watched the news from many areas. If you watch Look North and are not from Newcastle, you get nothing from it. In general, and as much as I hate to say it, I agree with JSP, and I think what she suggests is a very good idea.

I feel dirty. She'll make up for it I'm sure.

Posted by Robert Price | 01.10.08, 16:17 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I should have known that the woman behind the turd that was L!ve TV wouldn't have a better understanding of regional tv news.

Yes parts of it are better than others, and some regions are certainly more newsworthy.

In the north west we are spolt by two extremely good evening news programmes. Granada Reports even won a Bafta last year. (Something it appears JSP has only ever managed via the quality of graphics on one of her shows)

Regional news does need to expand its service wider than reaching just our tv sets, but I for one will be sad when these programmes inevitably disappear from our screens.

Posted by Simon | 01.10.08, 15:47 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I wholeheartedly agree, Look North is terrible. "And tonight the sad tale of how Doris from the west end has lost her tortoise after twenty years together".

Posted by Matty Morland | 01.10.08, 15:42 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I don't agree with Janet Street-Porter's remarks re regional news programmes. I used to share her view but not any more. Try watching North West Tonight - Gordon Burns and Ranvir Singh are brilliant also the weather and sports commentators - very entertaining, informative and extremely natural performers, all of them.

Posted by Viv Croft | 01.10.08, 15:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

"The way forward is to make regional news even more local and the areas it serves much smaller."
Which is exactly what's happening as local newspapers become online news providers, complete with video feeds. Strange that JSP hasn't noticed...

Posted by Sam Tana | 01.10.08, 13:03 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I quite agree that the way forward is to make regional news even more local and the areas it serves much smaller. Independent bloggers and small local newspapers can provide a much more locally responsive information input.

I have a blog that is almost exclusively about Walthamstow and have found over 400 things to write about in the last year. 70,000+ page views in that time suggests there is interest in local matters. A lot of it is about our real national sports - shopping and criminality.

Posted by Technomist | 01.10.08, 12:27 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

14 Comments

Columnist Comments

terence_blacker

Terence Blacker: The greasy gravy train of lobbyism

The idiocy and graft at work in the system barely merits a second glance.

dominic_lawson

Dominic Lawson: When 'life' should mean life.

Sometimes the public feel the perpetrator should not be released.

steve_richards

Steve Richards: Who is accountable for the police?

Why was Damian Green arrested with such spectacular insensitivity?