Simon Carr: A Dracula-lite turn that is only a little bit frightening
The Sketch: Rule 1... give your most obvious supporters a damned good thrashing
Tuesday, 30 September 2008
Pale, grave and romantic, George Osborne presented himself to his conference like the Barbie version of Count Dracula. Just the ticket, as it turned out. In these difficult times you need to be able to frighten people a bit.
He followed two Labour-in-Opposition rules from the 1990s. Rule 1) Give your most obvious supporters a damned good thrashing.
So, Blair dealt with the unions and Osbo with the bankers. "You helped cause this mess and you can help pay to clear it up." Gordon hasn't dared say anything so satisfying.
"I will not increase taxes on the family earning £20,000 to carry on paying the bonuses of the banker earning £2m." Gordon hasn't said that either. He doesn't like bankers enough to be nasty to them.
But how will the Tories pay for it all? It is absolutely essential they don't say because to do so would infringe rule 2. Opposition Rule 2): present as small as target as possible. A plan presents a big target. Something to have bits torn off it.
No, a plan can be as vague as you like. The important thing to do is to nail Gordon's reputation to his history. And that Osbo did, pale and grave, and armed with a number of sitcom zingers. Sneer very nearly under control, voice just about managing (how he would benefit from a lower register), he produced half-a-dozen shafts, including the conference favourite: "Mr Brown,when it comes to leading and listening and understanding – you know I believe in apprenticeships – but this is no time for a novice." It's funny because it's true.
He pulled it off, in short. He was old enough to be Chancellor (about 200,000 years, if the draculine theory is true). He diagnosed the situation with enough clarity and brutality to cause a frisson in his audience. "It's over. It's finished. The cupboard is bare. There is no more money." That's plain speaking that people like. And then those ... things. The Office of Budget Responsibility. The council tax freeze.
It's enough. They need to keep a presence just off-stage. Why? Because Gordon is about to be sentenced in the Court of Poetic Justice to a most terrible punishment.
He made his name for competence and prudence by denouncing the Tory Exchange Rate Mechanism debacle. But now he's going to suffer an ERM loss once a month for a year. He's doing the same thing as Lamont did, but on a massively larger scale. He's trying to shore up over-valued commodities that the market is determined to drive down.
History doesn't repeat itself, "but it rhymes", as someone said. That's what makes this so poetic.
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited





"Whatever has Gordon Brown done to you?" asks Valerie.
Well I know what he does to me: he was there on the 18:30 ITN News tonight as lugubrious as ever mouthing off about "taking the right decisions". The man's like an old 78rpm disc: cracked and repetitive.
But the real problem is that he has let down all the people he promised to help: kids and pensioners, for starters, mainly because his policies are so darned complex that they need shed loads of bureaucrats to implement them, and an army of people conversant with the forms to help claimants actually fill them in.
It never seems to have occurred to 'Calamity' Brown that one route to encouraging people to turn up for work would be a tax allowance based on a living wage: somewhere around the £10k mark, and indexed to inflation.
Mind you, I can't say I'm relishing the prospect of a Cameron Govt, last night Dispatches dispelled any lingering doubts on that score!
Posted by Tom MacFarlane | 30.09.08, 20:40 GMT
Is Simon Carr a fully paid up member of the Tory party? It certainly seems so. I expect the Independent political sketch writer to be just that but every article he writes descends into an endless rant about Gordan Brown. Why not have a pop at the Tories for a change Simon. Whatever has Gordon Brown done to you?
Posted by Valerie | 30.09.08, 16:17 GMT
can someone tell me point of this tory conference? about time the media asked them some tough questions cos am getting bored.
Posted by kaysika | 30.09.08, 13:54 GMT
His sound alike has got to be Piers Fletcher-Dervish,
B'Stard's sidekick in the ITV sitcom "The New Statesman". In the series Fletcher-Dervish was also tipped to become the next Chancellor of the Exchequer!
Please NO!!!
Posted by Alec T | 30.09.08, 13:20 GMT
Come off it Osborne, as last night's Channel 4 program showed Camoron and Osborne are funded by the very people that they are condemning. Any dodgy City dealer is welcome at the court of King David providing it's cash up front. As for Lord Ashcroft, Camoron will not give a straight answer to two questions. Is Lord Ashcroft a permanent UK resident and does he pay Tax in the UK? Rumour has it that Dave asked him this once and was told to Mind your own F***ing business. Dave allegedly took this as a yes.
Please could a TV presenter ask Dave Cameron for a straight answer on this one.
Posted by Bill Basing | 30.09.08, 10:07 GMT