Commentators

null 21° London Hi 21°C / Lo 16°C

Philip Hensher: Never mind the flags, just enjoy the music

Monday, 21 July 2008

For such an obviously immense and successful music festival, the BBC Proms presents, year after year, a surprising number of problems. It ought to be a matter of huge celebration. Every year, it supplies a remarkable range of top-quality concerts. It fills the hall with some of the most unexpected programmes – last year, a late-night concert of renaissance polyphony I happened to catch was packed to the roof. It is immensely popular on radio and television over two months and constantly challenges the audience with unexpected combinations and unfamiliar repertoire, as well as giving them the opportunity to hear visiting orchestras of world class.

Perhaps it's the Proms' evident success that points up some structural problems in London's music-making. For decades now, the administrators of London's concert life have been wondering what, exactly, happens to the huge Proms audience between October and June. For some reason, for many London concert goers, classical music is something which largely happens in the huge steam bath of the Albert Hall in late July and August. The relatively more civilised atmosphere of the Royal Festival Hall in the winter, on the other hand, has to struggle to register on the collective consciousness.

The Proms are, undoubtedly, an occasion, and they seem to be going through a particularly strong period at the moment. When the Government minister Margaret Hodge, earlier this year, singled out the Proms as an example of non-inclusive cultural activity, one wondered what on Earth she could be talking about. For a range of prices extending to the amazingly low Prommers' price of £5, a vast array of art music is made available to anyone who feels like it. The audience style is democratic and often very casual; the music-making, often, immaculate.

What Hodge was talking about, in her characteristically ignorant way, was, of course, the Last Night of the Proms. I don't think I've ever met anyone who doesn't think the Last Night, with its flag waving and its depressingly miscellaneous approach to programming, is anything but an embarrassment. Even if you found yourself able to enjoy the night, it presents huge problems for the festival as a whole.

This year's festival, for instance, includes a Berlin Philharmonic Turangalila, a whole Stockhausen day, and what looks like an unmissable Boulez account of the Janácek Sinfonietta and Glagolitic Mass. Is it really right that music-making of the highest order should be represented by the one-night-only flag waving?

The Proms provides abundant evidence of the general thirst for serious music. British musicians occupy the highest positions of esteem and fame throughout the world. London has more top-flight orchestras than any other city in the world. And yet there seems to be some difficulty in making an impression. "Music", in some newspapers, has come to mean exclusively pop music. Classical music is hardly ever given any space on the mass media – even such an obviously gigantic event as Daniel Barenboim's Beethoven cycle, earlier this year, could not clear the ceaseless round of crown green bowling and darts championships off BBC2, even for half an hour of Opus 111.

The Proms is the one point, evidently, when general awareness of classical music is awoken for a month or two. The challenge, for those who make such a success of this series of concerts, is to make people aware that they don't begin and end with Land of Hope and Glory; and to turn what sometimes seems like a summer enthusiasm into a year-round devotion.

A long Welsh wait for Brian

Don't hold your breath, but there is, at last, a remote possibility that The Life of Brian, which was banned by the burghers of Aberystwyth in 1979, might be given a licence to be shown in the Welsh seaside resort.

By an odd coincidence, Sue Jones-Davies, who played Brian's girlfriend in the much-loved classic, is now the mayor of the town. Beyond the age of videos, and into the age of YouTube, it now seems astonishing that a town council could effectively prevent its populace from seeing a film in this way. Borders and controls have dissolved in a way inconceivable in 1979.

I hope the people of Aberystwyth enjoy this delightful film after a three-decade-long wait. In case they hadn't heard, he gets crucified in the end, by the way.

* Dr David Hessayon, the horticultural expert who has sold some 50 million copies of his highly reliable and well-researched gardening books, has upset some of his many admirers. At the age of 80, he observed in an interview that, no, he didn't find gardening therapeutic or relaxing. It was, quite simply, his job.

I don't know quite why this should come as a surprise to anyone. It reveals rather a lot about the English gentlemanly insistence on assuming every human endeavour – discovering Australia, writing epic poems, breeding llamas – is probably nothing more than a hobby. Hessayon's books are so good precisely because they are not put together by a hobbyist, and he is right to resent any other suggestion.

A woman novelist acquaintance of mine was once informed by her dentist that he was going to write a novel himself one of these days. "That's a coincidence," she said. "I was thinking of taking up root canal surgery myself."

Interesting? Click here to explore further

xtQlMZ fdasjhgadghi hdagh iao hiasoh fgiash isafohsa

Posted by flower1800 | 22.07.08, 09:46 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Gay fascism is on the rise again, I presume Dr Watson.

Classical music is used in every Hollywood blockbuster and appreciated as such. by the masses, indeed.

The RLPO recently played Lennon's music brilliantly and was appreciated by ordinary scousers, of all persuasions. But not on the telly. despite capital of culture.

The Proms are an elitist, fascist display where the good music is only shown on telly because of the aristocracy (or is it the nouveau middle classes?) and the flag waving, with all their associations with murdering imperialism.

It's sad the music is not shown otherwise.

How sad.

Thank god for digital channels or they'd be on BBC1 or 2....

Posted by ian soffe | 22.07.08, 01:43 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Why does everything have to be inclusive? People are individuals and they don't all like the same things. Nothing is entirely inclusive if you want to get down to the nitty gritty of it. I hate football. It's never going to include me. But I have no problem with anyone else enjoying it or it having TV time.

If we are going to be a truly multi-cultural society, that means accepting everyone's culture, that includes the indigenous culture. I think articles like this are counter-productive. It's the sort of divisive behaviour that the tabloids indulge in. It gets people's backs up and causes conflict where non existed.

The proms are there for music lovers to enjoy. And music lovers come from all backgrounds and walks of life. It's a bit patronizing to suggest otherwise.

Posted by Andrea | 21.07.08, 15:02 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Sournote Mr Hensher seems unaware of the delight and pride of most people at The Last Night of the Proms. As a visitor from Canada I am always overwhelmed by the response of audience at that concert. I envy you that national joyousness.
Canada Goose

Posted by Canada Goose | 21.07.08, 15:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

So - People cant celebrate St George's day because its racist?
Why isn't St Patricks day/St. Davids day/St. Andrews day?

- People cant go to the last night of the proms and celebrate British greats like Elgar and have a good patriotic sing because its not all inclusive?

I'm very aware of this countries multiculturalism as I'm black. But I love this country i consider myself nothing but British I was born and I'll die here but we have absolutely no national identity any more. Nuts to the people who think we need to get rid of great things like the Last Night of the Proms, they are the ones who need a bit of National pride. Every other country in the world has more national pride than we do. People need to celebrate the fact that we are all British!

Posted by Ben | 21.07.08, 13:26 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

You are a miserable g*t. Why shouldn't we have ONE occasion to sing patriotic songs , wave flags and have fun? Good old Elgar -whoops - sorry forgot; Labour outlawed fun and loving your country.

Posted by Peersrogue | 21.07.08, 10:21 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I don't think I've ever met anyone . . . the festival as a whole.

You must move in very limited circles then, but you had to include that to demonstrate your multicultural credentials. And why should it be inclusive? It's fundamentally a festival of european classical music, but I'm sure than ultimately the organisers will be pressured into including Motown. They could make the proms more accessible by holding them somewhere in England instead of London. Brum would be fine.

Posted by Trofim | 21.07.08, 09:55 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

The proms this year has music by composers from 20 different countries and 4 different continents. The origin of the performers is probably even wider. If the UK puts on such a wide ranging festival of music why should it not congratulate itself at the end.

Posted by ron | 21.07.08, 09:06 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Funny then how the Danes thought so highly of The Last Night that they always transmitted a TV recording of it on their public broadcast service; and then started having their own version of The Last Night, complete with flag waving (Danish ones) at Copenhagen City Hall (I believe).

An embarrassment? The only embarrassments are that we don’t agree what it is to be British, and we treat each other very shabbily.

Posted by Alan Robinson | 21.07.08, 08:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Columnist Comments

adrian_hamilton

Adrian Hamilton: Old approach for new politics

Moscow has changed the rules of geopolitics and destroyed the post Cold War era of calm

janet_street_porter

Janet Street-Porter: No fake police

Has the Home Secretary increased the number of police on our streets?

john_walsh

John Walsh: Cut with Gordon's sharp tongue, a protégé escapes hell's kitchen

Marcus Wareing eclipses his former mentor and boss, Gordon Ramsay


Most popular in Opinion