Yasmin Alibhai-Brown: No welcome – now the Turks don't even want to join Europe
Europe had the chance to end the chasm between Islam and the West. It chose to be bigoted
Monday, 4 August 2008
Just back from Dalyan in Turkey, a place of such natural beauty and human kindness you almost cry with relief and released joy. A lush river full of fat turtles and thin, dancing water snakes runs through the smallish town (only a hamlet when we last stopped over 15 years ago), making its way to the Aegean/Mediterranean seas, warm and playful. Although tourism is changing the nature of Dalyan, nobody hassles you and you don't begrudge the inhabitants the economic surge delivered by delighted visitors.
Our compatriots behaved with such courtesy, it made us proud to be British. Most were non-Metropolitan, involved in building, making and selling awnings and blinds, engineering, farming and so on. A few were in public service. Several came back every year because, they said, the people were even warmer than the summer sun. No moody novelists or sulky media types were spotted. At a local fish restaurant (sea bass and bream for £4 with real chips and the sharpest rocket leaves in the world) sat a tipsy, buxom northern English blonde in a red polka-dotted dress. Oh, she loved this place, she said, most of all the Turkish Tommy Cooper in the café, who told bad jokes in his fez.
This goodwill only helped to emphasize the criminal failures of the EU political classes, who have betrayed their own post-war ideals. Western Europe promised to confront its heart of darkness after the war and Holocaust. Zero tolerance against anti-Semitism was the ransom that had to be paid and was, rightly and properly. But other racisms have been allowed to grow and ancient enmities reawakened. Fresh hate victims have been found to fill the continent's gaping pits.
Black migrants are treated like vermin, including in those EU countries known for easy charm; Muslims have had to accept institutionalised prejudice and Turkey has been treated as an abject and alien supplicant who must be kept that way. An essentialist, Christian definition of Europe has been settled upon, arguably one of the most self destructive of EU ideologies.
Sarkozy says: "Europe must give itself borders ... beginning with Turkey which has no place in the EU." Merkel and others in the enlarged club are even more phobic and Britain's honourable opposition to such a view has no effect. Patiently waiting to be admitted since 1987, the Turks are no longer asking. Never have I met so many young graduates and older secularists so violently opposed to joining the Union.
They believe a new power bloc of India and some of the more enlightened Muslim states offers them better prospects. In 2002, 70 per cent wanted to go in; in 2006 the figure had gone down to 35 per cent. Today I would guess enthusiasm has dropped to single figures. The Turkish journalist Farina Ahaeuser astutely observes that by keeping Turkey on the edge ( and on edge) relations with Europe "have certainly hit rock bottom".
This is appalling news for both sides. The EU has admirably democratized nations previously under authoritarianism. Turkey's ruling Islamicist AKP party has shown better governance because it wanted to impress Europe. The death penalty was abolished, human and minority rights were finally getting somewhere and the PM, Recep Tayyip Erdogan, agreed to abolish the abominable Article 301 that makes it unlawful to "insult the Turkish nation". He has reneged on this commitment.
The latest, failed attempt by the Turkish Constitutional court to undemocratically close down the AKP is another sign that the country is abandoning EU principles of politics and justice. Islamicisation is creeping in. Almost all the wives of government ministers are hijabed and "pious" homemakers. It frightens modern Turkish women who have had equal rights for longer than we have in the UK. I used to love meeting these sisters who were as deeply religious as I am but also strong secularists. These days they are depressed and angry.
Europe had the chance to end the ideological chasm between hardline Islam and the west by embracing its Christian and Muslim heritages, to heal the world. It has chosen instead to be injudicious, obtuse and bigoted. Even George Bush understands how dumb this is.
At a bar in Dalyan, the owner, a handsome man with green eyes said some mosque elders would soon close up and come over for a glass of rose wine: "Our God is inside. We are not crazy like those Saudis. We are both west and east. But these people in Brussels don't understand us and I am afraid they will push us away too far and then who knows what will happen? Only Allah knows."
-
Print Article
-
Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2008 Independent News and Media Limited





Comments
133 Comments
just cry baby cry!!!!!!
Posted by bobi | 10.08.08, 17:37 GMT
Dear lalit bagai,
According to your prognosis humanity should adopt a religion solely on the basis of the prevailing attitude of the masses. Henceforth Muslims in general should renegade their belief due its unfortunate association to terrorism, misogyny and general backwardness. Well should our ancestors in some quarters of the world be advised to abandon Christianity as a result of genocide, oppression, slavery, plundering of third world resources while ostensibly preaching the bible by the various European empires post Spanish/Portuguese expeditions in south America?
Surely one should choose faith/no faith on the basis of empirical data not as you claim "when one sees those bombing planes, buildings and trains". Which are committed only by a minority of the adherents of Islam and their actions not based texts of their holy scriptures? Stop listening to the smear and innuendo campaign against Islam and taking propaganda like a birth control pill.
Ray,
Posted by ray | 10.08.08, 14:49 GMT
yasmin should opt out of islam.
any religion-hinduism, budhism,christianity,voodo,
would be better.
and it would stop her eternal dirge about how unfairly muslims
are being treated.
absurd when one sees them bombing planes, buildings
and trains, and being dressed so badly.
Posted by lalit bagai | 09.08.08, 00:26 GMT
that's incredible!Oooh you yasmin......Are you crazy?you made me happy.But i think,europens are really angry with you.and you are in trouble....
Posted by strzzz | 07.08.08, 18:33 GMT
T. Andre, I see your point about Australia, NZ, and I guess in some creepy karmic way, the demographic overwhelming of the UK today is inevitable. (Maybe we should have done more of the imperial-apologising thing, like the Belgians?) Still, as an Englishman I can't bear to see this happening.
And your population figures for the UK are grossly inaccurate-- those numbers come from the old 2,000 census, whilst even they underestimate the Muslim presence. (They looked only at registered mosques, not at Muslim numbers in total-- I helped with the statistical auditing!) And since 2000, the UK has had highest immigration in history, mostly from Muslim South Asia/Africa/Middle East. (Eastern European numbers much lower, and they're all returning home!)
Our country is in its death throes and soon, England will no longer be populated by Englishmen. Like I said, maybe in some karmic way, England has this horrid fate coming to it. But most of us won't accept that.
Posted by Joe | 06.08.08, 21:20 GMT
The more I read Ms Alibhai-Brown column the more I am convinced she is a anti-racist racist. ie the opposite to what she wants to be.
Posted by Frankie | 05.08.08, 23:34 GMT
And now you know why so many of us despise the EU and want Britain out of it.
Posted by Neil Murphy | 05.08.08, 23:22 GMT
I feel very sorry for Ms Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, being always on the deffensive about her Islam religion. The majority of the people of the world know that Islam is a good religion, as good as Judaism and Christiniaty and Budhism etc... and that people who advocate terrorism in the name of Islam, have no relation what so ever to do with Islam...Most of the people of the wold know and admire the contribution of Islam to our modern world: Architecture, medicine, law, astronomy, art. If Ms Yasmin is not happy living in the west (England) why does she not move and live in a Muslim country ?
Posted by Samir, a moslem living happily in tolerant Sweden... | 05.08.08, 23:18 GMT
I feel very sorry for Ms Yasmin Alibhai-Brown, being always on the deffensive about her Islam religion. The majority of the people of the world know that Islam is a good religion, as good as Judaism and Christiniaty and Budhism etc... and that people who advocate terrorism in the name of Islam, have no relation what so ever to do with Islam...Most of the people of the wold know and admire the contribution of Islam to our modern world: Architecture, medicine, law, astronomy, art. If Ms Yasmin is not happy living in the west (England) why does she not move and live in a Muslim country ?
Posted by Samir, a moslem living happily in tolerant Sweden... | 05.08.08, 23:17 GMT
As a european born long after WW II I feel slightly insulted by anyone crediting himself to audit my supposed inherent tendency to racism/xenophobia. Only because I believe - like many- that Turkey is relentlessly sliding toward islamism, I don't think I have an essentialist christian view of Europe. I just think that implementing EU law need a common cultural background which is to much an extent the same from say Lisbon to Kiev (and possibly to some élite neighborhood in Istanbul) but quite alien to the identity of a too wide and increasing part of anatolia. I don't think politically correct newspeak can prevail, nor will some debatable concept (as matching on the same footing the 'christian' and a supposed 'muslim' heritage of Europe). I think Turkey would better found a central asian federation including Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Turkmenistan and so on, a wide union of mostly secular, turkic-speaking islamic states in which Turkey would play a pivotal role.
Posted by Vittorio T. | 05.08.08, 17:48 GMT
133 Comments