Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 5° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Janet Street-Porter: 'Healers' on the run – with your money

Thursday, 24 July 2008

The Government has rightly decided that doctors in the UK must face annual tests to determine their competence, and reapply to renew their licences every five years, something which anxious patients pressed for in the wake of the Harold Shipman case. No such controls apply to the lucrative alternative therapy business, where practitioners extract money from the gullible by offering treatments ranging from the bizarre to the frankly dangerous.

If I'd planted a tree every time I've paid for some of these weird cures over the years, I'd have grown enough wood to ensure I had no more heating bills... and, if I'm truthful, it would probably have been a far more productive use of my money. I've had the irises of my eyes "read", my aura cleansed, my hair analysed, and I've listened to some incomprehensible weight loss experts. Am I any healthier as a result? No, but all these treatments offered me (as they do a lot of people) a little bit of comfort psychologically, if nothing else.

Some therapies have entered the mainstream. The NHS now recognises the value of osteopathy and acupuncture. Massage is said to help to reduce blood pressure. The royals, including Prince Charles, swear by homeopathy. But the news that one of Europe's most wanted men, Radovan Karadzic, who instigated horrible violence against innocent fellow citizens, has spent his time on the run writing a weekly column about meditation for an alternative health magazine really takes the biscuit. Doesn't it just emphasise that thousands of people are currently working as alternative therapists with little or no qualifications, tapping in to our desire for healthier lifestyles. Karadzic, a trained psychiatrist, called himself an expert in "psycho energy" and saw patients at a centre outside Belgrade. He even had a website offering treatment for diabetes, using something called "quantum energy".

I don't doubt the gullible fell for it, just as I paid £60 to have a Russian woman run her hands around my body and eradicate "negative energy". That was a harmless con, but some a therapies can cause serious harm. Dawn Page won £800,000 in damages this week after injuries sustained when a nutritionist charged her £50 and advocated a diet which featured drinking a lot of water and reducing salt. The therapist, Barbara Nash – who also calls herself a "life coach" – described this ridiculous regime as "the Amazing Hydration Diet". Mrs Page says that when she started vomiting she was told it was "part of the detoxification" process.

What utter bilge. There's no such thing as toxins, except in the minds of people calling themselves alternative therapists. Mrs Page suffered brain damage and memory loss, enduring a six -year legal battle to reach a settlement. Mrs Nash, who has never admitted liability, obtained a diploma in Natural Nutrition at the College of Natural Nutrition, one of many such establishments. Log on to their website and discover that, if you pay £1,350, attend lectures from 11am to 5pm on Saturdays for 11 months and do the exam, you'll gain a diploma allowing you to practice as a nutritionist.

Reputable nutritionists want the Government to introduce compulsory licensing. I'd go one further. All alternative therapists should be licensed (like doctors) by the Department of Health, with far stricter controls set on the claims they can make. We scoff at the notion of a criminal like Karadzic offering healing – but every day unscrupulous therapists are taking huge fees from the public and offering little of any real benefit in return.

A very expensive revenge

Her website describes her as "activist... artist... woman and warrior", she's starred in a play (appropriately, perhaps) called Bonkers, as well as 500 TV ads. Tricia Walsh-Smith, left, loves being in front of cameras, but the wonderful video she posted on YouTube, in which she rants about her multimillionaire husband's sexual shortcomings and love of porn, has just cost her dearly. At their divorce hearing, the judge remained unimpressed that three million have seen Tricia's video and cut her settlement to just £350,000. The judge ruled that she'd elevated a private dispute into a public spectacle, causing hubbie "tremendous suffering". Meanwhile, she's holding press conferences and planning more television work.

* Shame that plans to open up the coastline to walkers have hit a stumbling block. The Committee considering the draft Bill want an independent appeals system set up, with compensation for any affected businesses. This ensures that the process takes decades and costs a fortune. Maintenance of the path should be overseen by local councils using funds allocated from the lottery, which is already paying for a chunk of the Olympics. The Government wants us to walk more – and the coastal path is a great way of doing that. At the moment, one third of the coastline is completely out of bounds to walkers – and one of the worst offenders is the Ministry of Defence. Can someone explain why some of our most beautiful coastline needs to be used for firing ranges? From Dorset to Kent, the seaside is desecrated by the Army, when there are plenty of better sites in the north and in Scotland, on moorland, miles from housing and tourist attractions.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

16 Comments

I am baffled that The Guardian will post such incoherent nonsense.
If you want to take up the topic of the admittedly grey market of supplemental treament you should have chosen someone who actually knows something about it its good and bad sides, and the reason why people are using supplemental medicine at all. This article is just a ramble of no interest to anybody but the writer, and rather than raising points is slanders everything in sight.

Posted by Thistle | 30.07.08, 08:59 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Unlike the healers mentioned in the article, Karadzic had a medical degree from the Sarajevo University School of Medicine. He was a psychiatrist, as someone else mentioned.

Posted by Dulcamara | 24.07.08, 14:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Well said, JSP!!! Your comments on 'Lifestyle-coaches' hit the mark! I read an article in a West Country community mag., where a Life Coach is 'sampled' by the very same community mag's editor! Needless to say, gushing and glowing comments abound, while the Life Coach is quoted as 'not making home visits with personal clients', rather 'meeting them away from their usual environment'. The editor in question met the Life Coach on a 'beautiful sunny morning' at a local seaside town, and apparently 'felt a lot more positive and motivated on the drive home'!

The article footnote quotes text abridged from two well-known self-help books, all of which makes me wonder if it wouldn't be cheaper to borrow the two books mentioned from a library, and to enjoy a beautiful sunny morning at the seaside free of charge!

Posted by S.O'Brien | 24.07.08, 14:20 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Simona, I agree with you. I wasn't arguing for detaox diets, I was saying that for Janet to say that toxins don't exist is a nonsense.

Posted by Andrea | 24.07.08, 14:13 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Jane, you are well off the mark claiming that the MoD is 'one of the worst offenders'.

It's actually well documented that MoD land is among the richest in bio-diversity - a lot of this due to the fact that animals prefer living in areas where hordes of anorak-clad peacenik bleeding-heart liberals aren't allowed to trample all over them, as they are pretty much all over the rest of the UK.

I would have thought this to be right up your street.

Posted by Mike Hayes | 24.07.08, 13:20 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Anyone whom has done their own research into herbs instead of being lazy and chasing every fad knows that they are effective and cheap to use, when used wisely.

Herbs from your own kitchen cabinet, or better yet, grown yourself, just plain old herbs, not magical detoxification cures or miracle weight loss concoctions, are what its all about.

Toxins DO exist in the system! How can you write that??!

However, anyone that thinks you can cleanse them out by sticking patches on your arse or drinking the juice of something-or-another to get rid of them is off base. What works more than anything is taking good care of that organ.

Anyone that follows self-professed "warriors" on their websites hawking god-knows-what without doing proper research on the subject only feed the negative image and inaccurate b.s. about herbalism and natural medicine...we need less of that, please, so just go to Boots like a good girl and leave us out of it!

Posted by K Douglas | 24.07.08, 12:58 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details



Why has the Independent chosen to headline this article "The Herbal Medicine Con" both on the front page of the newspaper and on the top of its website?
Janet Street-Porter does not mention medical herbalism at all, nor anything remotely approaching herbalism.
At the very least this is misleading. However, using the word "con" to describe herbalism in a headline, without any evidence to back-up such a description in the article, is approaching defamation.

Posted by Kate Sassi | 24.07.08, 12:06 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

But Andrea - the liver 'detoxes' the body and any other form of 'detox' is an utter lie. All of those silly detox diets and based on lies and celebrity branding, lies, mumbo-jumbo and nothing else. Vorderman should be ashamed - as should that stringey scottish fake doctor witch who has made a career of lies, lies and more lies. Wanna detox? Eat well - a balanced diet - drink water, give up takeaways and snacks and booze for a while, and let your liver do it for you. THAT is the only detox anyone needs.

Posted by Simona | 24.07.08, 11:54 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

'There are no such thing as toxins'

As one poster has already pointed out, the liver exists to remove toxins from the body. Maybe, before putting pen to paper, Janet would be wise to do some basic research into human biology.

Posted by Andrea | 24.07.08, 11:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

So, by admitting you stupidly paid for alternative medicines you are admitting Janet that you have been a gullible idiot for much of your life. Thank you. Been waiting for that confession for years. Strange, however, that you think you and all women are superior to men then, when it is almost exclusively women who pay for this nonsense and are hoodwinked into believing in it!!!

All alternative medicine is charalatan-promoted piffle - when it is proven, this medicine ceases to be alternative and becomes mainstream anyway. It is an utter scan and Prince Charles is the biggest genetically modified fool on the planet. But why do people believe in this codswallop? Are they really so stupid, ignorant and lacking in basic scientific empirical education?

Some people deserve to be scammed - I suppose they would have bought a piece of the true cross in another age, or a bone stolen from a grave that they have been told is the handbone os a saint! Fools.

Posted by DocSpoc | 24.07.08, 10:12 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

16 Comments

Columnist Comments

terence_blacker

Terence Blacker: The greasy gravy train of lobbyism

The idiocy and graft at work in the system barely merits a second glance.

dominic_lawson

Dominic Lawson: When 'life' should mean life.

Sometimes the public feel the perpetrator should not be released.

steve_richards

Steve Richards: Who is accountable for the police?

Why was Damian Green arrested with such spectacular insensitivity?