Commentators

Partly Sunny with Showers 12° London Hi 12°C / Lo 6°C

Kim Sengupta: Has Pakistani intelligence fallen out with its offspring?

Yesterday's attack in Lahore would seem to be another bloody signpost pointing towards Pakistan's slide into anarchy. There was, however, an added dimension to this particular bombing which showed the complex intrigue behind the insurgency spreading across the region.

For the first time since the start of the jihad in Pakistan, a base of the intelligence service, the ISI, was hit and a number of its agents were reported to be among the dead from the blast.

The ISI has long been the sponsors of the Taliban and other Islamist groups who are active inside Pakistan and abroad. Did the blast mean that the intelligence service had finally fallen out with its protégés?

It is not impossible. The Pakistani army offensive taking place in Swat – launched after intense pressure from the US – has caused consternation within the military/militant axis.

Some of the militant forces close to the ISI are suffering mounting losses. The attack could be the insurgents' response to what they see as the failure of the intelligence service to stop the offensive, and a warning that they are not prepared to be abandoned.

A parting of the ways between the militants and the ISI could have far-reaching consequences, with the insurgents losing the protection that they have long enjoyed by men in power.

The blast took place hours after talks between General David Petraeus, the top US general in the region, and the Pakistani government. The US wants changes to the structure and operations of the Pakistani military, weaning it away from the mindset of a conventional conflict with India and toward counter-insurgency. They want the police to take a greater role in combating terrorism and are pressing for more separation between the army and the ISI to stop soldiers being indoctrinated.

There are problems in fulfilling these aims. For many officers, the raison d'etre of Pakistan's armed forces is to confront India. The police are poorly trained and armed and in no position to take on the insurgency; and, as for separation between spies and soldiers, as a former head of the ISI, General Javed Ashraf Qazi, pointed out: "You cannot distinguish between the army and the ISI because 90 per cent of the ISI are uniformed officers. There is no distinction."

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Evil that men do..
[info]sharifl wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 07:44 am (UTC)
It is not our job to point out the defects in the working of ISI; All the other countries have their boys doing the dirty job 'in the name of the country'. I do, however, admit that using religious zealots for this job was not the best idea. To say that USA encouraged Mujahideen to 'bleed' USSR in Afghanistan is only partially true. the interest of the country should have been thought of in Islamabad and not in Washington. Now these SOBs have returned from the front and are hurting their own country.
The army might win the war in Swat and else where today, but can it say that the children of today, being brain washed in the madrassas and other schools will do it differently when they grow up tomorrow? I do not think so. These schools must be banned and an education of science and other subjects should be taught. Too much of religion can be unhealthy for the society, any society.
Has North Korea heard the world protest?
[info]famulla wrote:
Thursday, 28 May 2009 at 11:43 am (UTC)
Kim Sengupta: Has Pakistani intelligence fallen out with its offspring?
Has North Korea heard the world protest?
I thank you.
Firozali A.Mulla

Columnist Comments

hamish_mcrae

Hamish McRae: A time for giving with a difference

With the recession, there is a shift from giving people things to giving them services

mark_steel

Mark Steel: Come rain or revo- lution, it's money they want

Haven't the 20th anniversary celebrations of the overthrow of communism been miserable?

terence_blacker

Terence Blacker: Science must never be political or emotional

Politicians and action groups select favourable data, ignoring inconvenient evidence


Loading...


Most popular in Opinion