Commentators

Showers (AM and PM) 5° London Hi 10°C / Lo 5°C

Nigel Morris: This could be the knock-out blow for a PM on the ropes

Friday, 25 July 2008

Crewe and Nantwich falls into Tory hands for the first time in half a century. Labour comes fifth in Henley. More than 300 Labour councillors are kicked out of office in town hall elections and Boris Johnson takes control of London. Labour's opinion poll support crashes to an historic low of less than 25 per cent. How could it get any worse for Gordon Brown?

But it did get worse in the small hours today when the SNP's stunning by-election victory in the former Labour fiefdom of Glasgow East was confirmed. And just as the Prime Minister should have been relaxing in his Suffolk holiday home, it could be about to get worse still.

He faces a torrid session at Labour's national policy forum today, where party activists and union leaders will be wondering what the point is of drawing up policies when they look doomed to election defeat. His meeting with Barack Obama tomorrow will also provide a cruel contrast between a president-in-waiting and a Prime Minister heading for the exit. Mr Brown will face a fresh round of questions over his chances of surviving until the end of the year.

Before the Glasgow East result was declared there were already subtle signs of Cabinet manoeuvrings. Labour backbenchers – many of whom had witnessed for themselves the mixture of hostility and indifference to the party on Glasgow's doorsteps – left for the parliamentary recess this week in disillusioned mood. The gloomy whisperings will intensify when they return from their Cornish beaches and Tuscan villas. Given the murderous mood of the electorate, even those Labour MPs with apparently comfortable majorities could be facing the dole in less than two years' time. They know there is little chance of an economic recovery boosting their electoral prospects as all the signs are that the slowdown will continue and perhaps worsen.

Many will wonder whether their desperate last throw of the dice could be to change leader. The mechanism for setting that process in train is unclear, requiring a succession of MPs to go public in their demands for Mr Brown to step down or for a delegation of party chiefs to tell the PM that his days are up.

Mr Brown is a famously resilient politician and his allies will close ranks around him. But it could be that the voters of Glasgow's East End have struck a fatal blow to his hopes of remaining much longer in No 10.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

29 Comments

Zanulabour's first mistake was to try to be Nutory-lite-Blair made that one and Brown went along with it- we do not want the NHS privatised thank you and we do want localPost Offices, hospitals and police stations

Posted by peter c | 27.07.08, 12:10 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Arrogance, hubris, ignorance, stupidity, how shall I name the reason for Brown keeping the keys to N10?
Who does he think he is?
Certainly not the brilliant financial mind and the powerful and much loved leader in waiting of more than a decade of press fiction and his own dreams.
Brown, please go.
Now

Posted by Norman Bernard | 25.07.08, 22:24 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

the curse of Magna Carta strikes againthat'll teach nulaba to abolish Habeus Corpus and ban smoking in pubs now everyone hates Gordon

Posted by peter c | 25.07.08, 22:07 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

GB is his own worst enemy. Making new policy to make people work for benefits a tory idea, and he wonders why they voted them out. All safe Labour seat's will go at the next election as the core voters have been cheated by the PM with his nu-labour conservative 2 minsters bringing this about. Labour go back to being Labour. You may then not be wiped out then at the next election. Shame on you JGB.

Posted by James | 25.07.08, 13:10 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

The Brown cabinet never speak to the electorate and they never listen to the electorate and if we try to use something like Glasgow East to send them a message, they close ranks around Brown and tell us that we are all wrong

The worst thing is they send our armed forces into battle to defend democracy abroad when they dont seem to believe in it for their own country

Posted by Dave | 25.07.08, 12:35 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Owls hootings......Chains rattling...."I am the best man for the job"....."Get on with the business of running the UK"....Gordon Brown is a Poltergiest conjured up by Millbank; designed to stay "on message" for eternity or until he is exorcised by the "walking dead" in Westminster.....

Posted by Crawford | 25.07.08, 12:17 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Will Brown muse as follows on his ‘hols’?
‘Why is it all turning out like this? Maybe I should have made an appearance in Glasgow East’; but I thought that strutting the world’s stage would have impressed. I blame it on that greedy pair, the Blairs, the Ceaucescu’s of Islington, and his greedy New Labour litter who can’t get their snouts out of the trough...and what’s wrong with me claiming that the taxpayer should pay for my light bulbs. If you are going to worry about every little thing...OK, OK I grabbed too but it was done in a measured way, done for the economy, wasn’t it darling? Well, perhaps a bit...to shore up my reputation.

Still, I am the best man for the job. Now where’s the hubris in that. I still believe it and I only know what I know. Hold on, isn’t that what Blair said when he got us into Iraq. Oh dear, I never should have said that about the Arctic Monkeys, should I, darling?
“Stop calling me darling! I never know whether you are talking to me or to him.”

Posted by bosco cheevers | 25.07.08, 11:51 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Metropolitan journalist have been blinkered about events in Scotland, seeing this as being all about Gordon Brown, about Westminster and as a protest vote to a government in mid-term, and are only been galvanised into some kind of wider analysis when there is an easy hook for a sensational story. Things look very different on the ground in Scotland.

The Glasgow East result is much more than a protest vote, and to suggest that a significant proportion of the Glasgow East electorate did not fully realise the implications of voting for the Scottish National Party, and for a candidate totally committed to the independence of Scotland, is self-serving, patronising nonsense emanating from the unionist parties, and less than objective journalists.

This is the beginning of the end for the UK, and of Labour as a political force. David Cameron should commit fully to English nationalism, and begin the process of building a new relationship with the Scottish nation. Scots wish him well.

Posted by Peter Curran | 25.07.08, 10:52 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Why the constant complaining that Gordon Brown, is an unelected PM, it’s not his fault that no one within the party stood against him.

I’m not particularly pro-Brown but there seems to be a-lot of this “unelected scottish Prime Minister” talk. Is it more of an issue that he hasn’t held a general election because he is Scottish?

Posted by JohnM | 25.07.08, 10:34 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Time to face reality, Greedy Gordy has had his chips, time to go and take his hideous grasping NuLab morons with him. Sadly for the UK we face the prospect of Cameron and the Tories in power for the immediate future and lets face it, they will no better. Will they end the fuel duty escalator that is adding to the price of already rising oil prices, will they reduce the duty by 25p, will they hold the energy and utility companies to account for rising energy prices whilst making obscene profits for their shareholders? No of course they won't and bear in mind that these greedy MP's will continue to help themselves to our tax money with their over generous expenses. It's depressing just thinking about the whole mess this country is in and even more depressing thinking about the future!

Posted by eddie Appleby | 25.07.08, 10:14 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

29 Comments