Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 3° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Janet Street-Porter: The growth industry that is now obesity

Wednesday, 8 October 2008

Obesity is big business these days. A conference on the subject this week has generated the usual doom-ridden headlines. Organised by the National Forum on Obesity, speaker after speaker produced scary statistics.

Three out of four adults are overweight (the way our Body Mass Index was previously calculated is now thought to be inaccurate), and the number of children chronically obese so worrying that one speaker proposed the radical solution of taking the worst offenders into care and giving them weight-loss surgery.

Our backsides are spreading so fast that schools will have to order jumbo-sized furniture. And when we snuff it, our coffins will be too big to fit in existing crematorium furnaces. So council tax will rise at the same rate as our chloresterol. It's enough to put you right off that triple-decker sarnie you'd bought for lunch.

But hang on. There's always another, less exciting version of the true picture. Let's take a look at who is behind this plethora of fat-phobic news. The conference (at the Royal College of Physicians) was organised by the National Obesity Forum. The event was fully booked, attended by healthcare professionals and local government officers. All no doubt enjoyed an overnight stay in London and all the drinks and canapés on offer at the end of a gruelling day debating such pressing matters as what role pharmacy – ie drugs – can play in dealing with obese patients.

Over lunch, delegates could wander around the exhibition in the college library and take in the displays mounted by the conferences sponsors – Slim-Fast, and leading pharmaceutical companies including Roche (makers of Xenical, a weight loss drug) Sanofi-aventis (makers of Acomplia) and Abbott (makers of Reductil).

A keynote speech was given by Anne Diamond, who has twice undergone surgery and been given a gastric band to deal with her own weight problem. The problem I have with Anne Diamond, is not the vulgarity of the jewellery she flogs on QVC, but the fact that she once took part in a television series, Celebrity Fit Club, and didn't own up to her fellow team-mates about her gastric band.

Another session was chaired by Dr Hilary Jones, the News of the World columnist and part-time GP – hardly a man on the coal-face of medical research. Other speakers gave lectures sponsored by pharmaceutical companies, demonstrating the unhealthy link between heathcare professionals and the vested interests of the drug industry. The programme was packed with advertising for various weight-loss products, the manufacturers of which supplied free gifts to delegates.

The National Obesity Forum was set up in May 2000, and you could argue that they appear to have been rather unsuccessful in having much impact on the nation's battle with the bulge. Call me cynical, but obesity has become a growth industry in Britain, and the number of so-called experts who get paid to speak at events like this is expanding at about the same rate as the number of consultants employed by this government.

The bottom line is, we eat too much and we exercise too little. Children need to learn about nutrition and cookery as soon as they learn to read. Their parents need to be encouraged and incentivised to learn to cook. It's as simple as that. We don't need potentially addictive drugs or any more statistics. We are fatter than we used to be but it's not the end of civilisation as we know it. The moment I see that drug companies are involved in framing the solution to a social problem, then I'm worried.

* As Jacqui Smith and Boris Johnson compile their shortlists of suitable successors to Sir Ian Blair, they might like to consider how some top coppers conduct their love lives, and perhaps impose a ban on extra-curricular nooky. I was astonished to discover that Michael Todd, Chief Constable of Greater Manchester Police, who some considered would one day be in charge of the Met, cheated on his wife with up to 12 different women over five years, many of whom worked with him and have been offered compassionate leave during the inquest into his death. Boris's past lapses seem piffling in comparison.

Why this £5m butter advert is Rotten to the core

Thirty-one years after the BBC banned his punk anthem "God Save the Queen", the former Sex Pistol Johnny Rotten is starring in his first television commercial, flogging butter and sporting a dazzling array of outfits – from a tweed suit with bow tie and waistcoat to a tartan dressing gown with clashing check pyjamas.

The King of Punk gets chased by a herd of cows in a £5m commercial for Country Life Butter. Rotten is backing Britain, but Dairy Crest, which owns the brand, claims rising costs could mean lay-offs and factory closures.

Don't blame me (and Kate)

I have received the ultimate accolade – identified by the Daily Mail as one of the 50 people who have "wrecked" Britain – in a new book by Quentin Letts. My crime? "Moulding" a media elite who favour youth over everything else.

The wreckers sound like a great bunch, including the distinguished architect Denys Lasdun and the football manager Sir Alex Ferguson. According to Letts, I'm a "non-revolutionary" who hangs out with Kate Moss, left, in search of eternal youth.

It is my second insult in a week. When Nigel Farage, the head of UKIP, a party with big aspirations and limited success, was bumped off Question Time, he told newspapers that I only appeared to give the show "gender balance". Female voters, please take note.

Boris can't compare

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

11 Comments

Male licence payers take note - many programmes (on sport, business, politics etc) have female presenters JUST to provide gender balance. The majority of sport/business/politics journos are male - but not in TV-land. Oh no, on the BBC et al sport is always presented by women, at least partly, despite there being so many fewer female sports writers or experts - is is essentially sexual discrimination against men as employees should represent applicants not the makeup of the general population.

But then Janet is a sexist who considers all women superior to all men, and Jent superior to everyone! Sad really, the way some pensioners go all loopy...

Posted by Sudsy | 09.10.08, 13:14 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

...Speaking of "piffling", was your snipe at Michael Todd really necessary? You don't really know the exact nature of his relationship with some of the women.

Mr. Todd was a fine man and has been publicly aknowledged as a "brilliant police leader". There hasn't been any proof that he ever let the Greater Manchester community down while he was at the wheel.

So, please keep your astonishment to yourself, it makes you come across as judgmental and bitter.

Posted by Steve | 09.10.08, 07:20 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

As regards the obesity problem, we can find hundreds of billions of pounds overnight to bail out squandering, greedy bankers, but not the millions of pounds it would take for one major step in solving the obesity crisis. Why doesn't the government set up a national network of not-for-profit local stores selling fresh, preferably local, seasonal fruit and veg, meat and fish at budget prices with free cookery classes on site, targeted at the poorest areas? Or it could just buy up stores to let out rent-free to independent retailers selling these products. It should also pay a large part of any benefits (including child benefit) in vouchers redeemable only in these stores. It would boost skilled retail employment, health, local agriculture and help rebuild communities.

Spend a few hundred more million a year on proper cycle paths, health centres and swimming pools and then things might really change. But I forgot, this is cowardly, useless New Labour, so it can never happen

Posted by Robert C | 08.10.08, 21:26 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Where did you get your proof of Michael Todd's apparent 12 conquests? I am sure Michael would no doubt be flattered to know that he had conquered so many women in five years, do you actually know the nature of these apparent relationships, no I thought not but hey that hasn't stopped anyone commenting on them so far has it. Pity the press weren't up to standard enough to actually catch him with his trousers down, a bit slow considering the amount of shagging that this man must have done, shame on the press for their missing out on real proof. Hell he must have been at it all over Manchester, on the way to work, on the way home, probably someone under his desk even. Come to think of it this man was worth knowing he obviously had a pretty good extendable baton.

Posted by Friend | 08.10.08, 18:06 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Just to clarify.Nigel Farage did NOT tell the papers anything about Question Time.Neither did the UKIP Press Office.
It was NOT Nigel Farage that used the term gender balance.That was the explanation given to him by the BBC.
Apart from that spot on Janet.

Posted by Clive Page | 08.10.08, 15:02 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

janet , i remember network 7 which was shoddy,amateurish and had magenta da vine on it.
i dont think you ruined tv i just wish you had not found magenta.

Posted by unhappy jon | 08.10.08, 12:32 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Actually, that was what the BBC said, not Nigel Farage. Male license payers, take note?

Posted by Trixy | 08.10.08, 11:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Janet, You're quite right that the long-term solution to the obesity problem should be down to individuals taking responsibility for their own health. We need to raise a generation of children inspired by food and knowledgeable about health - not dependent on weight-loss drugs. Cooking should be one of the most important lessons in a child's life. After all food is central to the health and happiness of every single person throughout their life.

The introduction of 'Food Technology' in schools completely misses the point - food should be fun, not formulae. You can't teach anyone, you can only help them to learn: giving students the chance to make good food is appealing. Force feeding irrelevant knowledge for exams is not.

Posted by Sean | 08.10.08, 10:07 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Darling tell when will you be mine quango quango quango quango cha cha cha char.
You really cannot blame a man for trying to avoid any NHS old folks home even "Che" would have flogged hemroid cream to do that.
Che would be proud of you.

Posted by RSBridgman | 08.10.08, 08:53 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Further, highly toxic soy products interfere with thyroid function and cause massive obesity. Put this on your obesity checklist,you are willing to go out of box to re-educate. Bell DS and others. Use of soy protein supplement and resultant need for increased dose of levothyroxine. Endocr Pract 2001 May-Jun;7(3):193-4). The University of Alabama at Birmingham reports a case in which consumption of a soy protein dietary supplement decreased the absorption of thyroxine. The patient had undergone thyroid surgery and needed to take thyroid hormone. Higher oral doses of thyroid hormone were needed when she consumed soy--she presumably used iodized salt so iodine intake did not prevent the goitrogenic effects of soy. Although soy has been known to suppress thyroid function for over 60 years, and although scientists have identified the goitrogenic component of soy as the so-called beneficial isoflavones, the industry insists that soy depresses thyroid function only in the absence of iodine.

Posted by ThomasT | 08.10.08, 04:34 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

11 Comments

Columnist Comments

terence_blacker

Terence Blacker: The greasy gravy train of lobbyism

The idiocy and graft at work in the system barely merits a second glance.

dominic_lawson

Dominic Lawson: When 'life' should mean life.

Sometimes the public feel the perpetrator should not be released.

steve_richards

Steve Richards: Who is accountable for the police?

Why was Damian Green arrested with such spectacular insensitivity?