Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 19° London Hi 22°C / Lo 9°C

Janet Street-Porter: St George: the patron saint of cashing in

Thursday, 24 April 2008

St George's Day was celebrated yesterday in the usual way we mark these events – by linking them inextricably to sport. Instead of bunting, bright red England football shirts were festooned the length of Carnaby Street, and could be won by entering a newspaper competition.

Meanwhile, in my neighbourhood, a couple of white, overweight, middle-aged men lurched down the street wearing T-shirts emblazoned with the flag of St George, clutching cans of beer and singing "Jerusalem". They probably chanted "INGERLUND!" at full volume in the pub during the World Cup and flew our national flag from their white vans for weeks on end – the kind of people who aren't embarrassed to display the plastic bulldog that features in the Churchill insurance adverts on the rear shelf of their motor car.

Another reason why many patriotic citizens weren't keen to follow the Prime Minister and fly the cross of St George from their balconies yesterday was because the date had been hijacked by crafty entrepreneurs. It was simply another chance (like Mother's Day, Father's Day, Halloween and Christmas) to flog us T-shirts, umbrellas and mugs, not to mention plates of roast beef at participating branches of Beefeater Restaurants. For festivity read shoppertunity.

In London, stallholders from Borough Market sold produce – from oysters to cheese – in wet and windy Trafalgar Square, and a floating theatre marked Shakespeare's birthday by sailing down the Thames to the Globe. The promotion of St George is closely linked to the marketing of theme-park England, where visitor targets are the holy grail and tourists' cash a vital contributor to our leisure-based economy.

One of the most attractive characteristics of an Englishman is reticence– a tendency to be self-effacing and non-pushy. That's why there has been a reluctance to mark St George's Day with the kind of drinking, exuberant fancy dress parades, singing and dancing that the Irish and the Scots excel at when their turn comes around.

True, St George is the patron saint of the scouting movement, and hundreds of boys and girls marched in their uniforms in towns around the country last Sunday. But calling for St George's Day to be turned into a public holiday is doomed to failure. Up to 40 per cent of us have no idea how to celebrate it.

English Heritage cleverly exploit the commercial aspect of our past by selling everything from tea towels to seeds to key fobs in their gift shops at historic houses all over the country. I logged on to their online St George's Day guide, hoping for inspiration, but even that turned out to be sponsored by Wells Bombadier Beer. One of the traditional recipes featured fish in beer batter, another was chicken tikka masala. It seemed to be a marketing ploy encouraging us to visit attractions run by English Heritage – after all, that's what they are in business for.

The poem they commissioned from Brian Patten was a bit feeble, waffling on about larks and violets. With our mixed-up weather (sun in March, snow and hail in April), you'll not have seen much of either lately.

Nevertheless, festivities continue this weekend: asparagus will be driven from the Vale of Evesham and served to the St George's group of parliamentarians. There'll be a longbow archery competition in West Yorkshire, and a medieval feast at Lindisfarne Priory in Northumberland. If you don't mind, I plan to give it all a miss.

I'll be planting out my Italian cabbages, my Swiss chard and my leeks from Robinsons of Lancashire. That's what I call an English vegetable garden, a healthy mixture of the traditional and the tasty incomer.

Reality bites, even in fashion

Is there a natural trajectory for fashionable dress designers? Stage One, leave college, have first collection bought by small boutiques, worn by hot new models and featured in Vogue. Stage two, design wedding dresses for pop stars and royalty. Stage three, be deemed worthy of a retrospective at the Victoria and Albert Museum.

Finally, the need to make a decent living kicks in – even if that means coming up with uniforms for size-18 women flipping burgers in suburbia.

Bruce Oldfield might have dressed Diana, but he's nothing if not adaptable, and this week McDonald's proudly unveiled his new look for their staff. I'm not too keen on that dodgy neckscarf, but the top and skirt are really stylish.

* Cosmetic manufacturers get away with making all sorts of ambiguous claims about expensive creams that they market as being anti-ageing because most of these products contain extremely diluted active ingredients of retinoic acid, for example, in order to avoid side-effects like irritation and dryness. This means that the creams will have a limited effect, but it doesn't stop women paying a fortune in the hope of banishing wrinkles and lifting sagging chins, and as a result the "cosmaceutical" industry is booming.

Boots Protect and Perfect cream enjoyed massive sales after a television programme seemed to prove that it did make a difference to skin, and now scientists are carrying out controlled clinical trials on the cream to evaluate the true picture. It could mean that in future cosmetic companies rely on laboratory testing to validate their claims and market their wares – but don't hold your breath.

Meanwhile, models are using cheap baby wipes to remove make-up and a £2.49 nappy cream, Baby Bottom Butter from Waitrose, is the latest must-have moisturiser.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

18 Comments

You see Lindsey, I remember in the late 70s in the suburbs of london, there being a fair in the local park on st george's day - great for the kids, with stalls and rides etc, and the open-air shakespeare and music in the evening. It was great! I also remember that 11th november was quite a big thing, and harvest festival too.

All these things have been banned by stuffed shirts (and blouses) from the dreaded PC muliticultiralist local councils and replaced by grants to islamic bookshops and eid and diwali celebrations. You need money to celebrate a national day - but no-one cares in this country and a lot of people are emigrating to get away from the dump this country has become. Ironically, places like new zealand and more british than britian now. Paradoxically, if we had more patriotism there would be less nationalism - and racism too - and religious mania - from all types of people.

Oh and re the statues - white men did actually invent and build everything and create modern civilisation - so of course most statues are of them. Personally, I believe this is innate and genetic, not a result of sexism. I fully expect that that historical nothing Mary flippin seacole will get a great big statue in trafalgar square soon - she's a toofer - two for one, black and female... White male statues are now banned - but the 4th plinth should be shakespeare or darwin. Or Janet! I could stub my fags out in her great big bronze gob eh?!

If you left school in 2002 perhaps you have not yet realised the brainwashing you probably received. I can assure you that you will not have had a sense of national identity instilled in you as they do in france. Instead, you will have had endless lessons on the slave trade (all our fault), multiculturalism (what a spiffing idea), mary flippin seacole (again) and almost certainly have a very threadbare knowledge of british history (like your teachers). I may be wrong but... (used to work in it y'see).

Posted by Eddie | 25.04.08, 16:18 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Eddie,

I agree, England does get swallowed up as part of Britain a lot of the time. An odd example of this is the National Blood Board, which in fact covers only England as Wales (and I assume others) have their own. I expect the royal family only come up because of ingrained phrases like "the Queen's English" and there are relatively few phrases with the word 'English' in now, though these, like their Scottish and Welsh equivalents, are often stereotypes.

In terms of memorials, Shakespeare not only has his burial plaque in Westminster Abbey and the tourist industry of Stratford to his name, but also the new Globe Theatre which exists only to honour him and his plays. Darwin has a mural in his home borough of Bromley; something I was actually quite upset about as it replaced one for H G Wells; and a secondary school named after him. Please don't talk about them being banned purely for being 'white men' as I think you'll find virtually all the statues that are present in Trafalgar Square are of white men (and there is only so much space after all).

Local celebrations organised by councils would be an excellent idea. I think it would help foster some much needed community spirit, as well as bring a little joy into people's lives. I think it a little unfair to say councils spend all their money on religious festivals as I would expect the religious groups themselves would shell out for the elaborate parts, with the councils helping to organise the events. In most town centres there are usually huge numbers of christmas lights put out and lit by z-listers so I'm not sure what more you expect in that area. Also on a sidenote I did see a display of morris dancers last week...

I don't know when you went to school but I finished my A-levels in 2002 and I don't recall ever having a 'hatred of all things English' promoted to me. In fact most things I studied were English: history of WW1, plays of Shakespeare and Ben Jonson, poetry of William Blake, fiction of Ian McEwan, and geography of the Isle of Wight.

Posted by Lindsey | 25.04.08, 16:00 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

OK Lindsey - here goes.

One problem is that England, being large, has become almost totally swallowed by the concept of Britain - that is why the scots and welsh try to differentiate themselves - and anyway people abroad and in the UK refer to britian as england anyway. Also, people tend to refer to the royal family (outdated and awful apart from Brenda) or WW2 when talking of englishness.

On our English national day, (it could be 23rd April), which is also shakespeare's birthday and deathday (and why is there no statue of him or darwin in trafalgar square? Oh yes - they're white men...so banned...) We could do this: every council could have a fete/party/celebration in every local park, with traditional english food, and games, and music, and film, and theatre. It's what other countries do. It's what they do in ireland and scotland and wales (daffodils and evening song services); so why not in England?

There are so many many English people who have achieved greatness in all fields - in fact, England was the first modern country in the world - and traditional english food is also excellent (200 years ago it was admired throughout europe, then industrialisation changed it).

Unfortunately, I have no faith in PC bureaucrats and local councils - who can't even afford a few fireworks or christmas decorations, but somehow find millions for diwali and eid and prayer rooms and their own inflated jobsworth salaries. They'll make any English occasion a multiculturalist mess - full of steel drums and bangra and the usual diversity codswallop.

The thing is, this should start at home and in the schools - but as most teachers promote a hatred of all things english and big up other countries it seems we will never have social cohesion in this country. More suicide bombers though, who all went through this education system and decided to betray their country. I wonder why...

We should emulate the french who, in their rejection of multicultiralist ideology, and their superb education system, have got it so right.

Posted by Eddie | 25.04.08, 14:29 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Eddie,
Thanks for taking the time to respond to my post. I understand your point about nationalism in England being discouraged, but after living in Wales for four years and seeing only a small group come out in traditional dress each St David's Day to raise money for charity I wouldn't say their national day is particularly special there either.
Despite making many controversial assertions about other nations' views you still didn't make any suggestions of how I personally might go about celebrating my englishness, which is what I was really interested in.

Posted by Lindsey | 25.04.08, 13:55 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Alan

If the English were as nationlistic as the Scottish, many of whom do hate the Englsih and are brainwashed by Braveheart and sad schoolteachers to do so, they would be called BNP supporters and worse. So why is it OK for the scots to be like this and not the English? Personally I'd like everyone world-wide to stop flagwaving and singong dumb nationalistic songs. Tell you what, the Scottish can go first yeah? I look forward to it. Perhaps then Scotland will be less racist and non-scots will stop being attacked for their accents on scottish streets.

And yes I know the Scottish don't do GCSEs - like our Scottocracy (or Scrotocracy...) of a political elite and our tedious bean-counting PM, you perhaps need to do a Higher in sense-of-humour-studies. If you learnt proper history you'd know that what people think of as 'Scottish' culture was actually cobbled togethr by English Upper-class Victorians and Walter Scott. So it's all all fake and an English creation. Look it up.

Please feel free to consult an expert: if Scotland were independent it would go bankrupt, millions of jobs would come back to England and we would get 80% of north sea oil according to maritime law. We could also demand a refund of all the subsidies we have paid you, and continue to pay you, much to the understadable anger of those in northeast and northwest england who get less money because of the Bribery Barnett formula which gives you 10% more than the english. Hey, come to think of it... England for the English perhaps?

Crypto-fascist eh? I have never heard that word outside the zany confines of a comedy show. Well done for using a big word, evn though it past its sell-by date in 1973. Somebody got a dictionary for christmas...



Posted by Eddie | 25.04.08, 07:33 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

St George's Day has been declared a state holiday in Rio de Janeiro, even though St George is not the city's patron saint. Yesterday half the population was dressed in endless varieties on the theme of the St George-slaying-the-dragon t-shirts and immense queues of people waited in the hot sun for their turn to file into St George's churches to pay homage to the saint. Many were up at dawn to set off barrages of rockets for the saint.

Posted by Vik Birkbeck | 24.04.08, 22:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Eddie:

Firstly, there are no programmes on Scottish TV indoctrinating us to be more Scottish - these exist only in your imagination.

Also, the Scots don't do English Bastard GCSE - we don't do GCSEs at all, and your belief that the millions of us somehow collectively hate the millions of you is an appalling slur, typical of someone with 'issues'. Your grip of either maritime law or self awareness is non-existent.

It is however noticeable that for someone who sneers at other nations for their 'insecurity' that you seem to define yourself through your hatred of your neighbours.

Perhapos that's why the admirable English let St George's Day pass without celebration; it's too likely to be taken over by small minded crypto-bigots such as yourself.

Posted by Alan | 24.04.08, 22:27 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Lindsey. The reason why you would have no clue how to celebrate St-George's day is that you've been conditioned and trained by teachers, schools, the media, the PC 'liberal' elite to be like that. If you had celebrated every year at school and work and there were TV programmes about it - as with Scotland and Wales and Ireland - you would know what to do.

Personally I would prefer a British day - there did used to be Empire day years ago - but as the Scottish all do GCSEs in 'English B*stard studies' these days and to have become unpleasantly racist and nationalistic (perhaps they always were), and the Welsh make a big deal about 1st March, the English have to assert their identity - although it is only insecure and newish nation ststes that are nationalistic (Scotland, USA, Russia, Greece etc). Perhaps the English will get fed up one day and demand independence from those it subsidises - and take the 80% of north sea oil that belongs to them by maritime law...

Posted by Eddie | 24.04.08, 16:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

I find patriotism a difficult thing to express. I love my country, and do things like buy british produce and support local businesses, but I have to say, I wouldn't have the first clue of how to celebrate St George's day. So I'm not against it, I'm just not sure what I would do. Sit under an english oak, munching an english apple while reading Shakespeare's sonnets?

Posted by Lindsey | 24.04.08, 15:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

Janet Street-Porter is just one of those fashionably unpatriotic types who seem to despise England and just love trying to sound clever with puerile put-downs.

Why can't we have a National Day for England without people like her sneering? You don't seem to like England or the English, Janet, so why do you live here? Do you sneer at the National Days of the Scots, Irish and Welsh?

What a shame to waste your column on insulting any English people who just want to be patriotic,

Posted by R.W. | 24.04.08, 13:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note Name and E-mail are required.

Contact details

18 Comments

Columnist Comments

deborah_orr

Deborah Orr: For many in Glasgow East, Labour picked up where Thatcher left off

With a by-election coming up, it has become a fascinating part of the world

howard_jacobson

Howard Jacobson: Military service and ping-pong...

... that will separate the men from the boys

christina_patterson

Christina Patterson: A joyous display to help heal lives

Projects involving theatre, performance, music and the digital media


Most popular in Opinion