Terence Blacker: Sound and fury in the wake of this financial crisis
Friday, 3 October 2008
A picture redolent of past brutalities has appeared in some newspapers. A middle-aged man, looking shamefaced and frightened, is being escorted by another man down a street. His hands are tied behind his back and around his neck is a large placard, bearing the hand-written words, "THIEF. I stole £845. Am on my way to Police Station."
The scene took place in Witham in Essex. The alleged thief was a man called Mark Gilbert who, according to his boss Simon Cremer, the other man in the picture, had made a business cheque out to himself and cashed it. Cremer and three other colleagues tied Gilbert's hands, made him read and repeat out loud the words they had written on the placard, and then bundled him into van. In the middle of the town, he was taken out and walked to the police station. Gilbert was relieved to get there, he said later. He had thought he was about to be killed.
Suddenly the echoes of more barbaric times are all around us. They are not just in scenes of mob brutality, the public suicides, but are evident in smaller incidents of vigilantism like that which befell Mark Gilbert.
Violence of opinion flares up in the most unlikely places. Commenting on recent developments in the City, Sir Max Hastings, the respectable historian and former editor of The Daily Telegraph, wrote this week: "Delicious as it would be to see some bankers swinging gently in the autumn breeze from lampposts outside their offices, we cannot afford that indulgence."
It is a joke, presumably, but, like the "THIEF" placard, it speaks of a new kind of spiritual ugliness – a rage that, as the grip of financial anxiety tightens, may well become part of everyday life, rather as it did in the post-Crash 1930s.
One reason for the trend is to be found between the lines of Sir Max's fantasy about stringing up bankers. Here is a man of the right, or at least a one-nation Tory, attacking the dashing outriders of the free market with all the bitter rage of an old Trot. Resentful that bankers and hedge fund managers are not required to face up to their misjudgements, he – and indeed the whole Conservative Party – are playing the same game themselves. Absurdly, the very people who would normally be the most ardent champions of enterprise now go all pale and serious as they make pious speeches about public responsibility. They praise Thatcher's economic revolution and then, at the same conference, express prim disapproval of those trying to live the Thatcherite dream today.
But no one apparently is to blame for what is happening – not the Tories, nor our business-loving government. City spivs may have to endure a bit of finger-wagging but the idea that any senior director might actually take responsibility, apologise and resign in shame is a joke in poor taste.
On the radio and on TV, economic journalists, led by the increasingly self-excited Robert Peston, reveal that these problems have been within the system for years. Strangely none of these people were quite so wise during the days of quick-buck profit-making but that, again, is hardly worth mentioning. It was not their fault either.
Forget that old cliché, the "blame culture". We are witnessing, in public life, in business and in the media, the arrival of the no-blame culture. However badly things go wrong, whatever the pain they cause to the poor or vulnerable, they are simply the way things are. No wonder there is that whiff of dangerous rage in the air.
What is it about Astley that makes folk so ghastly?
There are not many contemporary stars who, within the same month, appear at the Northampton Balloon Festival and are then short-listed for the Best Act Ever category at MTV's Europe Music Awards. This achievement, by the great 1980s star Rick "Never Gonna Give You Up" Astley, has been widely presented as a joke perpetrated by pop pranksters who have over-dosed on irony pills.
Quite why it has been decided that Astley deserves to be mocked is a mystery. Earlier this year, he was the focus of an internet craze known as "rickrolling". Then there were incidents of "flashmobbing" – hundreds of people turning out in Rick Astley masks – at Liverpool Station during the rush hour. A song by Nick Lowe once actually rhymed "Astley" with "ghastly".
But in fact, given the level of the opposition at the MTV awards – the other nominees are Britney Spears, Green Day, Christina Aguilera, Tokio Hotel and the veteran rockers U2 – Astley deserves to win. Pop music has a habit of turning its clowns into heroes – think of Abba and The Carpenters. If enough of us vote for him on the MTV Europe Music Awards website, Rick's balloon festival days could soon be over.
Not tonight, dear, I've got a headache...
That august body, the Italian Society for the Study of Migraines, has announced serious news for adulterers. Cheating on your partner can lead to psychological stress which, for some migraine sufferers, could well bring on a fatal cerebral aneurysm.
Fifteen per cent of Britons, many of whom will surely have played away from home on occasion, suffer from migraines. This is black propaganda of the most irresponsible kind.
For thousands of people, it is precisely to escape from the pressures of marriage that they have a glorious stress-busting affair. The Italian busybodies should now study how many people the psychological pressures of marriage are likely to kill.
Three cheers for this stylish scam artist
Harsh words have been used to describe the recent activities of Shahra Marsh – or Shahra Christina Sylvia March de Sevigny, as she preferred to be called. While living on benefits, she passed herself off as a high-living toff, deploying her fluent French, knowledge of the market and acting skills to relieve auction houses of £2m worth of merchandise.
She did not, as has been claimed, betray their trust but merely exploited their in-built snobbery. The adventures of this stylish and clever woman deserve to be celebrated in an amusing, forgiving TV documentary.
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited





For the sake of a measly £845 he was "tortured" by four other men, before they took him to the Police station. He was not a violent criminal, yet some would support the actions of vigilantes. What should we then do to the financiers who have "stolen" billions from the country, and put millions of people's pensions and homes at risk? When this whole financial storm has subsided, it will still be the rich elite who have escaped any kind of suffering, and the rest of us will have to fight for scraps.
Posted by AndyUK | 03.10.08, 16:12 GMT
runesmith, i dont think the housing market has collapsed due to speculative overbuilding but because of a lack of credit in the market place, i would have let that go ,had you actually read what i had written, however. at no point do i by implication or by word suggest that overpopulation is a result of eastern europeans or any migrants from europe ,asia or bolivia.
your implication seems to be i am either a rascist or if my assessment is correct it has no validity because the migrants are British.
Your arrogance is the very reason that mob rule may be appearing on your doorstep soon.
Posted by unhappy jon | 03.10.08, 13:40 GMT
Anyone who really believes that "we cannot get housing because the country is so overpopulated" is so far away from reality that it is not worth trying to shout across.
We have a massive surplus of housing due to speculative building - this is one reason prices had no basis and have collapsed. The only shortage is in the Home Counties, which are not overpopulated with Eastern Europeans (or whoever is the current scare-immigrant) but with economic migrants from the rest of England.
Posted by Runesmith | 03.10.08, 13:32 GMT
You are right to be worried about the mob, but you ascribe it to the wrong cause. This action being taken by the citizenry is because they do not trust the state to look after them any more. Whilst most of your commentators live in the leafy home counties or london they may not be aware of the feelings of the majority of English people who live outside your liberal coterie. ( thats right i dont agree with you and yet i know what coterie means). The state has neglected us in favour of the scots and the welsh who we subsidise, we cannot get housing because the country is so overpopulated and if a crime is committed the police are so busy with clean up rates if its not easily solvable your wasting your time.
It is worrying becasue its a small step from this kind of action to supporting a reactionary government, BNP anyone?
So Liberals i ask you what are YOU going to do about it cos you cant dismiss it or condemn it and then ignore it.
Posted by unhappy jon | 03.10.08, 12:38 GMT
When you have government that shows it is really OK to go and wipe out millions of hitherto innocent victims and occupy their land for years, in an illegal war it is an example that brings out the worst in everyone.
Re pop:Pop music has a habit of turning its clowns into heroes
Yes look at the untouchable Kylie since she had cancer. It is cynical beyond belief. A mediocre nobody before now cannot even be critiqued rationally.Clown to Heroine in one small lump
Posted by Duncan MacGregor | 03.10.08, 12:29 GMT
bring back chari vari!
Posted by Peter | 03.10.08, 10:52 GMT
Anyone really keen on Max Hasting's fantasy should study the French Revolution. They will love it as the citadel of hate, the
symbol of all sin, is stormed and burnt down. They will cheer as aristocrats and "Fat Cats" walk up the steps and lay their heads on the block. They will be in extasy as the guillotine falls and heads roll to be paraded around the square for all to see. It gets even better as the political leaders then fall beneath the same retributive instrument - as Charles Dickens described it.
If we want society to change, trust the French!
Posted by peterfieldman | 03.10.08, 10:14 GMT
I hope these Essex vigilantes were arrested and charged (false imprisonment?).
The mob always thinks it has a right top do stuff like this - behave as judge/jury/executioner - against whoever they choose - paedophiles (alleged), paedeatricians, those who are different, those they don't like. This should never be allowed.
This is not the Wild West - and some Essex boys getting revenge and terrfiying people may have been allowed in the East End but it is essentially the barbaric behaviour of those who know no better. If someone breaks the law, you call the police. End of. A man has recently been killed for sticking his nose into a violent argument and trying to be a hero.
Could the members of this Essex boy mob say, hand on heart, that they're never stolen anything? Ever? NO? Mever broken any law? OK. Oh they have? - so let's put them in the stocks or tar or feather them!
The law exists to protect people from themselves. It should be enforced.
Posted by Nimble | 03.10.08, 08:08 GMT
"Suddenly the echoes of more barbaric times are all around us. They are not just in scenes of mob brutality, the public suicides, but are evident in smaller incidents of vigilantism like that which befell Mark Gilbert."
Are you on crack? He was arrested and taken to a police station. It may be a novel concept for you but, in the dim and distant past, we used to do that to criminals.
'Citizens' used to be RESPONSIBLE for the community not subordinate to the latest government social engineering fad.
Posted by Paul Waudby | 03.10.08, 07:49 GMT