Commentators

Showers (AM and PM) 6° London Hi 10°C / Lo 5°C

Michael McCarthy: At a time when elephants need our protection, this is a shameful decision

Wednesday, 16 July 2008

All over the globe, the natural world and its wildlife are under pressure as never before from the demands of human society. Fish stocks, the seabeds underneath them and the seabirds above them, are everywhere being decimated by industrial-scale fishing; rainforests are being cut down on every continent on which they are found; pollution is spreading across watercourses and seas; and many of the great wild animals, the "charismatic megafauna" are being driven to extinction.

How many tigers are left in India? No one knows, but it is probably fewer than 1,500, as they have disappeared from many of the protected areas that were supposed to be their refuges. How many mountain gorillas are left in Africa? Just 700. How many northern white rhino are left in Africa, come to that? At the last count, when they were last seen in Garamba National Park in the Democratic Republic of Congo in 2006: four.

As well as the pressure from development and deforestation, it is direct poaching that is sending numbers of the world's biggest and most majestic mammals plunging down towards extinction, and it is with this background that the British Government voted yesterday to allow an enormous re-expansion of the ivory trade, which more than halved the population of the African elephant between 1980 and 1989, until it was rightly banned.

Its decision is not only reprehensible: it is mad. Africa has terrible human problems and in most of the 37 countries in which elephants are found there is simply no money to enforce wildlife protection, no money to pay rangers and give them boots and guns and Land Rovers; you can only protect wildlife if you choke off the temptation for it to be illegally killed. Yesterday's decision racks up that temptation a thousand-fold. It is truly shameful.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

The African elephant is one of the most human creatures that walk this earth. They are extremely intelligent, emotionally bonded to their families and friends, capable of both joy and grief. It is horrific that such a decision was made to further the senseless destruction of such incredible beings. Just when we felt that the elephant halocaust was over, it now begins again in earnest. The CITIES Secretariat should be ashamed of themselves. How dare they proclaim that they are protecting endangered species, when it seems they bow to the almighty dollar and political loop holes instead.

Posted by T Dysart | 22.07.08, 03:16 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I am still in shock that we voted to promote the slaughter of elephants. Bowing down to China like this is truly disgusting.The fact that some African countries were against this sale speaks volumes, it is indeed a sad day for the reputation of our country, how dare this government put our name to this dirty deal!


Posted by Maureen Woodham | 16.07.08, 23:00 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Well Said Michael - couldn't have put it better myself.

I don't really blame the poachers as such - if you got nothing some one comes with a wallet full of dollars what you gonna do.

I say a fraction of what we spend on killing each other could equip the rangers so they could do their job.

This is the sam as the whales, come to that the vultures in India, the tigers, the reefs , the forests in fact the whole biosphere.

This makes me angry it makes me feel ill it makes me feel sick, most of all it fills me with a sense of sadness that this is the best that our so called leaders can do.

If the can't stop this ( ditto for whales) then THEY WILL NEVER STOP CLIMATE CHANGE - get rid of them lets get people in charge who actually care.

The whole system is rotten to the core eradicate it - we are a mass extinction event in process - WE WILL NOT BE HERE IN ANY MEANINGFUL SENSE UNLESS THEY ARE STOPPED.

Rise up - pretty soon we will have nothing because of them.

Posted by Sparky | 16.07.08, 13:32 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

So, Mugabe's ivory goes to China. The EU approves. How much changes in a few days. Shame on the UK Government and shame on China. A very sad day for all wildlife - the politicians carry on as if nothing in the world is changing as global warming threatens people and the environment more than ever.

Posted by Dave Currey | 16.07.08, 12:07 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Brittan is trying to be ever so Politically correct - I wonder what went wrong here? Why don't you sell your own Elephant tusks to China, don't rape Africa, it feels like we are being skinned alive like the Chinese do to cats and dogs. Thanks a lot Brittan for stabbing Africa and it's beauty in the back!!!!! Hope you sleep well tonight.

Posted by Solveig Klahr - Animal Activist | 16.07.08, 11:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

This story was not covered by any of the other major papers and I didn't hear anything about it on the BBC. The Independent did well to warn people about. However this was far too little, too late. By the time any of us heard this was going to happen so that there might have been some kind of popular protest the decision had already been made. News agencies, the Independent included, must take some responsibility for what makes it onto the public agenda and what doesn't. This sadly did not. This is a sad day indeed, not just for British politics, but for the world.

Posted by John Newport | 16.07.08, 09:25 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

This is the final straw for me and hopefully many others. This decision is an absolute disgrace and as such I will no longer be voting Labour at the next election.

Posted by C Wilson | 16.07.08, 07:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I am a Labour party member and am deeply ashamed of my party in government for backing this.
Ms Ruddock can explain to the children of generations to come why she did not act to stop this.
It is shameful beyond words.

Posted by Mike | 16.07.08, 06:48 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

This is heartbreaking and discouraging news. What's wrong with the British government? I'm cancelling plans to visit Britain in 2009. and from now on I'll try to avoid buying anything made in Britain. It's a small and probably ineffective way to protest this decision, but I'd encourage more people to do the same thing. We're supposed to be working to try to reverse the global decline in species, not accelerating it with stupidity and greed. Shame on the British government and shame on China. Thanks to Michael McCarthy for a clear and eloquent argument against this retrograde and really quite horrific political action.

Posted by Caroline G. | 16.07.08, 05:40 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I will never forget the first time I saw wild elephants (in Zimbabwe) and am horrified that they will, once again, be hunted simply for their ivory. They are possibly the most intelligent and majestic animals on our earth. The greed of China is totally reprehensible and I am deeply disturbed that the British Government should be seen to pander to this. To me this is just another step towards Chinese domination of Africa first, then the world!!

Posted by Sue Shaw | 16.07.08, 05:11 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details