Commentators

Rain (AM and PM) 2° London Hi 9°C / Lo 6°C

Mark Steel: People would play golf if the sport wasn't so snobbish

Dress codes ban denim and inist on jackets and ties in the bar

As the Open Golf Championship is about to begin, the question everyone must be asking is, "Why is a splendid game still allowed to be ruined by stuck-up condescending suburban snobs, who probably think the most scandalous aspect of the MPs' expenses issue is that Douglas Hogg let his moat get dirty in the first place?".

For example many clubs have an 'artisans' club attached to them, which allows commonfolk to play in return for labouring on the course. The secretary of a club in Yorkshire was quoted recently as saying: "The artisans may play on a Sunday after raking the bunkers, but they're not allowed at any time to walk in front of the clubhouse."

Because who hasn't, if we're honest, had our day ruined by unexpectedly catching a glimpse of a hideous artisan? If they broke the rule the club secretary would probably ring environmental health and scream "Come quick for God's sake, we've got an infestation of the working class. We've put powder down but they walk straight over it, it's terrifying."

This elitism oozes throughout golf. Dress codes bar denim and insist on jackets and ties in the bar to "Protect standards". They must fear that if they let the working class in, they'd drag a piano to the hole and all dance up and down to "My Old Man Said Follow the Van", until the green was ruined. Then they'd tape all the clubs together to make one long pole and use it as a chimney sweep, getting dirt all over the fairways, then turn the clubhouse into a shop selling everything for a pound. The place would be WRECKED.

A typical dress code, at the Oxford club, insists: "Caps must not be worn the wrong way round at any time on the grounds." Because if you relax that rule the Oxford spire posse would be down there yelling "Hey caddie I don't want no four iron muthah, pass me my Uzi, I'm gonna SHOOT the ball out the rough."

Representing one side of this elite cosiness over the next few days will be commentator Peter Alliss, conveying an Edwardian amateur unworldliness completely at odds with the fierce competitive nature of the players. And everything revolves around charming lunches and everyone's lovely as long as they're posh and you can imagine him saying: "Oh there he is there he is, the dear old Duke of Middlebury, right by the clubhouse, splendid fellow, hasn't missed an Open Championship for more than 70 years, except for 1943 when he commanded a unit of the SS in Bavaria and even then he found time to pop in to the Munich Masters, delightful wife too."

To be fair to the golf elite, they haven't just been obsessed with snobbery. They've managed to promote every other kind of prejudice as well. Hundreds of clubs refused membership to women until forced to by new legislation.

In America the Professional Golf Association adopted a 'Caucasian-only clause', that barred black players until 1962. Even now, a player in Yorkshire, Jay Athwal, has set up an 'Asian Open', because clubs make Asian players feel unwelcome. He said "A steward at one club told me not only could I never join, nor could my children's children." Of course the clubs don't officially practise segregation. They'd probably say "Coloured folk are more than welcome to join, as long as on the first tee they're accompanied by a missionary who converts them to Christianity."

But the frustrating part is far more people would play and watch the game, if they could feel comfortable doing so. In Scotland and Ireland, where it doesn't have the same image, golf has a much wider appeal. Putting greens and pitch and putt courses are hugely popular. But somehow society is so riddled with division, the simple joy of whacking a ball is organised to exclude most of the population.

So the first step to popularising the sport should be to change the commentators. This year's open should be covered by a DJ from Kiss FM, going "Big shout out to Lee Westwood and the fourth tee massive, put that bunker behind you bro. And here's a text from MC 2wood of Oxford saying Tiger is FIT, now down to the tenth for some Ernie Els action".

Peter Allis can be employed at crazy golf courses, muttering "Oooo my my my she's over-chipped that right over the windmill, and well, well, well she'll be lucky to make it into the funnel in two from there, what a funny old game this is."

More from Mark Steel

Post a Comment

View all comments that have been posted about this article.

Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.

Comments

Get orff my gofe course!
[info]rogersbrother wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 05:58 am (UTC)
Well if the policies of which you complain keep out sneering, whining socialist oiks like M.Steel one can see the point.
What else!
[info]over325one wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 06:26 am (UTC)
It's the last bastion of snobbery. But, if it's a club it's their affair. It's good to know that there are still places that would not want me, a working man as a member. Watt Tyler was always my hero! The reason they play golf at these places is that they have to look down their noses when striking the ball. Suits you Sir!
Who cares?...
[info]themartindale wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 06:52 am (UTC)
...a good walk ruined...
Golf snobbish?
[info]vaitibi wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:00 am (UTC)
What a pathetic piece of juvenile drivel - in a newspaper that calls itself Independent but isn't. I trust he didn't get paid for this.
Mark Steel: People would play golf if the sport wasn't so snobbish
[info]famulla wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:23 am (UTC)
Mark Steel: People would play golf if the sport wasn't so snobbish
NO IT IS expensive The sizes of the clubs do not fit my palms and they keep on changing from wood to fibreglass and stell. They are pretty heavy have you tried these on the heads of the caddy? Incidnetalyy do you have a doctor in the course?
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla
Holes Holes holes holes You put ball one at a time in one day
[info]famulla wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:26 am (UTC)
If you miss the hole you are idiot if you put the ball in the hole you are at par with what i have no idea But you get 12 points and some lost balls I have 345 marked WOODS and LOGS.
I thank you
Firozali A. Mulla
Out of date
[info]andy108 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:45 am (UTC)
This article is about 30 years out of date.
Land
[info]kaptainkitten wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 08:14 am (UTC)
People will always wish to show they are a cut above everyone else, even when they are clearly not.

That's fine, let the silly people have their delusion of grandeur.

But the issue of land makes it a public issue, so golf glubs must be seen as a public resource which should be accessable to all. Without prejudice.

If we had off-shore courses it would be different, floating man-made golf islands for example.


So these types can go and form a bridge club if they wish and have all sorts of rules and regs if they wish.




Just not with land involved
Re: Land
[info]andy108 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 08:32 am (UTC)
'People will always wish to show they are a cut above eveyone else'.
Do you include yourself in this? It sounds like it.
Re: Land
[info]gis_1506 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:26 pm (UTC)
why is private land a public issue? enviromentally golf courses are excellent, providing habitat for wildlife often incorporating woods and ponds. does the general public have a say in the way you use your garden?
[info]the100thidiot wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 08:32 am (UTC)
Most of the article rang true. But my experience of golf clubs is that there are also an awful lot of blue collar workers pretending to be posh - they like mixing with their "betters" and put on the same daft airs and graces.

And I just wish I could stop my mother in law harping on about golf the whole time. I choose not to play golf because I can't stand the tedious bores in the club house. But golfers don't seem to get this and insist on boring all who are still awake with the fine details of their last round. Yawn.
[info]roly9 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 09:29 am (UTC)
What a load of prejudiced bollocks! What kind of world does Mark Steel inhabit? Golf is played by thousands of perfectly ordinary people up and down the country and most clubs are very welcoming to visitors. Artisans included.
get a life
[info]daniels09 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 09:52 am (UTC)
Mark Steele wants to get a life. He should try some decent clubs - most municipal courses, for instance, or anywhere in Scotland not on the Open rota or called Loch Lomond.

BTW wearing caps back to front should be banned everywhere - penalty, six months community service picking up litter. Refusal to do so, prison.

Silly piece.
Mark Steele
[info]seant666 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 10:39 am (UTC)
My golf club does not have a jacket and tie rule , you can wear your cap anyway you like . I visit clubs that have these rules and I go with the flow , I wear a jacket and tie in the bar , what is the issue ? These so called snobbish clubs are some of the friendliest clubs I've been to . By the way the title of the article , " People Would Play Golf If The Sport Wasn't So Snobbish , I don't get . People do play golf in their millions every weekend , we currently have the number 3 in the world in Paul Casey and several others in the world top 50 . Is Mark saying that England would be better if more people played ? The article seems to suggest that golf is not popular , I don't see that . There will be 50,000 per day entering the gates at The Open over the next few days and check out the queues on the tees at most public golf course any weekend . The article is pointless .
Golf snobs
[info]philydog wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 10:46 am (UTC)
Presumably Mark wants to eradicate these oddballs, thereby depriving us the opportunity of chuckling at the pointlessness of their vapid lives. Leave it Steel! They're funnier than you are.
Mark Steele
[info]seant666 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 10:59 am (UTC)
Many Clubs have an artisans club attached to them ? Eh ? very few clubs have this , only a tiny amount of very old clubs have this set-up.
Hundreds of clubs refused membership to women before legislation forced them to ? Utter nonsense , the men only clubs again were very few and far between and were rightly vilified by the majority of golfers throughout the country.

I have no problem with articles slagging off golf and golf clubs but get your facts right first. Why is there always this class obsession when golf is written about, I am a member of a club , working class background and have never once in 30 odd years of playing ever had a problem anywhere. Why do people in this country have issues with dress codes? Why is there this issue with wearing certain clothes? Would you turn up to a funeral wearing a t-shirt and jeans ?
[info]hoody_youth wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 11:27 am (UTC)
They are just scared the working class might actually be better at it then them ;)
You don't get it do you?
[info]hugofirst wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 12:23 pm (UTC)
Lighten up you people for goodness sake! This is simply a humorous piece by one of the UK's funniest columnists. No more and no less. As we've just learned, Boris Johnson gets paid a small fortune for stuff which barely raises a chuckle dashed out over his Sunday morning toast and marmalade. The comic device much favoured by Mr Steel is known as hyperbole. I honestly think he is a master at it. And we don't even have to pay to read it. I'd like to see Mr Steel try his hand as a parliamentary sketch writer. He could probably give Simon Hoggart a run for his money. Yep, he's that good.
Mark Steel
[info]bestwasgod wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 12:31 pm (UTC)
Mark Steel is my favourite Indy writer with a brilliant comic/accurate take on most matters. I also dislike the "snobbish" middle class / aspiring middle class mentality pervading most golf clubs (and in numerous other "middle class" persuits eg sailing, skiing, rugby union, rambling, rennis etc etc). However, I have no idea where Mark is going with this and. unusually, he clearly has no real knowledge of today's subject matter (artisan membership -What ??!! ). Keep to your brilliant and highly amusing critiques on more serious matters and leave this sort of stuff to lesser talents.
Re: Mark Steel
[info]brholmes wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 01:15 pm (UTC)
"oh my, my, you've really chipped a beauty out of the rough there. surely a garaunteed eagle. well said sir/madam"
Warning
[info]daverawle wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 01:17 pm (UTC)
Wearing a baseball cap reduces the IQ by 50% - wearing it back-to-front reduces it another 25%.
[info]world_of_water wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 01:30 pm (UTC)
Down at the arsenal they keep the nerve gasses
Guarded day and night by caged white rabbits
Been sitting there for years
I'm gonna have at it
I cut through the fence, run right in and grab it
Go crazy crazy crazy crazy:

Now I got my own mustard gas in my pocket
Climb on a tree on a branch and drop it
On a country club full of Saturday golfers
So I can watch them die chokin' shakin'in convulsions
Go crazy crazy crazy crazy
Crazy crazy crazy crazy:

Chemical Warfare Chemical Warfare
Chemical Warfare Warfare Warfare

Panic in the air
See the headless chickens runnin'
Golf carts head on crashin'
Crackin' heads wide open
Scratch the grass, mister, you can't breath
And roll and writhe in a sandtrap
Starting to heave
Claw those clubs, lemme see you seethe
Crazy Crazy Crazy Crazy Crazy Crazy

Chemical Warfare Chemical Warfare
Chemical Warfare Warfare Warfare

Yellow air
Yellow clouds
Blowin' down down down the fairway
Sensitive to the touch
Mowin' down the putting green
Heading straight for the big clubhouse
Where the stuffed country club
Effervescent ladies, so carefree
Relax, pose by the pool
Limber limp with a dry martini
Until






MS
[info]seant666 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 01:44 pm (UTC)
But it's not funny?
displacement activity
[info]tph197 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 02:17 pm (UTC)
Golf is a displacement activity, specifically designed, to avoid what is generally called a Life.
Very Disappointing
[info]fox_1980 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 02:24 pm (UTC)
I'm normally a big fan of Mark Steel's work but I have to say that this column is absolute drivel from start to finish and is clearly written by someone who has not one clue about the subject matter. I play on public courses nearly every week and they are packed with ordinary working people, not the sort of out-dated stereotypes that Mark seems to think inhabit them.

All that could be forgiven if it was in the least bit funny but unfortunately it failed that crucial test too.

I expected better.
Rubbish
[info]hungryhungry wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 03:45 pm (UTC)
I'm working class and I don't play golf. Not because it's snobbish - I quite like laughing at posh people, and not because it's expensive.
It's because I'm rubbish at it.
Vile golfers
[info]idontvote wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 06:47 pm (UTC)
When I was 15 (1972) I used to caddie at Wentworth and Sunningdale. I can honestly say that I have never met such a vile bunch of nobbers as golfers. I vowed never to be like them and to this day refuse to have anything to do with golf.
People would play golf if the sport wasn't so snobbish
[info]septimusgrunge wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 07:42 pm (UTC)
Might I suggest Mark Sreel looks into the world of Tennis
people would play golf if the sport wasn't so snobbish
[info]vauban33 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 08:04 pm (UTC)
Would Mr Steel please let us know exactly which clubs he has visited? His ideas do sound somewhat out of date, although I must say my last club, which I belonged to for 40 odd years, did not seem to have any ethnic minority members as presumably none had tried to join? As to the rule about ties, these were only donned after 6pm., in case the absence of the same might offend lady members. The wearing of denim was not allowed, but since this is a very uncomfortable material in warm weather, perhaps a sensible precaution? On my last visit, I did see an Indian gentleman playing, and was somehow glad that I no longer played the game.
In total agreement
[info]paulbad123 wrote:
Wednesday, 15 July 2009 at 08:57 pm (UTC)
As much as I love playing golfers in general are complete plonkers. I totally agree with Mark
Rather an own goal, vauban33
[info]richardcarter wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 05:40 am (UTC)
Congratulations, vauban33, id anyone was unconvinced by Mark's article they only have to read your contribution to see that he was absolutely right:

"I must say my last club, which I belonged to for 40 odd years, did not seem to have any ethnic minority members as presumably none had tried to join?" No doubt because it would have been made absolutely clear to them that they were not welcome.

"ties ... were only donned after 6pm., in case the absence of the same might offend lady members." Why, exactly, would the absence of a tie offend any 'lady' member or, indeed, any normal human being?

"The wearing of denim was not allowed, but since this is a very uncomfortable material in warm weather, perhaps a sensible precaution?" And what if the weather isn't warm?

"On my last visit, I did see an Indian gentleman playing, and was somehow glad that I no longer played the game." That rather gives the game away, doesn't it? Why would any decent person not want to play having seen an "Indian gentleman" on the course?

Well done, old sport, you've (re)convinced me about a certain type of middle class bigot!
Re: Rather an own goal, vauban33
[info]vauban33 wrote:
Thursday, 16 July 2009 at 04:49 pm (UTC)
Dear Richard - you've obviously never heard of the old expression "tongue in cheek"? My observations were not meant to be seriously taken, but you've taken them!! As to being a middle-class bigot, you will be interested to know that I am so working class, it's not true ( and can trace my working-class ancestry back to the 1500s - apart from one Mayor of London)... Although I did send my children to public schools - where the classes averaged around 12 and my son to Cambridge where he achieved an education not usually available to persons like myself who spent their leisure hours practising games - any games, not just golf, and achieving some skill in most of them - presumably Mr Steel is also against tennis, as this game seems much more snobbish than golf and we English don't seem to be very good at that either? On the subject of ethnic minorities failing to get into golf clubs - can you imagine the damages that could be paid out by a club that refused them? Getting back to denim, anyone who wears it to the exclusion of other materials is probably barmy, and completely biaised towards comfortable clothing. I still play golf, and think the best player at my club is an ethnic...I'm not sure what ethnicity he has and would never ask him, but believe me, he's very good.
True and to the point
[info]bianca_2306 wrote:
Friday, 17 July 2009 at 01:11 pm (UTC)
Great column once again. Funny and unfortunately not even exaggerated.

Brilliant as always, Mister Steel
Allis
[info]bestione wrote:
Sunday, 19 July 2009 at 10:12 am (UTC)
Peter Allis is one of the best, most knowledgeable commentators on sport there is. he may be genteel, but that is not the same as a snob. I agree that many elite golf clubs have a terrible attitude, but many clubs are full of normal people. My club had a no denim rule and no Tee-shirts as shirts must have a collar, but I play in a rugby or polo shirt, always wear a baseball cap (if you are older than your (UK/US) shoe size and wear it backwards you are a twat anyway), and have NEVER worn a tie or jacket in the bar. There are also lots of pitch and put courses in the UK, once you get away from London.
Come on
[info]bugsyb6 wrote:
Thursday, 23 July 2009 at 05:55 pm (UTC)
Mark, I read all your articles and have enjoyed doing so for many years. I generally share most of your views but in this case I think you are missing the point.
You are generalising hugely about golf clubs....there are some yes that impose stricter codes of dress and there are a few pompous clubs that make non-members change in portakabins rather than the members' changing room and so on. But most clubs aren't like that and my own club has a real mix of members from car mechanics to City brokers. Most clubs I play are friendly and I don't think people mind not being able to wear jeans for a day - not exactly a hardship. One of my best friends shares your views on golf...saying that he hates the 'club' mentality and the 'elitism' it exudes.but then he doesn't play so how would he know. This is not a minority sport and it could not be described as being elitist. Most clubs are crying out for members these days (largely because so many clubs were designed and built in the 1980s)
But fair comment about Peter Alliss he is a pompous arse.


Columnist Comments

bruce_anderson

Bruce Anderson: The EU battle isn't over for Cameron

A short-term crisis has been averted, but a longer term crisis is inevitable

simon_carr

Simon Carr: Don't call me an alcoholic

Binge-drinking was once praised as being safer than steady soaking

philip_hensher

Philip Hensher: Berlin... but that was in another country

A great wall rises up between us and what we remember


Loading...


Most popular in Opinion