No variety leaves tourists in spin
Options, options, options. That is what captains require when Plan A has disappeared into the 17th row of the grandstand, but for the third consecutive occasion in New Zealand, England's selection policy deprived captain Paul Collingwood of any choices.
In Auckland, England overcame the handicap of picking an unbalanced side and a bowling attack lacking variety to gain their sole one-day victory of the tour. But in Napier, where they could not defend 340, and here in Christchurch, it contributed significantly to their downfall.
At the toss yesterday, it was obvious that one side had got it wrong. New Zealand selected two spinners for a series-deciding match but England chose to omit Graeme Swann and pick six seamers of varying pace and ability. The result, a comfortable four-wicket victory and a 3-1 series triumph for the Black Caps, highlights England's flawed thinking.
One-day international cricket is predominantly about batsmen scoring runs but there is no point omitting bowlers to fill the side with willow wielders. A bowler can have an enormous influence on a match, especially a good spinner, and each team should select a minimum of three pacemen for every game.
Unfortunately for England, it can hardly be said that James Anderson and Stuart Broad are models of consistency. Broad is young and inexperienced so his unpredictability should be tolerated, but Anderson, who has disappeared in all but the Auckland match and conceded almost seven-and-a-half runs per over throughout the series, is in a precarious situation.
Anderson has been playing ODI cricket for more than five years now but his career does not seem to be going anywhere. There have been times when the 25-year-old has been exceptional and his record, overall, is very respectable. But with 86 games and 121 wickets to his name, he should be leading England's attack rather than looking like a novice.
He seems incapable or unprepared to bowl six consecutive balls on the same spot. Patience is not one of his virtues. From the outside, it seems he chooses to go in search of wickets rather than wait for them to come through miserly bowling.
Bouncers, attempted yorkers, slower balls; in every over Anderson seems to want to go through his whole repertoire. Very few, if any, bowlers can control such variation, and Anderson's approach is not helping his cause.
With his form and confidence low, England had to pick a fourth specialist bowler, and it should have been Swann. Selecting him would have been at the expense of Dimitri Mascarenhas or Luke Wright. That would weaken England's batting, but good teams do not look to No 7 and No8 to get them out of trouble – they provide the icing; it is the responsibility of Nos 1 to 6 to produce a cake with substance.
The problem for England is they do not appear to rate Swann. England's off-spinner had an excellent one-day tour of Sri Lanka last October but his stock has fallen. The size and peculiar shape of a couple of grounds here has influenced England's decision-making but they do not seem to have affected the contributions of Daniel Vettori and Jeetan Patel.
Vettori is the joint top wicket-taker in the series and Patel conceded 3.2 runs per over in the two games he played. England's batsmen came to terms with Vettori just once – in Napier – and his left-arm spin had a huge influence.
The return to fitness of Andrew Flintoff would make a huge difference, as would Monty Panesar developing some of Vettori's dexterity. But if neither makes the progress every England fan wants, the wait for England to become a major force will continue.
Monaco is a street circuit where driver ability is more important than anywhere else and if we take ...
by Gareth Purnell
24 May 2013 02:00 AM
Three weeks ago as I drove off the Eurostar, I remember thinking what a very long time it was until ...
by Martin Ayres
23 May 2013 05:29 PM
McDowell did brilliantly to land the World Match Play title in Bulgaria last week, but it’s a format...
by Gareth Purnell
23 May 2013 09:13 AM
David Moyes delighted after Rio Ferdinand agrees to stay at Manchester United with new one-year contract
Sergio Garcia / Tiger Woods 'fried chicken' racism row takes fresh twist after 'coloured athletes' comment
After racist remark, Sergio Garcia fights for reputation as Tiger Woods slams 'hurtful' fried chicken joke
Manuel Pellegrini must deliver five trophies in five years at Manchester City says chief executive Ferran Soriano
Major refinancing sees Manchester United slash interest bill by £10m a year
- 1 Pope Francis: Being an atheist is alright as long as you do good
- 2 'He was always smiling': Lee Rigby named as Woolwich victim
- 3 'Something passed underneath us, quite close': Airbus A320 has close encounter with UFO
- 4 Lord of the Sings: Sir Christopher Lee, 91, to release heavy metal album
- 5 Two bailed after arrest over Woolwich attack Twitter comments
BMF is the UK’s biggest and best loved outdoor fitness classes
Find out what The Independent's resident travel expert has to say about one of the most beautiful small cities in the world
Nook is donating eReaders to volunteers at high-need schools and participating in exclusive events throughout the campaign.
Get the latest on The Evening Standard's campaign to get London's children reading.
Win anything from gadgets to five-star holidays on our competitions and offers page.