Yasmin Alibhai-Brown: Those who seek justice do so in vain
Some nations – and some leaders – are beyond the reach of the law
So that's that then, is it? Gaza is done and dusted? Very satisfying, I'm sure, for the Israeli leadership and their devoted allies at the BBC. But not so fast. For the one and a half million traumatised and wounded souls in that small strip, unendurable agony goes on. The very earth they stand on burns and cracks. And I am not here indulging a writer's tendency to hyperbole or neat metaphor.
Up to 60 per cent of the best farmland in Gaza has been systematically destroyed, livestock too. Christine van Nieuwenhuyse, a director at the World Food Programme, says this deliberately blighted land "may not be exploitable again". The lemon trees and noisy chickens must have been hiding Hamas rockets. Israel is also keeping some of the remaining arable land beyond the reach of the Palestinians who own it by making it into a buffer zone. Almost all the infrastructure has been flattened too. The resulting perpetual humiliation and dependency, one assumes, is part of Israel's strategic plan.
President Obama has sent forth George Mitchell, a skilled and respected negotiator, to start dialogues that could eventually lead to a durable settlement. We must hope he can achieve the impossible. But even if he does, that alone cannot ensure the kind of peace that all the people in that region sorely need and surely deserve.
There is too much unfinished business, too much reckoning left over. Peace without equality and credible scrutiny is itself a violation of human rights, an affirmation that some nations are beyond the reach of the law. Mitchell would not have been able to achieve peace in Northern Ireland if Britain had, with impunity, bombed the Catholic areas and slaughtered civilians. Israel is today a ruthless nuclear state, with arsenals of artillery, missiles, chemical and biological weaponry. It respects no international laws and conventions (originally set up to stop Jewish persecution) and does what it pleases.
But why pick only on Israel? Western nations, including Britain, supply some of the killing machines used on children in Gaza. The US and UK have never been hauled through any independent judiciary to explain their lies spun to justify the war on Iraq, or the cluster bombs dropped on civilians, the massacres in Fallujah, the million dead and many more who are born deformed.
We may at long last learn about what happened in the run-up to the war in Blair's cabinet meetings. Many of the ministers who colluded – Hoon, Straw – or acquiesced have gone on to further great success. As have several "ethnic minority" MPs and Peers always happy to oblige. Blair has enriched himself faster than any recent British PM I know of – an indication of how low is his sense of public morality and of those who pay him for his services. All is forgiven and forgotten. He is even our most trusted Man in the Middle East – who must have known about Israel's plans in Gaza and did F all.
Henry Kissinger is in the same happy position. Instead of being tried for actively supporting Pinochet, bombing Cambodia etc etc, he became a sought after statesman, rich and famous enough to stroke the fair arms of Princess Diana. How shocked he was when, a few years ago, Jeremy Paxman interrogated him on Start the Week on his unethical foreign policies. (Paxo's finest hour in my view) and Kissinger walked out of the studio. Such men do not expect to answer such questions. They are above all that. Watch this space and George Bush Jnr will be raking in loot and obsequies. That is what power gets you – immunity and pleasures untold.
We are still basking in Obama's radiance and are heartened that he so soon announced the closure of Guantanamo Bay concentration camp. But again that cannot be the final word on the crimes committed there. The men evoked by the new American president would understand why. Thomas Jefferson's words at his own inauguration speak up clearly from the grave: "Equal and exact justice to all men ...freedom of the person under the protection of the habeas corpus and trail by juries impartially selected – these principles form the bright constellation that has gone before us".
Martin Luther King also warned: "Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice around the world." The west too often fails these truly noble ideals. What happens to those who established the camp and its methods? To the torturers and prison guards? Binyam Mohammed, a British resident is said to be close to death and may well leave in a coffin. But apparently nobody is responsible.
Only Third World and ex-Communist bastards ever get to face international condemnation and trials. If the Sri Lankan government carries on shelling Tamil civilians, it will be ( rightly) censured and held responsible by the UN and other bodies. Not so-called "leading nations" when they ignore binding conventions. Sure, a few unfortunate soldiers or policemen are forced through weak, domestic investigations to prove that rule of law is respected. They are merely sacrificial goats. People of real of power or influence in the west or Israel, or Russia, now China and India, know they will never be dragged off to The Hague.
Corrupt individuals with the kind of money that makes western politicians salivate are always safe and clean. Accountability will not come knocking at their doors. The freemasons making torture equipment and arms thrive, protected in perpetuity by official secrecy. Individuals in those hidden crypts will never stand in the dock. Peace without fairness and due process is worthless. Even in South Africa, where Mandela virtuously put reconciliation before justice, furious urban blacks still feel that the settlement on that basis was profoundly unjust because whites who cruelly administered Apartheid policies got away with it.
Millions around the world, the young in particular, will not accept that double international standards are as immutable as laws of nature. They are now connected up, sharing rage and frustration. The beneficiaries are Mugabe (a hero for many), Bin Laden, Hamas, suicide terrorist cells, violent nihilists and real anti-Semites. And so there will be no peace. The great anti-slavery judge William Mansfield said in 1768: "Fiat justitia, ruat coelum" – Let justice be done, though the skies may fall. If the powerful don't understand that, they deserve the contempt increasingly heaped on them.
y.alibhai-brown@independent.co.uk
More from Yasmin Alibhai-Brown
View all comments that have been posted about this article.
Offensive or abusive comments will be removed and your IP logged and may be used to prevent further submission. In submitting a comment to the site, you agree to be bound by the Independent Minds Terms of Service.
- Print Article
- Email Article
-
Click here for copyright permissions
Copyright 2009 Independent News and Media Limited





Comments
The crazy radical extremists who rule the palestinians refuse to stop attacking a strong country and refuse to declare a permanent peace with that country don't seem to be smart or sane enough to do that.
Not that complicated. Except for people who want to keep making excuses for the insane, irrational, self-defeating behavior of the Palestinian religious and political leaders.
And if the Palestinian powers that be want Israel to leave them alone forever, all the Palestinians have to do is end this by declaring a permanent peace with the Jewish State of Israel.
That's what anyone sane would have done by now.
But the problem is, Israel is Jewish. And the leaders of the Palestinians are crazed islamic radicals who think they are serving god by attacking the jews forever to undo the very existence of the jewish state.
So, the palestinian powers that be want to just keep attacking, now and forever, never letting this permanently end, and never giving Israel a reason to trust that they have complete security.
Hamas and the islamic terrorist groups are PRIMARILY to blame for what just happened to Gaza, not Israel.
That's pretty silly.
How many articles did you write in the last three years demanding that gaza stop firing rockets into israel. None, I bet? But Israel finally responds, so you're mad?
And if you want the palestinains to have total freedom in the west bank and gaza, urge them to declare permanent peace with israel. And then step by step Israel would keep handing power away, as long as the people who received it proved trustworthy.
The Israeli atrocities in Gaza is worse than the Nazi WWII crimes because the remorseless Israeli atrocities were committed in front of live camera whereas the German crimes came to light after WWII. Also, the West by supplying Israel the latest state of the art weapons and its unconditional support of Israel is as guilty as Israel.
Therefore, the Western and Israeli leaders MUST be tried for war crimes against innocent civilians.
http://www.wrmea.com/html/us_aid_to_isr
Gaza fired 3 years worth of rockets into Israel, so Israel attacked Gaza.
The West Bank isn't firing rockets into Israel, so Israel didn't attack the west bank.
* Huge car bomb left near school and houses branded reckless, callous and contemptible
A 300lb car bomb has been discovered close to a primary school, police said tonight.
The viable home made device was placed in the back of a black Volkswagen Bora in the Co Down village of Castlewellan, in Northern Ireland.
Incidentally, Lansky "retired" to Israel which has always been a haven for Jewish criminals including war criminals, as we know.
www.thirdworldtraveler.com/Assassination
I'll start by genuinley condemning the Hamas rocket-fire (otherwise I'll be condemned myself).
The West Bank is quiet. So is Jerusalem.
However the Israeli wall still divides comminities and cuts off Bethlehem (surrounds it).
Israeli settlements are proceeding apace. These are illegal.
Palestinians are not allowed to build or extend houses and Palestinian houses are still being demolished.
The Gaza conflict is a useful cover for more unpleasant activity by the Israeli authorities elsewhere.
Moreover, the IDF has a very long history of killing (callously targetting?) civilians.
Furthermore, the collective punishment of the civilian population of Gaza is illegal.
When Hamas talk of ending occupation, they refer to Jews in Israel. Israel is almost exactly the same size as Wales and would fit into "little" Florida eight times over, into the UK eleven times over. The 22 Arab countries in the Middle East and Africa have a land area 640 times larger than Israel. Some 15% of Israel is arable land, the rest mountains and desert. 20% of the population is Muslim and Druze, all living in freedom without oppression. Some live in million-dollar-plus homes. None of us could survive without Israeli technology (you would not be able to read this), and your medicine cabinets have at least one Israeli product. Per capita, Israel produces more Nobel prize winners.
So let us be clear. Muslems (and Hamas) stated objectives are not to destroy Israel, but all Jews.
exec-ceo: Find a job - get a life!
The bottom line is that Israel ethnically cleansed several hundred thousand Arabs in 1948 and since 1967 has been progressively stealing the West Bank (and tried to do the same with Gaza). The settlements are illegal under international law. The vicious assaults on the Palestinians as a whole are brutal and immoral not just killing but destroying lives and aspirations. I have long supported the continued existence of Israel - but it MUST be within the pre-1967 armistice line and MUST recognize and compensate the Palestinians for the loss of homes, property, livelihood and for decades of savage attacks. The most recent attacks on Gaza and before than on Lebanon have begun to undermine my support for the kind of Israel I see. Thank goodness there are increasing numbers of people - Israelis, Jews and others - who are now speaking out. As one recent writer put it - the current leaders in Israel are on the wrong side of history.
This is the typical reaction of a gangster state. To see what makes a gangster state - see my journal entry here:
http://sketchley.livejournal.com/571.ht
or here:
http://dailysketcher.blogspot.com/2
well done Yasmin, brilliant artical and the essence of the point is Justice before Peace.
called hamas.
To her there is only one side to any conflict, usually Israel,but she can also rail against the UK, US or Western Europe.
To her Jews are never killed in deliberate racist terrorist attacks, for the crime of being Jews. To her insane radical muslims did not crash planes into the twin towers killing nearly three thousand innocent civilians. According to her and her likes double standards the 9/11 terror attacks are justified. And that is why she, and her like, are the real criminals.
The irony is that were she to be foolish enough to come into contact with cancerous groups such as Hamas, she would really understand the meaning of "Palestinian resistance" and the (Hamas understanding of ) rights of women.
There is a good, moral side to this conflict which treasures human life and only takes up arms as a last resort and which does not deliberately target civilians, and that is Israel.
The cancerous growth in humanity of these vile racist, terrorist organisations such as Hamas, are the truly evil side . Simple as that.
Could it be because, however much you distort, mislead, excuse, exonerate, twist, apologise ... for one group of Muslim murderers, there remains another group of Muslim murderers in that conflict that you cannot exculpate.
It's not so easy for you to find a "guilty" side when both sides are Muslim, is it?
I don't need to look internationally for double standards. I can find it on the pages written by The Independent commentators.
Wider still is 'Apostacy; making all muslims commit to murder any muslim who changes, or stops being muslim. The combination is deadly for muslim societies that are corrupted by 'takeyya' and riven by murders, based on alleged apostacy, on tribal lines to gain power and money. These are merged in sharia that is a local based law under interpretation by the unregulated appointees (cronies) of an immam, which relies on subjective case assessment and not common law precedent, with the buying off victims and other corrupt financial practices.
The result sadly is most muslim countries are 'Failed States', save for the mineral rich areas like Saudi Arabia. There muslim rules have to be enforced by Religious Police that number more than the British Army.
The only way forward is to remove violence from islam. And allow freedom of religion. The Bible is banned in muslim countires. One reason is that muslim teaching about what the Bible says differs to what the Bible does say. Muslim authorities are afraid that average muslims would accect the Bible message of love and forgiveness and reject the violence of islam.
One way to a peaceful Middle East is for freedom of religion and rejection of violence to be agreed by all.
There are jews and christians living in arab and majority muslim countries for centuries.
During the inquisition the jews fled to northern europe and lived there in peace.
Christians in Gaza are being bombed by israel not by muslims.
Jewish rabbis in the US remember living in peace with the muslims in jerusalem..until the zionists came and started hell on earth in all surrounding countries.