Leading Articles

null 0° London Hi 5°C / Lo 2°C

Leading article: Pakistan stares into the abyss

Monday, 22 September 2008

Pakistan lies at the centre of American strategic calculations about South and Central Asia. All the United States' plans regarding Iran, Iraq, Afghanistan, and the struggle against al-Qa'ida, involve Pakistan, which is why Saturday's blast in Islamabad is not only a human tragedy but a deeply troubling sign that the crisis in global security is further than ever from a resolution. That terrorists can cause such carnage in the middle of the capital of Pakistan not only makes a mockery of President Asif Zardari's claims to be getting tough on Islamic militants but raises long-term fears for the state's very survival. The fact is that terrorists have been detonating bombs with growing boldness in recent months.

About 30 people were killed earlier this month in Peshawar, while another 78 people perished in twin suicide bombings in August in the weapons factory in the town of Wah. It is only because the victims did not include Westerners and diplomats that these terrible attacks attracted such little international attention.

The factors behind Pakistan's apparent descent into a "failed state" are many. One has been the government's own ambivalence in recent years towards radical Islam at home and in neighbouring Afghanistan. Another is the constant American pressure on Islamabad to take a tougher line on the militants operating in the so-called Tribal Areas on the Afghan border. Despairing of real action on Pakistan's part, especially after the departure of their close ally Pervez Musharraf as president, the Americans have taken to launching unilateral attacks on those they believe are behind attacks on American and Nato forces in Afghanistan. However, an unintended consequence of this unilateral policy has been an upsurge in anti-Americanism in Pakistan itself, which has aided the militants in their drive to take their crusade against the US to the heart of the country.

The future of the country looks bleak. The economy is in a poor state, its failings made manifest in food riots, high unemployment and falling currency reserves. The new President looks weak, and the army disorientated. The intelligence services have been penetrated by Islamic militants. Sectarian violence is worsening, opening up the prospect of a country virtually at war with itself. The border with an even more chaotic neighbour, Afghanistan, remains porous.

The President's late wife, Benazir Bhutto, herself the victim of Pakistan's increasingly violent political culture, warned that the growing ills afflicting her country could not be addressed without an economic turnaround. With that in mind, we must hope that the Friends of Pakistan, the international forum that Mr Zardari has established, and to which Gordon Brown has lent full support, will achieve something at its first donors' conference in New York this Friday.

It may be too much to expect that a substantial injection of foreign cash into the economy can calm the waters of this deeply troubled country, but in the absence of any other solutions, it remains the only hope.

Interesting? Click here to explore further

Comments

22 Comments

 Systematic policies, PPP is very much ready for destroying the peace process, as the Business Tycoons of this Party are busy to make money. Therefore all I know Zardari & Co. at some extent try to get the Red White & Blue countries’ system, especially now with Bush & the Ambassader i.e. Ms. Peterson under suspicion. Assuarance, she`ll talk her head off with Bush & Co., thereafter Zardari, Gillani & Kiyani and then get some other promise. But the promise won`t be worth phlim spit. Because the real control of USA is existing even at the offices of above mentioned personnel.

Posted by Adnan Arshad Mansoori | 24.09.08, 13:18 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

There should be no free public money for the unreliable Pakistanis. The place is deeply corrupt, they can't be trusted and there are too many enemies of our British values and way of life there who will benefit.

The government now needs money to fight the terrorists their own military incubated? They need money but they have nuclear weapons programme? Don't make me laugh. This is Pakistan's bed and they have chosen to lie in it. Not a penny from me.

Posted by Taxpayer | 24.09.08, 08:57 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Pakistan would be better claim UAE rather than Kashmir. Atleast they will get oil reserves. UAE must be considered as part of pakistan. Root cause of current crisis is high price of oil and thus caused rapid fall in forex reserves and worsening situation in pakistan. Its economy stupid. IF situation comes where pakistan cannot buy oil then it should invade UAE to get its due share of oil

Posted by satish | 24.09.08, 06:28 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Don't want to scare you, but the abyss you are referring to is the very real possibility that if Pakistan loses control of its nuclear weapons, the USA will take whatever steps necessary to neutralize them, and if that means bombing them, even with small tactical nuclear weapons, it will happen. There's a very real possibility that the US only has loose knowledge of exactly where they are at, so the necessary destruction could be widespread and radioactive. I hope the leaders of the military and the ISI are reading this. I'm not in the government, but I know my country, and it would hesitate for a minute to prevent a nuclear explosion in its own territory. Woe be to Pakistan if it lets its greed and submission to religious leaders submerge its national self-interest. I hope business and civic leaders read this and understand Pakistan can remain harmless in appearance by looking competent to control the weapons. They have a tiger by the tail, called the Taliban. I hope this isn't true.

Posted by Ormond | 22.09.08, 23:30 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

It was heart-breaking watching the Marriott Hotel in Islamabad being bombed by terrorists. It was a time when people would be opening their fast with family and friends.

What is of concern is that a large dumper truck was allowed to roam the streets of Islamabad, a city under 'strict' security arrangements, without being noticed. This is a major lapse in security and intelligence.

The shadowy all-powerful ISI intelligence agency needs to be dismantled and a completely new intelligence structure needs to be set up.

Pakistan is sandwiched between two evils- on the one hand there are US forces and on the other hand the Taliban/Al qaeda. Pakistan is once again paying a heavy price for allying itself with the US in its so-called "war on terror"- ths was its biggest mistake- Pakistan never experienced suicide bombings prior to 9/11. It must now completely distance itself from the US as well as the Pakistani army crushing the Taliban/Al Qaeda and for US troops to leave Afganistan.

Posted by Dr Khan | 22.09.08, 22:58 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

With Pakistan needing careful thought and help from the West, today in the Wall Street Journal we see Richard Holbrooke, R. James Woolsey, Dennis B. Ross and Mark D. Wallace claiming that "even the most conservative estimates" are that Iran will soon have nuclear weapons, when there is no solid evidence Iran even has a nuclear weapons development program! Pakistan is nearing the point of possible explosion, and American foreign policy "experts" are doing their best to demonize Iran, when Iranian help is essential for even minimal stability to be achieved in Afghanistan.

Posted by James Canning | 22.09.08, 22:24 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Brits are looki9ng into an abyss and don't even know it. An abyss of your own making. You have a country full of Muslim's well on their way to taking over your country and you are making snide remarks ae in our country but you already have and will stand in tolerancewhile it replaces your own laws! You will be the minority, they the majorty and all of Europe is cutting their socialist throats!

Posted by Ruth Skidmore | 22.09.08, 20:02 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

Ashok Mehta bhai, I like your pakistan bashing. But to claim that Pakistan's main object is hating India is an exaggeration. If you care to read these comments, you cannot but conclude, that Pakistanis, main entertainment is 'Paki bashing'
The country is in a mess and these 'gentlemen' not only ignore to acknowledge what the problem is, blaming it on the current leaders. You know why? Most of them hate democracy and freedom of expressions. I wonder if you have many in India doing that. Now seriously, India is also responsible for some of the mess here. Attacking Bangladesh, forcing their will in Kashmir is not the help any weak neighbor needs. Who said: If a man is down, don't kick him. Please remember that. Have sympathy, not hate.

Posted by sharifL | 22.09.08, 17:01 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

With Mr Ten Percent in the state house, believe me. Pakistan will never do away from chaos.
Though power brokers and their masters can wrongly assure themselves that their abracadabras will work, the hoi polloi know what transpired.
To get rid of hatred in Pakistan people with probity and mission must be in power.

Zardari is worse than Musharraf and as the days go by this will be proved beyond doubts.

Posted by Nkwazi Mhango | 22.09.08, 15:58 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

With Mr Ten Percent in the state house, believe me. Pakistan will never do away from chaos.
Though power brokers and their masters can wrong assure themselves that their abracadabras will work, the hoi polloi knows what transpired.
To get rid of hatred in Pakistan people with probity and mission must be in power.

Zardari is worse than Musharraf and as the days go by this will be proved beyond doubts.

Posted by Nkwazi Mhango | 22.09.08, 15:58 GMT

Post a complaint

Please note all fields are required.

Contact details

22 Comments

Columnist Comments

deborah_orr

Deborah Orr: One more inquiry isn't going to help

I don't believe a public inquiry into the Baby P case is necessary

hamish_mcrae

Hamish McRae: It will take time, but we'll recover

If officialdom seems over-optimistic in its forecasts, the markets seem too pessimistic

janet_street_porter

Janet Street-Porter: Mother does not always know best

One of the most sensitive subjects for writers is the mother-daughter relationship

mark_steel

Mark Steel: Never mind the baby, just get back to work

The next thing will be an exciting new scheme known as the 'workhouse'