Robin Scott-Elliot: A brave new world for cricket must take county game outside existing boundaries

Next summer, 2012, will be much tougher, with cricket floored by the combined sportingclout of the European Championship and the London Olympics

Suggested Topics

Spring is in the air, the sun is out, Alastair Cook has finished lambing and is back playing cricket. There is a spring in the step of cricketers up and down the country as whites are dusted down and that back-foot cover drive in front of the mirror takes on more urgency. Back, across, boof; and a wave of the bat to acknowledge applause for that previously elusive century.

English cricket begins the season on an Ashes-induced high but there is never a fanfare to the start of a new domestic campaign. A week ago Cook, the well-scrubbed poster boy of the English game, began his domestic campaign at Fenner's, opening the batting for Essex against the students of Cambridge watched by one man because the dog had stayed home to watch the World Cup final. That day, some x-hundred miles away, Mahendra Singh Dhoni confirmed himself as the poster boy of Indian cricket, thundering the six that was heard around the world. India, it declared, is cricket, and cricket is India's.

The Indian Premier League has also returned, the closeted whispers over its future drowned out by a new wave of money flooding into the sport. When last year more than $700m (£427m) was paid out for two new franchises it was difficult not to believe that they were operating in a cricket fantasy world, reached through the back of a Mumbai wardrobe. Now the figures are all too real. Dhoni commands $2m per endorsement in the wake of capturing his country's glory.

As for the English domestic game, in which only three of the 18 first-class counties made a profit according to most recent figures, where does it go? Unlike the IPL, which exists purely for itself, the English game exists, or rather has evolved to exist, for the national side. And in return the national governing body keeps the counties, all 18 of them, in existence. But for how much longer?

There are few more depressing sporting spectacles than a trip to watch, say, Derbyshire on a damp, blustery day play in a 40-over league match, but there are plenty of other grounds to visit where there is true sporting pleasure to be found. A post-lunch sojourn in a Hove deckchair, seduced by a gentle sea breeze and serenaded by ripples of applause, is the sort of British sporting event that should be listed, along with Boxing Day football and Sir Alex Ferguson.

County cricket is a very different sport to the days when Cook's predecessors in the Essex side would use a game against a South Coast county to take an overnight ferry trip to France and be back in time to take the field for day two. It remains, though, on the fringes of any sporting radar, even if the scorecards are a reassuring presence in the papers. The fear is that, in this time of harsh economics and loosening ties with the past, it has reached the point for the game to take some harsh decisions. There are working parties and reports and delayed decisions; which only goes to suggest that the authorities and the counties themselves know there is trouble ahead.

To blame the economic downturn for the counties' current struggles is at best disingenuous. There has long been a reliance on a central handout. It is time to cut; rugby league assesses any newcomers to Super League on a number of factors, on and off the pitch. Something similar could be applied for the grisly task of dispatching a couple of counties to the minors, although there could also be a route for readmittance.

In Britain there is not the all-consuming passion for cricket, nor the vast numbers wanting to watch it that has helped India become the game's powerhouse. But that does not mean a franchise system couldn't work well for Twenty20 in this country; a spread of urban bases can easily ensure nationwide reach. Perhaps they could assume responsibility for all limited-overs cricket. Scrap the embarrassingly pointless 40-over competition and reintroduce a 50-over knockout with a showcase Lord's final.

That helps rid the game of the impenetrable mess that is the current fixture list and leaves the counties to concentrate on feeding the Test side, a role they are meeting with a notable degree of success. The County Championship is successful on the field. As executives look to Australia for models of how cricket grounds can become multi-purpose arenas, Australia are looking with a rare tinge of envy at the on-field fruits of our domestic first-class game.

For all that, this summer is forecast to be the most lucrative in the English game's history, some feat outside an Ashes year, but the money is coming from India, largely via a colossal TV deal.

Next summer will be much tougher, with cricket floored by the combined sporting clout of football's European Championship and the London Olympics. That will hit the game hard financially, and is no time to be stepping into a brave new world. And that gives the authorities the chance to prevaricate, or the chance to get it right and give birth to a new form of the English game come spring 2013.

Independent Comment
blog comments powered by Disqus
Career Services

Day In a Page

Special report: Tamil asylum-seekers to be forcibly deported

Special report

Tamil asylum-seekers to be forcibly deported
The problem with social mobility

The problem with social mobility

Politicians who say they want to break down Britain's social barriers have been told to unlock closed-shop professions – starting in their own backyard
France's sixth biggest city* goes to the polls (*that's London, by the way)

France's sixth biggest city* goes to the polls (*that's London, btw)

Next month expats in the stronghold of South Kensington will have a big say in who is returned as the first French overseas MP
Aftershock: How Haiti's quake hit the whole of Hispaniola

Aftershock: How Haiti's quake hit the whole of Hispaniola

Two years on from the disaster that shook the Caribbean state, its eastern neighbour, the Dominican Republic, fears a new wave of illegal immigrants could hurt its economy
Mean streets at the movies

Mean streets at the movies

Plan B's new film explores the urban tensions that led to last summer's riots – and he's not the only one finding cinematic inspiration in social unrest
Romney hits the magic number, but his smartphone app fails crucial spelling test

Romney hits the magic number...

... but his smartphone app fails crucial spelling test
Car-crash TV: Ferrari quits news after gaffes, rows and poor ratings

Car-crash TV: Ferrari quits news after gaffes, rows and poor ratings

Weeks after the demise of Sarkozy, the TF1 star he's said to have dated finds herself out of office too
Meet your doctor (please don't unplug it)

Meet your doctor (please don't unplug it)

Can a network of hi-tech terminals and online medics make the connection?
The 10 Best cycling gear

The 10 Best cycling gear

It’s summer, it's sunny... it’s the perfect time to get on your bike.
Song of the suicide bomber: How 'Babur in London' negotiated a cultural minefield

Song of the suicide bomber

Daring new opera 'Babur in London' features British terrorists planning an attack.
The school that brought the International Baccalaureate to the East End

Bringing the IB to the East End

The International Baccalaureate is not just for pupils in leafy suburbs.
England must beware brilliant Belgium

England must beware brilliant Belgium

They may have missed out on the Euros but the Belgians have a rash of young players who, thanks to the unifying skills of their coach, look to have a bright future
James Lawton: Liverpool must show new man the respect he needs to do the job

James Lawton

Liverpool must show new man the respect he needs to do the job
2012: the year when England's support decided to stay at home

2012: the year when England's support decided to stay at home

Three Lions will play their Euro 2012 games in front of only a few thousand of their fans
What's wrong with Rory?

What's wrong with Rory?

Is the trouble with the defending US Open champion in his head, in his swing, with his girlfriend – or is it all in the minds of others?