Commentators

null 0° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Yasmin Alibhai-Brown: A lament for the death of the left as a political force

Most depressing is the sight of black and Asian Britons following the wind blowing Tories to victory

Monday, 2 June 2008

"The best champagne and the best people" I was told, celebrated the launch of Standpoint, a magazine aiming to "celebrate Western civilisation", to reassert its dominance, shaken up by the effrontery of 9/11. It is edited by Daniel Johnson, son of Paul Johnson, the leftie who turned rabid right. His other son Luke, a libertarian, presides over Channel4 as chairman. Enthusiastic guests included Sir Tom Stoppard, Sir Vidia Naipaul, Frank Field and Nasir Ali, Bishop of Rochester, who appears to want to compel us all to join his church.

The sun now rises on the right and those of us on the other side are left despondent as we anticipate a prolonged winter of discontent. We, who believe in fairness, equality, human rights and universal justice, are of no consequence. The fever of failure consumes our hopes and there is no relief as we witness the collapse of the British Left and the ideals that defined post-war advancement in this country, turning an obstinately class-riven, imperial nation into a model of progressive politics.

Local election results show the country lurching right, in some parts even embracing the BNP. Instead of condemning the scum, Britons are instructed to "understand" why these voters are "driven" to vote for neo-Nazis. We are simultaneously warned to show no such understanding of young Muslims who are seduced by hate-filled Imams. White resentment of "foreigners" is no more respectable than Muslim hatred of Westerners. Yet in our unequal world it is.

The coup was complete when Boris took over our London, world city, colourful home of mavericks, revolutionaries and monarchs, radicals and cultural conformists, money makers and penniless refugees, the hopeless and hopeful. And so power inexorably shifts towards authoritarianism, new imperial arrogance and design (bafflingly known as "liberal intervention"), fundamentalist Christian revivalism, enforced assimilation ("You WILL love and only ever praise this country"), racism and cultural protectionism, Anglo-Saxon privilege and unregulated capitalism which creates both appalling levels of wealth and poverty. The media serves the new master class and credo, with some notable exceptions.

How did we get here? Are right-wing ideas and policies irresistible to the British public (always more conservative than most European partners) and is this a return to the natural state of this nation? Or do we blame the wretched cowardice of the Left, which took power by surrendering its body and soul? Labour elected Tony Blair as leader knowing he was never a socialist; he continued Thatcherism, only with the zeal and underlying self-doubt of someone who felt trapped in political disguise. She stood as an equal to Reagan; Blair was a supplicant to Bush.

Meanwhile, Gordon Brown is too scared to be the authentic leftie he was believed to be and instead flaps around, allies himself with preposterously extreme measures, so extreme that Cameron, can, with easy conscience oppose them.

Banging up suspect terrorists for forty two days in detention without charge is exactly that kind of Big Boy gesture that reveals wobbly conviction, shaky commitment to those principles that make this nation a free and great democracy.

Almost more depressing is the sight of black and Asian Britons following the wind blowing the Tories to victory. Boris has recruited Afro Caribbean "leaders" who believe in physical chastisement and smart young Asians who deny the existence of racism and want an end to political correctness. The more old-fashioned Uncle Toms and their female equivalents are now expediently making themselves known to the Tories and right-wing think tanks.

For reasons I have yet to fathom, two weeks ago, I was invited to address a meeting at the House of Lords organised by the Conservative Muslim Forum. The room was full and the discussion on Muslim women lively. Many there were previously New Labour acolytes; others were young and ambitious and now devoted to the charismatic Cameron. To see such enthusiasm for a party whose members have always opposed our presence on these shores was a wake-up slap. All over now. The right has crushed the left.

By the time our time comes around again, I will be pushing up the daisies or dancing half naked in some home for sufferers of senile dementia, a blessing perhaps, to be lost in irreversible lunacy and never again to care about what happens to politics. Still, between now and then there will be plenty to moan about.

y.alibhai-brown@independent.co.uk

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

232 Comments

There's a great common sense article in my own Irish Independent yesterday (05/06), thankfully stating an opinion that is pretty much commonplace when European heritage folks talk in private (and increasingly in public) these days:

No need to read it all unless you want to, here's the telling, penultimate paragraph:

"Ruairi Quinn got it spot on when he said: "If people want to come into a western society that is Christian and secular, they need to conform to the rules and regulations of that country ... Nobody is formally asking them to come here. In the interests of integration and assimilation, they should embrace our culture."

Quite.

Posted by Kevin | 06.06.08, 01:39 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Kaspar,

You are right, the BNP opposed the war in Iraq for what it stood for - an aggressive attempt to preserve access to dwindling oil resources. I believe on their website they have coherent & reasoned arguments supporting their opposition; also, they have well argued articles on Peak Oil and how the world will cope with dwindling energy resources - the problem is partially one of access, in that there are reserves but for geographical or political reasons, these will be increasingly difficult to extract. The BNP appear to stand for self-sufficiency which is natural territory for a farmer like myself (albeit one in supplementary full-time employment). Neither they nor I appear to be driven by financial greed, which so unfortunately afflicts Labour (cash for honours, cash for anything, really) or the Conservatives (MPs / MEP's raking in expenses and allowances). I have what I have gainfully earned, I don't want more, if more comes my way I will be thankful.

And I'm not scum.

Posted by Kevin | 06.06.08, 01:23 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

It's too easy to laugh at this stuff. But what is interesting is how the Left has been hijacked. Not lost. Yasmin wouldn't know a Socialist if she found one in her champagne.

When I was a kid, the Left in Britain had a history that could be respected. There were individuals who really, truly believed in the betterment of society...and in particular the less fortunate.

Sadly, Yasmin is a typical example of the type of pseudo Left winger who knows a good thing when she sees it. Like George Galloway, she has the wit to realise that she has limited talent and charisma; therefore the only way forward is to carve out a niche.

George has had to resort to pleading with immigrants for his constituency. While Yasmin apparently also appeals to a desperate niche: the simple racist.

Yasmin is not Left wing. Yasmin is simply an opportunist who would say anything just so people will listen to her. But she and her ilk have been rumbled.

This is why her rants are becoming more desperate.

Posted by joe | 05.06.08, 21:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

I’ve not had a chance to read Yaz’s latest offering until now. The last two were rather disappointing, and I must admit I feared that she had gone off the boil. But, no – this shows that she is back on form. Possibly not quite a classic, but plenty of entertainment to be had. I’d score this at about 8 Yasmins. She does well in all the principal assessment categories. For example:

- Egotism: The use of “we” to mean right-thinking people like Yaz. Dreadful writing, but very funny.
- Disorganised thinking: The election of Boris Johnson described as the completion of a “coup”. She shouldn’t use words she doesn’t understand.
- Name-calling: “Uncle Toms and their female equivalents” deserves special mention.
- Unintended comedy: From start to finish.

Yaz is to political commentary what William McGonagall was to serious poetry. Thankfully, she is similarly oblivious to just how funny her writing is.

Posted by PMR | 05.06.08, 19:09 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

"We, who believe in fairness, equality, human rights and universal justice."

During the 4 June 2006 edition of Dateline London, Yasmin, Gavin Essler put this question to you:

"What's wrong with white guys?"

You replied:

"I DON'T LIKE THEM. I WANT THEM TO BE THE LOST SPECIES IN 100 YEARS!"

In this article, you say this:

"Instead of condemning the SCUM, Britons are instructed to 'understand' why these voters are 'driven' to vote for neo-Nazis."

Thus, Yasmin, 36 six years after we gave you sanctuary, you equate the British voter (who doesn't buy into your genocidal notion of universal sisterhood) with SCUM! You continue:

"We are simultaneously warned to show no such understanding of young Muslims seduced by hate-filled Imams. White resentment of 'foreigners' is no more respectable than Muslim hatred of Westerners."

So, voting for the BNP is "no more respectable" than blowing up 52 Londoners or wanting white men gone, eh Yasmin?

For real SCUM - the iamanenglishman web site.

Posted by Jack Black | 05.06.08, 18:04 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

hahaha, thanks Craig. You just made my point for me. Agression doesn't just mean violence you know. Your words are full of aggression and hate. I hope you live a long and healthy life so that you will see that your sick vision of a fascist state in Britain will never become a reality. Sorry but people like me are not just going to leave and let you have your way. Was that your idea of fun as a child? Bullying all of the other children til they left you in the playground all alone? you crack me up!!!

Posted by John Newport | 05.06.08, 16:53 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Agression, what agression? The BNP are not fascist, and I challenge you to either prove your point, or be quiet. Spineless
people like you simply don't deserve a free country, and with all
this sycophantic behaviour towards anyone foreign, and your
appeasement towards certain sections of that community, it won't be long before you haven't got one! Unfortunately, there are those of us that don't want to lose that hard fought for freedom provided by the men and women of our armed forces during WW2.
Still, you can bellyache all you like, every day the nationalist movement grows stronger, as more and more people see through the lies and smears of those like this rotten journalist. So you'd better make your mind up where you want to go, because we will take back what is ours and change the system to suit the indigenous folk of these islands.

Posted by Craig Pond | 05.06.08, 16:17 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Good lord Joe! You'll be telling the poor child that Santa Claus, the Easter Bunny and Bilbo Baggins don't exist next! How could you?

Posted by Kaspar | 05.06.08, 16:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Craig Pond,
Try channeling that agression into something useful. Find a hobby because you're wasting your time with what you call "politics". I was not comparing the BNP to fascists. I was saying that the BNP ARE fascists. It is a sad thing that you cannot see that but fortunately most people can which is why they will never be the government of this country. You've got to feel sorry for the Liberal Democrats because its people like you provide the best argument against proportional representation.

Yours,

An Idiot

Posted by John Newport | 05.06.08, 15:15 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Not all white people are racists. Not all immigrants are parasites. Not all nationalists are Nazis. Not all immigrants are 'of the Left'.

I just thought I'd clear that up for you Yasmin.

The true test of multiculturalism is really whether, in real life, it works. I have met a cross section of immigrants and they don't fall into neat stereotypes.

Some are parasitical pests, feeding on the tolerance of well meaning people. Some are criminal low life, who have been stealing, raping and murdering in a previous hell hole of their own making.

Others are good, honest hard-working, law abiding citizens who just want to join in and get along. They are grateful for a new chance and cannot under any terms be thought of as parasites.

I know and have tought plenty of Asian kids who are the salt of the Earth. I also have had the misfortune to come across Asian gangs who are, to put it mildly, a danger to society. To simplify life in the way that you do is not only dangerous it is childish.

Posted by joe | 05.06.08, 14:38 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

232 Comments

Columnist Comments

deborah_orr

Deborah Orr: One more inquiry isn't going to help

I don't believe a public inquiry into the Baby P case is necessary

hamish_mcrae

Hamish McRae: It will take time, but we'll recover

If officialdom seems over-optimistic in its forecasts, the markets seem too pessimistic

janet_street_porter

Janet Street-Porter: Mother does not always know best

One of the most sensitive subjects for writers is the mother-daughter relationship

mark_steel

Mark Steel: Never mind the baby, just get back to work

The next thing will be an exciting new scheme known as the 'workhouse'