Leading article: Mr Cameron road-tests the politics of responsibility

News in pictures
News in pictures
Opinion blogs

Did Hitler father a lovechild?

A big thank-you to the Daily Mail sub-editors for converting a Daily Telegraph story, which resolute...

Poll alert

We have a ComRes opinion poll in The Independent on Sunday tomorrow, shared with the Sunday Mirror. ...

Why David Cameron owes unemployed single mothers an apology

How would you describe an unemployed single mother, with moderate depression, who can't afford new s...

It is a brave politician who utters the words "personal" and "responsibility" in the same sentence, and an even braver one who, without wincing, adds "morality". But David Cameron knew exactly what he was doing in Gallowgate this week. He was careful where care was needed and bold where he meant to be bold. He also neatly avoided the trap in which John Major's "back to basics" agenda was crushed, conceding that politicians were "as likely to screw up" as anyone else. Never let it be said that politicians do not learn from others' mistakes.

From there it was relatively plain sailing into the delicate matter of good and bad, right and wrong. He did not go so far as to deny the existence of society, but he did argue that social problems were "often the consequences of the choices that people make".

The Conservative leader's decision to make Glasgow East the "broken society by-election" is a smart move in every sense. The party has not the slightest hope of victory here. It can afford to test the electoral appeal of some straight talking. It was also a stroke of luck for Mr Cameron – a politician who has been as blessed in this respect as the Prime Minister has been cursed – that this crucial by-election is taking place in the very constituency where Iain Duncan-Smith experienced his epiphany about "Breakdown Britain".

Unlikely as it might once have seemed, places like Gallowgate are now familiar territory for Cameron Conservatives. And the more benighted the estate, the more grist it provides for their policy mill. "The social breakdown you can see here," Mr Cameron told his audience, "is just an extreme version of what you can see everywhere." And "everywhere", of course, is the country that was once Blair's Britain and is now the responsibility of Gordon Brown. From there on, Mr Cameron's rallying cry writes itself: "Wasn't Labour supposed to end this degrading poverty?"

The gritty urban backdrop of Monday's speech provided the most graphic illustration to date of how successfully Mr Cameron has managed to seize the initiative on social policy from Labour. It is a feat reminiscent of the Blair-Brown coup of the Nineties that made New Labour the party of the economy and law and order. Coincidentally, much about this new Conservative agenda chimes with the increasingly grim public mood. Today's cause for agonised introspection may be knife crime, but few regard it as an isolated phenomenon. Teenagers armed with knives can be seen as a cypher for Labour's failure after more than 10 years in power.

Mr Cameron's appeal to such – recently – unfashionable themes as personal responsibility and morality will also strike a chord. After all, so much else seems to have been tried, yet social mobility has ground to a halt, the gap between poor and rich has widened and the Government is nowhere near meeting its target of halving child poverty by 2010. There is ample political space here for the Opposition to occupy. Yet the Conservatives will have to tread carefully. Mr Cameron's words were carefully crafted, but his party must be wary of sounding like new Victorians. To counter this, Mr Cameron alluded to the latest sociological fad – the theory that peer pressure can "nudge" people to behave better. The big test, of course, is whether the policies can match the salesmanship.

Mr Cameron spoke of radical plans to reform schools, improve housing, strengthen families and make state benefits more conditional on work. But it is not just, as he concedes, that such policies will come up against entrenched interests; they will have popular appeal as well. It is that coaxing the workless into work can cost more than underwriting idleness. This is where morality meets economic reality. The Conservatives may be on to something here; but they have more work to do.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

So long Sarkozy: Inside the tiny town that will topple the French president

Inside the tiny town that will topple Sarkozy

The tiny town of Donzy is France's political weathervane finds John Lichfield.
A class act: Claire Foy on criticism, tumours and embarrassing sex scenes

Claire Foy: Criticism, tumours and embarrassing sex scenes

Her luminous good looks made the actress the star of Little Dorrit and Upstairs Downstairs
A new leaf: Mark Hix sings the praises of spinach

A new leaf: Mark Hix sings the praises of spinach

Spinach is the versatile superfood that will keep you strong and healthy throughout the winter months.
Hollywood ate my novel: Novelists reveal what it’s like to have their book turned into a movie

Hollywood ate my novel

Novelists reveal what it’s like to have their book turned into a movie
How you can force companies to behave themselves

How you can force companies to behave themselves

Buying even a single share in a firm gives you the right to question its practices
Lost in the landscape: Wilderness and wildlife in Australia’s Top End

Wilderness and wildlife in Australia’s Top End

This sparsely populated region is home to creatures that are both fantastic and formidable
48 Hours: Marrakech

48 Hours: Marrakech

From the ancient medina to the Palmeraie, Morocco's Rose City offers a warm escape from the cold of winter.
Bear with Bern for Swiss skiing

Bear with Bern for Swiss skiing

Stephen Wood arrives at the gateway to the Bernese Oberland with plenty of respect for the slopes and the city's ursine inhabitants.
Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

Dawn of the age of wireless medicine

New technology means doctors will soon be able to regulate and monitor drug intake remotely – as long as patients remember to swallow their chips
Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Pete Doherty: I was a bit unhinged

Former Libertine talks frankly and exclusively about Kate Moss, Amy Winehouse, his baby daughter and why he paints with his own blood
Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10 (but Blair's still the leading earner)

Brown makes £1m since leaving No 10...

... but Blair's still the leading earner
The West Bank's Bobby Sands

The West Bank's Bobby Sands

Khader Adnan's two-month hunger strike has made him a hero among Palestinians outraged by Israel's policy of arbitrary detention
Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Hey, You've got to hide your drug away

Paul McCartney has given up smoking dope. Simon Usborne charts a career of highs and lows
The 50 Best lights

The 50 Best cheap eats

The top spots for breakfast, lunch and dinner
MI5 helped US in fruitless search for Charlie Chaplin's Communist past

Investigating Charlie Chaplin

MI5 helped US in fruitless search for star's Communist past